Which part of Manchin said he would not vote for her, Republicans would not cross over to vote for (Reply #44)

In the discussion thread: White House withdraws Neera Tanden nomination : Breaking [View all]

Tue Mar 2, 2021, 08:42 PM

Autumn (42,866 posts)

44. Which part of Manchin said he would not vote for her, Republicans would not cross over to vote for

her do you not understand? Bernie could have wasted his capital and voted for her and she still would not have been nominated. Senators can do math, everyone knew there were not the votes for her and it was a very long shot that any Republican would cross over. Had one done so Bernie would have voted yes, he, unlike Manchin, supports Biden's agenda.

Reply to this post

Back to OP Alert abuse Link to post in-thread

Always highlight: 10 newest replies | Replies posted after I mark a forum

Replies to this discussion thread

171 replies	Author	Time	Post
White House withdraws Neera Tanden nomination : Breaking [View all]	superpatriotman	Mar 2021	OP
Post removed	Post removed	Mar 2021	#1
Manchin was not the only one. Sanders started it with his scold and demand for apology.	LizBeth	Mar 2021	#4
Manchin lead the charge on the dem side	jorgevlorgan	Mar 2021	#7
Sanders started the charge on the Dems side at the committee hearing.	LizBeth	Mar 2021	#9
This message was self-deleted by its author	jorgevlorgan	Mar 2021	#10
it's not as though the tweets weren't going to come up at the hearing w/o Sanders mentioning them	fishwax	Mar 2021	#15
Looking over those glasses, and scolding her. Yes, he could have said any number of things to	LizBeth	Mar 2021	#18
I don't see anything wrong with him addressing the tweets	fishwax	Mar 2021	#20
Right, he was simply the victim. There was no "two sides of the story" in this scenario, for sure.	LizBeth	Mar 2021	#23
he wasn't the one intervjewing for a job	fishwax	Mar 2021	#48
Yes, I found it offensive once again as I watched that finger wagged at a woman demanding apology.	LizBeth	Mar 2021	#49
Brava! We know whaat happened..	Cha	Mar 2021	#85
Sanders would have voted for her, because he supports Biden. Manchin would never vote for her.	Autumn	Mar 2021	#16
I do not know that to be true. Regardless, he started the tone.	LizBeth	Mar 2021	#19
Regardless, Bernie supports the Democratic agenda that Biden wants. Manchin is kneecapping him.	Autumn	Mar 2021	#24
Sanders was the very one that kneecapped Tanden. Manchin just kicked her while she was down.	LizBeth	Mar 2021	#27
So? He still said he would vote for you. You can blame Manchin, who said he wouldn't vote for her.	Autumn	Mar 2021	#33
So? Ya right	LizBeth	Mar 2021	#35
I don't think he did say he would vote for her	dsc	Mar 2021	#71
From the article	rogue emissary	Mar 2021	#117
From another article	Autumn	Mar 2021	#129
"would have been"	rogue emissary	Mar 2021	#139
"she dropped out". Know who else didn't officially endorse her? Your Democrat, Joe Manchin.	Autumn	Mar 2021	#164
You are wrong. White House sources said that Bernie said he would vote for her	Autumn	Mar 2021	#128
It was said after, though not by him publicly	dsc	Mar 2021	#130
Let it go. You're wrong. Bernie said he would vote for her, he supports Biden's agenda. Manchin	Autumn	Mar 2021	#133
No I am not wrong	dsc	Mar 2021	#136
HE doesn't have to say he would vote for her in public. HE TOLD THE WHITE HOUSE	Autumn	Mar 2021	#137
please stop lying about what I said	dsc	Mar 2021	#138
I NEVER SAID you said it was his job. You are accusing me of lying about what you posted.	Autumn	Mar 2021	#143
