Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

ElboRuum

(4,717 posts)
38. That's not how it reads.
Mon Sep 2, 2013, 01:50 PM
Sep 2013

I can't say for certain what the context of that quote was, but considering the fact that Carl was a scientist, and happily so from what I know, he seems to be incredulous not that people don't know, but that they don't share his insatiable interest in it. Why this should be is why I find it to be nothing but a glib remark.

Educated people sometimes just don't get the fact that some people (and it Dr. Sagan's case, relatively speaking, most) are simply not as well educated, and in some cases, simply have no interest in what they have interest in. I love it when the mathematicians decry the lottery, pointing out time and again the utterly miniscule chance of winning and essentially calling anyone who plays an idiot. Has not a single mathematician considered the fact that people play the lottery for fun and NOT as some seem to think as a long-term retirement investment strategy? People who are enamored of literature who don't get the draw of television, making crass remarks about Cheeto dust all the while, are another fine example.

Some people just don't get science and technology, and others simply are happy that most of the time it works. I know how a car works, but I have no interest in getting out a box of tools and going to work on one. Many of my gearhead friends just don't get how this is possible. It's easy. It interests you, not me. That the car starts and gets me where I want to go is quite enough, thank you.

Is this some recipe for disaster as some have conjectured? No. For so long as there are cars, there will be mechanics. So long as there are puzzles to solve, there will be those of keen mind and insatiable interest to solve them. If science and tech trips your trigger, bully for you, as I know personally how compelling that world can be. But not knowing or caring about it has yet to claim our society, and just for the record, there is nothing new about that mindset at all.

Du rec. Nt xchrom Sep 2013 #1
"exquisitely dependent" handmade34 Sep 2013 #2
That's funny, sad, and very true. And it's a recipe for massive failure. LuvNewcastle Sep 2013 #3
Actually, it isn't. ElboRuum Sep 2013 #10
Americans certainly don't have to know everything about science and technology but when... BlueJazz Sep 2013 #12
Exactly. LuvNewcastle Sep 2013 #16
But was that really was Carl Sagan was saying in that quote? ElboRuum Sep 2013 #21
It's not that they are lacking in "scientific skills" ElboRuum Sep 2013 #24
Your words are true and wise. BlueJazz Sep 2013 #26
One of the best critiques of the average American's mentality I've read. Thanks! Surya Gayatri Sep 2013 #27
I think that's a terribly naive point of view that mirrors the excuses, and reasons, for slavery. jtuck004 Sep 2013 #14
I agree. LuvNewcastle Sep 2013 #17
Terribly naive? ElboRuum Sep 2013 #20
No, and the logical end isn''t to pose an outlandish and impossible answer, either. jtuck004 Sep 2013 #35
Interesting points. ElboRuum Sep 2013 #41
Interesting how you conflate points just to erect your little scree... jtuck004 Sep 2013 #42
Of course. ElboRuum Sep 2013 #43
The problem here Stargazer09 Sep 2013 #28
Wasn't Neil DeGrasse Tyson ElboRuum Sep 2013 #30
I sure do wish I could believe you, but I have little faith. reusrename Sep 2013 #31
Science does not require faith. ElboRuum Sep 2013 #33
Read the graphic. It doesn't say .... Scuba Sep 2013 #37
That's not how it reads. ElboRuum Sep 2013 #38
k and r--and, sadly, the anti-science, anti-intellectual crowd wants to keep it that way. niyad Sep 2013 #4
Hey, I built that skydive forever Sep 2013 #5
cool! progressoid Sep 2013 #7
I'm jealous! Stargazer09 Sep 2013 #29
It's miracles. Jesus done 'em. nt valerief Sep 2013 #6
How few 'key' people could we lose...... daleanime Sep 2013 #8
We live in a society which expects us to be clothed. ElboRuum Sep 2013 #9
DURec leftstreet Sep 2013 #11
hell yeah pasto76 Sep 2013 #13
We need more STEM majors! LOL reformist2 Sep 2013 #15
I'm okay fadedrose Sep 2013 #18
Sound and pitchers? ElboRuum Sep 2013 #22
beer? fadedrose Sep 2013 #23
You know, I think that's false advertising. ElboRuum Sep 2013 #25
U gotta leave the door open & hang a few baloons fadedrose Sep 2013 #40
It's called SPECIALIZATION, genius. Dreamer Tatum Sep 2013 #19
You could also take the statement at face value: Quantess Sep 2013 #34
True. ElboRuum Sep 2013 #39
there is only a "critical mass" of the specialized knowledge needed... yawnmaster Sep 2013 #32
+1 K&R nt Jasana Sep 2013 #36
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»We live in a society exqu...»Reply #38