General Discussion

qwlauren35

(6,279 posts)

5. I have heard so many reasons.

Wed Jun 10, 2020, 11:22 AM

Jun 2020

Takes too much explaining.

Isn't accurate - reduce budget is not de-fund.

Gives GOP talking points.

Not during an election year.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

And this from our "allies". The ones who came up with "Blue Lives Matter" and "All Lives Matter" because "Black Lives Matter" didn't work for them.

Took too much explaining.
Isn't accurate - all lives matter.
Gives the GOP talking points.
Not during an election year.

Sometimes our allies don't know how to be allies. If they can't choose how to define us, they don't want to be a part of the solution.

It's like Americans standing up for France, but getting upset because their slogan is in French, and they can't understand it. And of course, the xenophobes would jump all over it because it's not in English...

Edit history

Please sign in to view edit histories.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

38 replies

= new reply since forum marked as read

Highlight:

"Defund" - such a poor choice, right? [View all] qwlauren35 Jun 2020 OP

I have a severe issue with people trying to tell black activists which words are acceptable SoonerPride Jun 2020 #1

I have heard so many reasons. qwlauren35 Jun 2020 #5

Exactly. Thank you. SoonerPride Jun 2020 #7

One Group RobinA Jun 2020 #25

The problem with "defund" is that it is a reactive term. Tommy_Carcetti Jun 2020 #2

"Rethink Police Budgets"? maxsolomon Jun 2020 #17

Not saying it has to be "rethink" Tommy_Carcetti Jun 2020 #20

It is accurate, but feels milquetoast. maxsolomon Jun 2020 #28

Yes It Does Suggest A Solution RobinA Jun 2020 #27

Well its better than "defend the police" but thats about it. milestogo Jun 2020 #3

So far "defund" has had to be explained to everyone. And if you're explaining, you're losing. Gidney N Cloyd Jun 2020 #4

Nothing is ever good enough. SoonerPride Jun 2020 #6

But if you spend too much time getting defensive about your messaging... Tommy_Carcetti Jun 2020 #9

Maybe if people would focus on the issue at hand instead of attacking word choices... SoonerPride Jun 2020 #10

Okay, I see we have a chicken and the egg thing going on here. Tommy_Carcetti Jun 2020 #15

Choosing the most effective words helps with that focus. Gidney N Cloyd Jun 2020 #16

and once again whites come to the rescue to tell blacks what messages are palatable to THEM. SoonerPride Jun 2020 #19

You again? I'm black and I think "defund the police" is the stupidest... brush Jun 2020 #29

I'm with Rep Clyburn on this one -- reform. PunkinPi Jun 2020 #8

Can't agree. qwlauren35 Jun 2020 #11

I agree with you. We have been "reforming" the police since the 60's and nothing has changed. cayugafalls Jun 2020 #21

I'm not saying defunding wouldn't occur within reform. PunkinPi Jun 2020 #26

+1 Gidney N Cloyd Jun 2020 #12

Why not "define and defend" the definition? cayugafalls Jun 2020 #13

"Defund the Police" is as poor a slogan as "Democratic Socialism" brooklynite Jun 2020 #14

Agreed 100%. It's red meat for trump to feed to voters... brush Jun 2020 #31

I'm thinking "Disband". rgbecker Jun 2020 #18

I like "abolish," myself -- I learned about police abolition from black women, and I follow their WhiskeyGrinder Jun 2020 #22

I am white and it's not my call Maeve Jun 2020 #23

You Have No Stake RobinA Jun 2020 #30

Of course I have a stake--that's not what I said Maeve Jun 2020 #37

It's a fine line between stupid and clever. Sneederbunk Jun 2020 #24

The response to this thread answers the question itself. Tommy_Carcetti Jun 2020 #32

Um... qwlauren35 Jun 2020 #33

I don't think the word "defund" is a black or white term. Tommy_Carcetti Jun 2020 #34

Too many differering interpretations to be effective Zambero Jun 2020 #35

"Defund the police" is a Russian bot wedge used across platforms right now; so yeah, wrong choice. ancianita Jun 2020 #36

I think that the fact that support hangs on a "Slogan" is sad. Caliman73 Jun 2020 #38