...	jcgoldie	Mar 2021	#132
Where in this article does it quote him or his staff on the record?	rogue emissary	Mar 2021	#141
Oh I see the game now	jcgoldie	Mar 2021	#149
Do you mean the game where you can't quote him or his staff saying he'd vote for her?	rogue emissary	Mar 2021	#151
No	jcgoldie	Mar 2021	#152
Let me be clear, I blame them both for tanking Tanden's nomination.	rogue emissary	Mar 2021	#158
"people were lying"	jcgoldie	Mar 2021	#160
Yes, that includes their trash article which is more click bait than an article.	rogue emissary	Mar 2021	#162
Bullshit	jcgoldie	Mar 2021	#168
+1. It truly amazes me the insistence to vilify Manchin and the exoneration or Sanders. It is what	LizBeth	Mar 2021	#153
Exactly, they both held Tanden to a level they didn't for many of Donny's nominees.	rogue emissary	Mar 2021	#159
Whats petty	jcgoldie	Mar 2021	#167
No one in the thread absolved Manchin's role except the people that want to wipe out Sanders role.	LizBeth	Mar 2021	#170
I posted that link. But Bernie never said it PUBLICLY.	Autumn	Mar 2021	#144
Kind of ironic the "real democrat" Manchin harpooned her nomination.	Hassin Bin Sober	Mar 2021	#42
Sanders harpooned it, Manchin joined in.	LizBeth	Mar 2021	#45
Exactly, and they know that.	Nixie	Mar 2021	#52
+1	LizBeth	Mar 2021	#57
The man as chairman made it about mean tweets instead of issues	JI7	Mar 2021	#73
This. He started the ball rolling then sit back and let others do. Now we see his signature is not	LizBeth	Mar 2021	#76
Yes, and it was a pathetic display	Nixie	Mar 2021	#147
Post removed	Post removed	Mar 2021	#56
A friend said this morning, razor thin margins in the senate means we need to be prepared to	Autumn	Mar 2021	#127
First of all, as pointed out below, you're not correct. But, how is this different	Cuthbert Allgood	Mar 2021	#134
Yep.	seaglass	Mar 2021	#31
+1. Thank you	LizBeth	Mar 2021	#36
Why would he vote for her if Manchin and no Republicans would cross over to vote for her?	Autumn	Mar 2021	#37
Make up your mind. You just posted that he would have voted for her.	seaglass	Mar 2021	#38
Which part of Manchin said he would not vote for her, Republicans would not cross over to vote for	Autumn	Mar 2021	#44
He should have announced she was withdrawing her nomination and there would be no vote? Or lied?	Autumn	Mar 2021	#51
The last I saw he refused to say if he'd vote for her.	rogue emissary	Mar 2021	#113
Right. Thank you.	LizBeth	Mar 2021	#115
He said it was true	jcgoldie	Mar 2021	#131
Depressing. n/t	Laelth	Mar 2021	#2
According to CNN she requested that her name be withdrawn. Still depressing.	marmar	Mar 2021	#3
Boiler Print.	mobeau69	Mar 2021	#28
Neera Tanden's Exit brought to you by the following white men	liskddksil	Mar 2021	#5
Sanders was first to step up and call out her out with his scold. Why are we forgetting Sanders	LizBeth	Mar 2021	#6
Because Sanders would have voted for her and didn't cost us vital Senate races nt	liskddksil	Mar 2021	#8
This.	marmar	Mar 2021	#11
+10,000	jorgevlorgan	Mar 2021	#14
Glad he would have voted for her, but he didn't need to say anything	kcr	Mar 2021	#26
Really? He didn't seem as sure as you are.	seaglass	Mar 2021	#32
Sanders' part in a lot of things is forgotten	Skittles	Mar 2021	#54
Yes.	LizBeth	Mar 2021	#58
+	JI7	Mar 2021	#82
Always find a way to blame Bernie	wellst0nev0ter	Mar 2021	#70
Sanders was the first to scold a grown woman on being mean to him, on record.	LizBeth	Mar 2021	#72
Sanders didn't out and out announce he won't vote for her	wellst0nev0ter	Mar 2021	#77
