Welcome to DU!
The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards.
Join the community:
Create a free account
Support DU (and get rid of ads!):
Become a Star Member
Latest Breaking News
Editorials & Other Articles
General Discussion
The DU Lounge
All Forums
Issue Forums
Culture Forums
Alliance Forums
Region Forums
Support Forums
Help & Search
General Discussion
In reply to the discussion: Holy shit. Be prepared for the consumer to get screwed on your healthcare advantage programs. [View all]Cirsium
(413 posts)13. Medicare "advantage"
No Democrat should be supporting or praising this right wing privatization scam, this assault on Medicare.
Edit history
Please sign in to view edit histories.
238 replies
= new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight:
NoneDon't highlight anything
5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
RecommendedHighlight replies with 5 or more recommendations
Holy shit. Be prepared for the consumer to get screwed on your healthcare advantage programs. [View all]
LilElf70
Sep 16
OP
I've had an Advantage plan for five years. Costs me $0 additional. I love it.
Sibelius Fan
Sep 16
#3
Clinic systems have contracts with insurers and the reimbursement rates are already negotiated
dflprincess
Sep 16
#52
They get commissions on advantage and drug plans too, which are private insurers.
Silent Type
Sep 16
#109
I have no copay for doctor visits. Generic drugs are $0. A three-month supply of
Sibelius Fan
Sep 17
#181
I have $2000 worth of dental work that needs to be done next month which I now will get done
elocs
Sep 17
#173
Humana has a plan which covers dental extensively in Ohio...I have never been on it but good reviews.
Demsrule86
Sep 17
#188
"I know some people are limited financially and must go with what they can afford"
elocs
Sep 17
#176
Yes - you have to be able to afford it. On the other hand, having to pay the 20% of B could be bankrupting.
kerry-is-my-prez
Sep 17
#215
"Supplement" is the wrong term if you are talking about privatized Medicare
Jmb 4 Harris-Walz
Sep 17
#192
If something seems too good to be true, it definitely is. We won't get Medicare Advantage either.
lostnfound
Sep 16
#16
Yup, Medicare Advantage is privatized Medicare. My concierge dr won't take you if you have a disadvantage program
vapor2
Sep 16
#50
Your concierge doc probably does not take traditional Medicare either, especially new patients.
Silent Type
Sep 16
#110
You are initially, don't fall for advantage if you're going to be new to Medicare.
we can do it
Sep 16
#97
I think it all depends on the Advantage Plan that was chosen. There are several to choose from; suggest you
Jmb 4 Harris-Walz
Sep 17
#194
Max out-of-pocket for prescriptions drops to $2000 next year. That's $3,000 in savings.
Sibelius Fan
Sep 16
#2
I think that's a big deal; however I'm not sure what that will do to premiums.
Silent Type
Sep 16
#111
I spent 46 days in hospital, had open heart surgery, two subsequent heart surgeries and take Eliquis-
Demsrule86
Sep 16
#46
Humana Gold Advantage PPR give back ( GB means I get just over 100 back monthly from part B)
Demsrule86
Sep 17
#193
I have Humana Gold. You have regular Medicare. I couldn't afford it. I pay no premiums and get 100 + a month back in
Demsrule86
Sep 17
#186
Part C is Advantage...you have traditional now. And Medigap covers the 20% Part B doesn't cover and insurance companies
Demsrule86
Sep 17
#198
I have gym membership free with my supplement and can go to any doc who takes Medicare w/o asking insurance permission.
we can do it
Sep 16
#100
Do you realize that Advantage plans are private plans and not Medicare plans?
Think. Again.
Sep 16
#8
And insurance companies sell Medi-gap policies...so I don't see the difference.
Demsrule86
Sep 17
#199
That is your opinion. I have advantage and I get 100 per month back on part B, no premium and everything is
Demsrule86
Sep 17
#209
Medicare works with it, but doesn't administer it. Medicare gives Medicare Advantage
pnwmom
Sep 17
#142
That's just a label -- it means it's approved by Medicare as an option, but it's not managed
pnwmom
Sep 17
#135
Your drug and MediGap policy are private too. And private insurance companies do all the admin
Silent Type
Sep 16
#113
So is Medi-gap coverage. I don't see the difference. Other than I pay more for traditional.
Demsrule86
Sep 17
#195
The difference is Medicare is a government program while Advantage (and medi-gap) are corporate programs.
Think. Again.
