Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search
 

johnlucas

(1,250 posts)
37. One of my first posts here was "There's no such thing as the Middle Class"
Sun Oct 27, 2013, 12:53 AM
Oct 2013

Last edited Sun Oct 27, 2013, 03:52 PM - Edit history (1)

Can't seem to find it anymore due to the change from the old Democratic Underground to the current one...
...But that I believe was my very first post here in 2008.

The words you speak influence the way you think.
In truth what is called "Middle Class" income is closer to the low ends of all incomes.
The true middle is probably a multimillionaire if you go by dollar amounts alone disregarding number of people who fall into those income categories.
A straight up Arithmetic Mean.

So knowing this reality let's say that we account for number of people who have a particular income as well as counting all incomes available.
A Mode Average.
Then you'll probably see a number closer to Poor when you see THIS kind of Middle.
Let's say a number under $20,000 as the Mode Average.
The Working Poor pretty much.

ESPECIALLY if you tie it to ratio of cost of living per region.
Regions vary in income so a more pricey income can skew data higher than it actually is.

That mythical Middle Class income either way looks fake & false.
But the myth is mighty & the culture that has come up around it is mighty as well.

In reality Middle Class people are just Poor people with the Illusions of Wealth.
I call it Poor First Class (sort of like the military with Private First Class).
They get a taste of the luxury the TRULY wealthy enjoy & think they're no longer poor.
Those who are honest with themselves & introspective realize this phony twilight & are in solidarity with poor people AKA the Underclass.
They know that they are one major medical emergency or natural disaster away from homelessness.
They're thankful for what they have but they know better than to get haughty & condescending toward those with lesser financial means.

The reason you're starting to see more progressive positions take root is because at last the illusion was breaking away.
Poor people have suffered endlessly throughout history in this country & every other.
But nobody really makes a big deal with the problems of the Poor.
When the robber barons started taking away the so-called "Middle Class" illusions of wealth only THEN did you see reporters out here making a big deal over the injustice.

That's the best thing that came out of the Great Recession. It finally woke enough of these complacent jabronies up.
They were starting to re-remember that they were the Poor all along & will be treated just like the Poor.
All that talk of "I'm a taxpayer!" "I work hard for my money!" & all those myopic points of view started falling by the wayside when they can't afford to go to the doctor, food is getting more expensive to buy, & gas is crunching budgets to extreme degrees.

I say it like this.
If YOU WORK FOR YOUR MONEY, then you are POOR.
If YOUR MONEY WORKS FOR YOU, then you are RICH.

It's that real.
The truly wealthy don't work to live. It's an arbitrary adventure for them if they actually do any work.
They spend time strategizing their existing resources to further expand their financial & social power.
Money is momentum-based & the more money you have, the more money you will have to make even more money.
You can seed a small portion of your money just like farmers plant their crops & watch that seed bloom into a dollar bill harvest.
From there you take a piece of that harvest to plant more seeds to get more harvests.

And once you get to a certain point of income & stored wealth, you EXCEED all possible price tags, so money just self-collects after a certain point.
You simply don't have anything to spend it on & it accumulates exponentially.
Price tags are the Bouncers keeping you out of the club, out of the VIP room.
Poor people are faced with price tags every day, Rich people don't even know price tags.
AND EVEN MORE since wealth is worshipped (since humans bow to power of any kind), the Rich get freebies just for showing up.
They make regular people pay $7 for an entry fee into the club, a rich celebrity gets in for free since the club owner knows everybody will want to see that celebrity & pay more entry fees to get in.

That's why taxes need to be high on the Rich because if they aren't nothing puts them in check & they abuse their power over society.
The Rich have passed their responsibilities of financing the country's infrastructure onto the so-called Middle Class.
There's more "Middle Class" incomes available to draw from after all.
Yet who do many "Middle Class" people demonize & blame for their problems?
You got it. The Poor.

Hell, those are the people they live around, right? Can't expect them to demonize somebody they hardly ever see.
And oddly enough they never come to the realization that if I'm around a bunch of Poor people that MAYBE just MAYBE I just might be The Poor myself.

It's a classic case of Divide & Conquer.
Give a portion of the Poor a slight taste of wealth & watch them enforce Elitist oppressions on the Poor they came from.
Same with Police & the Citizens. Give 'em a taste of power & watch them enforce the will of the Powers That Be onto the Citizens they came from.