That's the line you are standing on?	LizBeth	Mar 2021	#78
Why are you caping for Manchin anyway?	wellst0nev0ter	Mar 2021	#79
All about gaslighting. Pretending Sanders didn't start it all and certainly had his part in this and	LizBeth	Mar 2021	#80
This is about Manchin, not Sanders	wellst0nev0ter	Mar 2021	#81
Tou totally misread the poster.. she	Cha	Mar 2021	#86
The poster was clearly trying to deflect blame from Manchin to Sanders	wellst0nev0ter	Mar 2021	#87
Blame Manchin. Sanders started it and he gets equal blame. This is not a tough one.	LizBeth	Mar 2021	#89
Don't bothsides this	wellst0nev0ter	Mar 2021	#92
I am on Tanden side. I do not know why you do not get that.	LizBeth	Mar 2021	#94
Then aim your vitriol at Manchin	wellst0nev0ter	Mar 2021	#96
I disagree with you as I have argued thru out this thread.	LizBeth	Mar 2021	#98
Sounds like you just want an excuse to dump on Bernie	wellst0nev0ter	Mar 2021	#101
Poor picked on Sanders defending himself to the point of scolding a woman on record because she	LizBeth	Mar 2021	#102
Tanden is mature enough to own those tweets and apologize for them	wellst0nev0ter	Mar 2021	#105
Like I said.. she is giving the timeline of	Cha	Mar 2021	#106
No.. she was Clearly Not "trying to Cover	Cha	Mar 2021	#104
Well, Tanden certainly had a reason to apologize. Sanders was scolding her on record at the	LizBeth	Mar 2021	#109
Yes, for the reason you stated.. but	Cha	Mar 2021	#122
But she did apologize for her tweets	wellst0nev0ter	Mar 2021	#110
He was holding the job over her head. Are you for real? Damn this would not be the hill I stood on.	LizBeth	Mar 2021	#111
You're on the hill of blaming Bernie or bust	wellst0nev0ter	Mar 2021	#114
I am calling out Sanders actions that were in part to the ousting of Tanden that I found to be very	LizBeth	Mar 2021	#116
Tanden put herself in that position with her tweets	wellst0nev0ter	Mar 2021	#119
Exactly.. like I said	Cha	Mar 2021	#124
Yes, I read she "apologized".. she was left with	Cha	Mar 2021	#123
You're okay with people insinuating that Democrats and allies	wellst0nev0ter	Mar 2021	#145
Not only did Sanders own it, he then blamed HRC for not addressing it. A pattern.	LizBeth	Mar 2021	#146
Reverse it. If Sanders had tweeted about Tanden what she did	Cuthbert Allgood	Mar 2021	#135
Let's be honest. These people love exacting political revenge for anyone who said anything...	Hassin Bin Sober	Mar 2021	#142
Here's the thing about being a grownup. You have to conduct yourself as one on social media.	Hassin Bin Sober	Mar 2021	#148
Here is something else about being a grown up. Recognizing and acknowledging the different standards	LizBeth	Mar 2021	#154
Remember when AOC got her Covid vaccination? That was epic too.	Autumn	Mar 2021	#165
Agreed - it's like people think people should have their cake and eat it too - get plaudits for	Midwestern Democrat	Mar 2021	#171
VERY much deserved	Skittles	Mar 2021	#83
Tanden did herself no favors with the Bernie mean tweets	wellst0nev0ter	Mar 2021	#84
Now you acknowledge Sanders part in ousting Tanden then blame Tanden. Just like	LizBeth	Mar 2021	#88
Bernie had every right to address the mean tweet	wellst0nev0ter	Mar 2021	#90
Again you acknowledge Sanders scolding and are good with it. I am not.	LizBeth	Mar 2021	#95
Yes, nobody can say anything about her mean tweets	wellst0nev0ter	Mar 2021	#99
Yes Sanders wagged the finger scolding her and giving her a stern look over his glasses eliciting	LizBeth	Mar 2021	#107
Tanden put herself in that position	wellst0nev0ter	Mar 2021	#112