Sep 17
#200
No, they are private plans that Medicare regulates and pays on your behalf. The plans aren't run by Medicare.
pnwmom
Sep 16
#83
That is BS. Unless you want to pay 20 % out of pocket, you have to get an additional plan with a commercial insurer
Demsrule86
Sep 16
#49
That is not true. My sister in law had regular Medicare and she was denied care. They can and will deny you.
Demsrule86
Sep 17
#204
You misinterpret...you pay Medi-gap plans for coverage..and these plans are insurance based...not different that
Demsrule86
Sep 17
#210
The difference is whether your own doctors and hospital decide on the care you need,
pnwmom
Sep 16
#87
You are kidding yourself if you think traditional Medicare doesn't deny certain procedures.
Demsrule86
Sep 17
#206
Supplements are private insurance plans, though with little discretion. As are drug plans,
Silent Type
Sep 16
#114
You need to take a look at original Medicare policies that limit all kinds of coverage for "excessive"
Silent Type
Sep 17
#132
I'm really glad it's worked so well for you up to now. It appears less stellar in other regions. I'm sorry the
LauraInLA
Sep 16
#98
Have you or your wife ever needed X-ray treatments that cost more than $10K each?
pnwmom
Sep 17
#128
Bad news. Private insurers get paid billions to administer original Medicare too. So you
Silent Type
Sep 16
#116
No, they don't. Medicare itself administers Parts A & b with the money people pay into it.
pnwmom
Sep 17
#150
Absolutely wrong. Private insurers have subsidiaries that administer original Medicare. Give me your state and
Silent Type
Sep 17
#165
Insurance companies make them, I guess. My mother, who died in 2009, had the United American supplemental plan,
LauraInLA
Sep 16
#103
I live in Cleveland on my Advantage plan...I can us Cleveland Clinic, UH or Metro...all fine insurers.
Demsrule86
Sep 16
#51
"No Democrat should be supporting or praising this right wing privatization scam, this assault on Medicare. "
MichMan
Sep 16
#57
the 2025 changes that save the beneficiaries money shift the financial burden to the plans
Coexist
Sep 16
#21
Once you get locked in, it may be difficult to go back to original Medicare. They now own you.
keithbvadu2
Sep 16
#26
You can go back to original Medicare (parts a & b) at any time during open enrollment
hot2na
Sep 17
#149
Rightly or wrongly, MA rates were cut. Personally, until our government-- regardless of party --
Silent Type
Sep 16
#30
The issue is the trade-off. We turned down Advantage and its freebies (free dental, gym, etc)
pnwmom
Sep 16
#80
Might be worth checking the AARP United HC Medicare Supplement. It provides gym memberships.
we can do it
Sep 16
#104
I get it. Your situation like half of Medicare eligible people is unfortunate and you're right
Cheezoholic
Sep 16
#85
Well, CMS is cutting rates for next year. Whether that is justification for cutting "extra" benefits
Silent Type
Sep 17
#123
Medicare Advantage is a ripoff, and I would never choose such a plan. Buyer beware!
Martin68
Sep 16
#81
The private insurers running MA plans have been subsidized, to the disadvantage of regular Medicare.
Ms. Toad
Sep 16
#93
No, I think people are just bringing it up, to shed medicare in a bad light during an election, and stoke discontent.
Think. Again.
Sep 17
#122
I saw tens of thousands of my husband's co-retirees threatened with the loss of their doctors
pnwmom
Sep 17
#134
The people screwed by advantage are dead...they aren't going to answer
questionseverything
Sep 17
#155
One of the biggest providers in the city will not take Advantage anymore.
kerry-is-my-prez
Sep 17
#202
Lots of people are happy with MA. That's why 52% of Medicare beneficiaries choose it.
Silent Type
Sep 17
#124
When they join they can only hope they'll be happy long term. And in most states, if you wait too long to switch back,
pnwmom
Sep 17
#139
I know, some folks think that 52% are too stupid to make the right decision for them.
Silent Type
Sep 17
#166
Medicare Disadvantage - 11 years ago when I was considering 'Advantage' plans, that's what an agent called it
GoneOffShore
Sep 17
#148
hospitals and clinics are not getting adequate reimbursement from them
travelingthrulife
Sep 17
#162
How did I know that the doom and gloom post would be from a relatively new member?
ZonkerHarris
Sep 17
#196
In case you haven't noticed, the only significant upgrades to our healthcare system-- ACA, drug plans, Medicaid
Silent Type
Sep 18
#220
There is nothing more confusing than Medicare. I still haven't wrapped my head around it but someone stopped me from
kerry-is-my-prez
Sep 17
#213
I have Medicare and Tricare for Life so I don't need or want Medicare Advantage
LogDog75
Sep 18
#221