Generally the Rich don't like to share but they know where to spend money as necessary to keep the bulk with themselves.

When politicians—including Democratic politicians—talk about Middle Class & Middle Class only, I get a little sick.
I know how phony this talk is.
John Lucas

Does Maher write his own stuff? Smarmie Doofus Oct 2013 #1
He has writers, but he also writes. grahamhgreen Oct 2013 #4
There are a bunch of writers on the show including Bill. progressoid Oct 2013 #5
Coronel? and I "is" ? Maher is not usually this sloppy SoCalDem Oct 2013 #34
One of my first posts here was "There's no such thing as the Middle Class" johnlucas Oct 2013 #37
This message was self-deleted by its author PotatoChip Oct 2013 #41
It looks like a transcription error, but it's an ironic one ... the_chinuk Oct 2013 #43
Powerful stuff. Baitball Blogger Oct 2013 #2
It's always been that way from the start of "America" Yavin4 Oct 2013 #3
I think Maher and his writers read DU LittleGirl Oct 2013 #6
americans ARE indentured servants or slaves to the USA riverbendviewgal Oct 2013 #7
Not really. LittleGirl Oct 2013 #16
I don't understand your post riverbendviewgal Oct 2013 #24
Yes, a little confusing, sorry LittleGirl Oct 2013 #51
You are almost correct. If you have a very low income, you don't even have to file. JDPriestly Oct 2013 #40
yes, it's complicated LittleGirl Oct 2013 #52
Good piece. Aldo Leopold Oct 2013 #8
They want most of us to die already. Starving preferred, as a starving person LiberalLoner Oct 2013 #9
"This is the question the right has to answer. Brigid Oct 2013 #10
The problem is....they do want both! CANDO Oct 2013 #27
One strength of this point is that it perfectly illustrates DirkGently Oct 2013 #11
If you are like me and ctsnowman Oct 2013 #12
Thanks for that link!!! arcane1 Oct 2013 #26
K & R !!! WillyT Oct 2013 #13
K&R woo me with science Oct 2013 #14
I expect right-wingers would disagree with this part: Marr Oct 2013 #15
No. Enthusiast Oct 2013 #17
They're answer is already being said out there. They claim she has an "entitlement mentality"... Spitfire of ATJ Oct 2013 #20
Trickle Down, bay-bee. 1980. And still goin' strong in DC. blkmusclmachine Oct 2013 #18
Trickle up, no more trickle down NBachers Oct 2013 #30
to paraphrase the late George Carlin- pitchforx Oct 2013 #19
K&R but DJ13 Oct 2013 #21
Big K&R nt riderinthestorm Oct 2013 #22
I must be naive BrotherIvan Oct 2013 #23
Astute observation laundry_queen Oct 2013 #38
Someone should introduce Ted Cruz to the concept of inflation. Spider Jerusalem Oct 2013 #25
No kidding! intheflow Oct 2013 #33
BLS says 50 cents in 1957 is $4.16 now muriel_volestrangler Oct 2013 #49
He's telling us something very important Warpy Oct 2013 #28
It was always thus, Bill. DeSwiss Oct 2013 #29
Bill's great. About 6 months behind Thom Hartmann, but better late than never. nt navarth Oct 2013 #31
People are finally realizing that Welfare and Food Stamps are not hand outs to the poor, tecelote Oct 2013 #32
The Walton Family Is Worth Roughly $145 Billion DallasNE Oct 2013 #35
kick woo me with science Oct 2013 #36
I think it was about Hubert Flottz Oct 2013 #39
K&R! Phlem Oct 2013 #42
That's why Republicans oppose minimum wage AND social programs Prophet 451 Oct 2013 #44
It's a lovely ideology isn't it? stillwaiting Oct 2013 #47
They've actually invented a whole new religion Prophet 451 Oct 2013 #48
These are the issues that Dem representatives should be pushing mnhtnbb Oct 2013 #45
Hey Bill. . .it happened January 21st, 1981. Look up what happened that day! Nanjing to Seoul Oct 2013 #46
When did the American Dream exist for every American Citizen Mass Oct 2013 #50
So basically we are paying higher taxes because B Calm Oct 2013 #53
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Bill Maher Asks: "Wh...»Reply #37