That tweet is factual and not mean at all.	radius777	Mar 2021	#91
Tanden suggested that Bernie got foreign help	wellst0nev0ter	Mar 2021	#93
But our intelligence agencies suggested that Bernie's movement	radius777	Mar 2021	#103
Exactly.. it was well documented .. it can't be	Cha	Mar 2021	#125
Yes, exactly. And why I refuse to just walk on by. Yes. You said it well.	LizBeth	Mar 2021	#97
I know.. it's Horrible. No need to	Cha	Mar 2021	#120
yes, telling the truth is not always a great idea	Skittles	Mar 2021	#163
Sanders would have voted for her	BradAllison	Mar 2021	#150
Sanders issue was certainly personal also. He brought it to the forefront in a committee hearing	LizBeth	Mar 2021	#155
But it was Joey Boy's deal breaker.	BradAllison	Mar 2021	#156
I have not minimized Manchin's participation in sabotaging Tanden. I refuse to ignore Sanders	LizBeth	Mar 2021	#157
Bloomberg had nothing to do with Toomey winning	Deminpenn	Mar 2021	#47
:	onecaliberal	Mar 2021	#12
If this were to become a standard going forward, that would be one thing	dsc	Mar 2021	#13
+1	LizBeth	Mar 2021	#21
They are considered uppity women and should know their place.	sheshe2	Mar 2021	#34
+1	uponit7771	Mar 2021	#60
Yup, did those who scolded her for tweets say anything about Josh Hawley ?	JI7	Mar 2021	#75
Yes, this is pretty depressing. Sucks to be a woman. Men are not held to the same	Biophilic	Mar 2021	#17
one word	bdamomma	Mar 2021	#22
That won't be a problem. nt	mobeau69	Mar 2021	#30
Biden & Team will pick a highly qualified alternative.	Kaleva	Mar 2021	#25
Agree.	Hortensis	Mar 2021	#40
Sounds like Biden will find a non-confirmation position for her.	BlueCheeseAgain	Mar 2021	#29
Welcome to DU!	bdamomma	Mar 2021	#41
Yes, and oh yes. It could be noted I suppose that Sanders	Hortensis	Mar 2021	#46
+1	uponit7771	Mar 2021	#61
Welcome to our DU family.	niyad	Mar 2021	#66
There are a whole lot of fragile, easily bruised egos in the senate.	BannonsLiver	Mar 2021	#39
Yup, bitterness over multiple losses which they claim were rigged	JI7	Mar 2021	#74
Yeah, they think their	Cha	Mar 2021	#121
I thought Presidents had an absolute right to appoint their own people?	gratuitous	Mar 2021	#43
It should be that way	Nasruddin	Mar 2021	#59
They do, the advise and consent doesn't extend to blocking. Same with SC justices ...	uponit7771	Mar 2021	#62
She'll be fine	Deminpenn	Mar 2021	#50
Damn!!! I love her laugh, wit and experience.	BigmanPigman	Mar 2021	#53
I understand why Neera Tanden withdrew, but it's a shame a competent/experienced person couldn't	iluvtennis	Mar 2021	#55
Too bad. She was great. I guess different standards apply to us.	mahina	Mar 2021	#63
After 4 years of the garbage mouth "insulting Insult"....?	Hulk	Mar 2021	#64
Well... that didnt take long	quakerboy	Mar 2021	#65
This is sad. But she will land on her feet.	PatrickforB	Mar 2021	#67
I still think she was the sacrificial lamb.	Calista241	Mar 2021	#68
If we keep folding without a fight they will challenge every nominee until we fold.	usaf-vet	Mar 2021	#69
Math is math.	tritsofme	Mar 2021	#108
Sure, it's the middle aged brown woman responsible for the toxic online culture.	radius777	Mar 2021	#100
+1	LizBeth	Mar 2021	#118
You are confusing supporters with the Principal	Hassin Bin Sober	Mar 2021	#140
Yeah, "let's blame it on Neera Tanden".. that should	Cha	Mar 2021	#161
Well known?	AZProgressive	Mar 2021	#166
Yes I saw it with my OWN EYES.. nobody	Cha	Mar 2021	#169
What will Tanden's new position in the Biden admin be?	Hortensis	Mar 2021	#126

Edit History

Please login to view edit histories.