Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

FB47243

(58 posts)
15. Pardon Power
Mon Feb 10, 2025, 04:05 PM
Feb 10

Actually, the president can pardon someone for civil contempt charges, but there are limits.

The U.S. Constitution grants the president broad pardon powers for federal offenses (Article II, Section 2). Civil contempt can sometimes be considered a federal offense, especially if it’s linked to a federal court order. However, if the contempt charge is coercive (meant to force compliance, like refusing to testify), a pardon might not immediately free the person—courts could reframe the punishment to continue enforcing compliance.

In contrast, state-level civil contempt is outside the president’s pardon power. Governors handle pardons for state cases.

So, while there are nuances, the president does have the ability to pardon civil contempt in many cases, particularly at the federal level.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

Constitutional crisis only 3 weeks into his term Sanity Claws Feb 10 #1
Trump will tell the gang to ignore this new order dalton99a Feb 10 #2
Yup. sakabatou Feb 10 #6
Impeach him. mobeau69 Feb 10 #3
We don't have the votes. littlemissmartypants Feb 10 #14
He could be impeached for failure to "faithfully execute the office of President and to uphold the Constitution"... thesquanderer Feb 10 #24
We will see if the Trump complies with the Court's Order. surfered Feb 10 #4
Yep, scary to even think about. mobeau69 Feb 10 #23
"...or ELSE!" dchill Feb 10 #5
Can judges start fining drmeow Feb 10 #7
Could they just ignore that too? ananda Feb 10 #19
(Historically) banks obey court orders. mobeau69 Feb 10 #22
K&R UTUSN Feb 10 #8
Just 24 hours after I posted that Trump and Musk would defy the court's orders it has happened. flashman13 Feb 10 #9
or else... what? FoggyLake Feb 10 #10
And Trump will continue to ignore it... Quanto Magnus Feb 10 #11
if they dont comply moonshinegnomie Feb 10 #12
Unfortunately angrychair Feb 10 #13
Pardon Power FB47243 Feb 10 #15
Exactly contempt is it's own thing JCMach1 Feb 10 #17
NBC News: Judge finds Trump administration violated court order halting funding freeze Dennis Donovan Feb 10 #16
And if they don't orangecrush Feb 10 #18
Which one is this? I'm getting confused. NT mahatmakanejeeves Feb 10 #20
SEND THE MARSHALLS TO THE WHITEHOUSE spanone Feb 10 #21
Trump's DOJ isn't sending marshalls anywhere he doesn't want them to go. (n/t) thesquanderer Feb 10 #26
He's going to appeal until he Tickle Feb 10 #25
Question: returnee Feb 10 #27
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Kyle Cheney: Breaking: Fe...»Reply #15