Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

intheflow

(28,463 posts)
28. The Constitution is not infallible.
Mon Feb 15, 2021, 10:50 AM
Feb 2021

The framers were in the midst of a war with England and created a document that

a) assumed no free man (i.e., a man free from the divine right of kings) would favor a tyrant;
b) only men of "honor" would be elected to Congress by a free electorate;
c) all the MEN making these decisions were white landowners who created a document that both protected their wealth/power/status/privilege and was flexible enough for evolving interpretation and revision.

IOW, there is no fail-safe for the majority under the Constitution when foxes are in the hen house. Literally, we are held hostage by voting cycles and we have to change procedural rules (which again, assumes only honorable people are elected to Congress).

There is also no professional penalty for lying to the detriment of the nation. Censure is toothless. It is an imperfect system created by imperfect men and it can be changed. Abolish the electoral college, and go with straight majority rule. The judicial system is designed to protect minority rights under majority rule. (In theory, though that, too, is made ineffective by racist authoritarian abusers. But that's a rant for another thread.)

So it wasn't individuals that failed us here, it's the systems we have in place. That's not to say that the 43 aren't responsible for their actions, but that their actions only succeeded because of the system.

If I were a judge on the tweet of the day I'd give it to you hands down 🙂 MLAA Feb 2021 #1
Great tweet malaise Feb 2021 #2
Message auto-removed Name removed Feb 2021 #3
This StarfishSaver Feb 2021 #5
I agree PatSeg Feb 2021 #15
Good point! BobTheSubgenius Feb 2021 #18
An excellent and all too true point! Thanks for sharing! dutch777 Feb 2021 #4
I get the point, but we'll be happy for this supermajority requirement the next time StarfishSaver Feb 2021 #6
Well, that is exactly correct PCIntern Feb 2021 #7
Lying lindsey has already threatened VP Harris. niyad Feb 2021 #8
Which I hope they will remember OldBaldy1701E Feb 2021 #26
I expect as soon as they get the chance, they'll impeach Obama, Dark n Stormy Knight Feb 2021 #32
K&R burrowowl Feb 2021 #9
Trump lost the popular vote in 2016 and 2020 and broiles Feb 2021 #10
Trump lost the popular vote in ,2016 and 2020 and broiles Feb 2021 #11
Let's not forget Tom Delay and his ambition to create a "permanent Republican majority" through..... RussellCattle Feb 2021 #12
The Constitution is not the problem, 43 cowards are. rickyhall Feb 2021 #13
Correct, ALL 43 ignored their oath of office and put themselves before country GOPistheEnemy Feb 2021 #16
I'm not sure all 43 were cowards. Poiuyt Feb 2021 #23
Thank you. They may be cowards, but that's not the explanation Dark n Stormy Knight Feb 2021 #33
The Constitution is not infallible. intheflow Feb 2021 #28
Beyond 'in the midst' xxqqqzme Feb 2021 #29
Way to pick up on a technicality! intheflow Feb 2021 #35
K&R for visibility. nt tblue37 Feb 2021 #14
The Framers thought patriots and men of property should rule bucolic_frolic Feb 2021 #17
No kidding Joinfortmill Feb 2021 #19
Never very tiptonic Feb 2021 #20
What bothers me is hearing that "Trump was acquitted by a vote of 57-43" Mr. Ected Feb 2021 #21
Agreed. It should read "43 Republicans think insurrections is OK" mdbl Feb 2021 #25
Yup, I'll tell the kids that crime pays as long as you're a Republican Blue Owl Feb 2021 #22
And it always has. (n/t) OldBaldy1701E Feb 2021 #27
Yeah, that's such BULLSHIT!!! Rt TY! Cha Feb 2021 #24
Thank you for posting the text. DeeNice Feb 2021 #30
Well, look TimeToGo Feb 2021 #31
Yep ThatJustHappened Feb 2021 #34
So no one understands why the constitution sometimes require a two-thirds or three quarters Nitram Feb 2021 #36
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»My submission for the Twe...»Reply #28