HomeLatest ThreadsGreatest ThreadsForums & GroupsMy SubscriptionsMy Posts
DU Home » Latest Threads » Forums & Groups » Main » General Discussion (Forum) » Re: JFK... Whether You Be... » Reply #27

Response to sabrina 1 (Reply #22)

Fri Nov 22, 2013, 05:22 AM

27. "Motive is extremely important in any murder case." I disagree.

In murder mystery novels, yes. In actual prosecutions? Not so much. They help at times. But, no, if the facts on the ground show someone committed the crime and mens rae can be demonstrated without explaining a motive, then motive can be set aside.

Since Oswald can reasonably be expected to know what would happen as he fired his rifle at the President, and since he then fled the scene (demonstrating a consciousness of guilt), mens rae at his trial would have been easily demonstrated. So as far as his guilt, his motive wouldn't need to be shown at trial.

I think the possibility of Oswald being hired or put up to the assassination by a conspiracy is rather low.

Sure, we can speculate on motive. He did it to get people to pay attention to him at last. He did it so people could only ever think of him passionately again (hat tip, "Assassins". He did it because Kennedy was the human face of the bloodthirsty capitalistic United States, the enemy of Castro and the Marxist revolution. He did it to punish Marina for not coming back to him in the end. He did it because he thought Castro would let him into Cuba. He did it hoping that Kennedy's right wing enemies would get the blame. He did it to finally succeed at something in his sad, pathetic life. He did it to gain a national platform in his trial. He did it because everything in his life had prepared him for that moment.

He did it because he could.

That Oswald did it, easily shown. Why he did it, we'll never know for sure. And evil and good and good/evil people swept in and took advantage of JFK's death - of course they did. They always will when a powerful and influential man dies. But benefit is not evidence of guilt, not even when they are spectacular benefits. Guilt does not rest on knowing a motive.

Reply to this post

Back to OP Alert abuse Link to post in-thread

Always highlight: 10 newest replies | Replies posted after I mark a forum
Replies to this discussion thread
Arrow 44 replies Author Time Post
WillyT Nov 2013 OP
WillyT Nov 2013 #1
billhicks76 Nov 2013 #10
JaneyVee Nov 2013 #2
SoLeftIAmRight Nov 2013 #3
duffyduff Nov 2013 #4
sabrina 1 Nov 2013 #18
Pretzel_Warrior Nov 2013 #28
HangOnKids Nov 2013 #29
Pretzel_Warrior Nov 2013 #30
HangOnKids Nov 2013 #32
Pretzel_Warrior Nov 2013 #33
HangOnKids Nov 2013 #34
laundry_queen Nov 2013 #41
DFW Nov 2013 #31
Mc Mike Nov 2013 #5
Bolo Boffin Nov 2013 #6
sabrina 1 Nov 2013 #19
Bolo Boffin Nov 2013 #20
sabrina 1 Nov 2013 #22
LineLineLineLineLineReply "Motive is extremely important in any murder case." I disagree.
Bolo Boffin Nov 2013 #27
sabrina 1 Nov 2013 #37
zappaman Nov 2013 #38
sabrina 1 Nov 2013 #39
zappaman Nov 2013 #40
Bolo Boffin Nov 2013 #43
Scuba Nov 2013 #7
Spider Jerusalem Nov 2013 #8
WillyT Nov 2013 #9
ancianita Nov 2013 #16
Mr.Bill Nov 2013 #17
Sognefjord Nov 2013 #24
Spider Jerusalem Nov 2013 #25
Spitfire of ATJ Nov 2013 #11
sabrina 1 Nov 2013 #21
Spider Jerusalem Nov 2013 #26
sabrina 1 Nov 2013 #35
RagAss Nov 2013 #12
sabrina 1 Nov 2013 #36
Booster Nov 2013 #13
Matilda Nov 2013 #14
JackRiddler Nov 2013 #23
laundry_queen Nov 2013 #42
ancianita Nov 2013 #15
underpants Nov 2013 #44
Please login to view edit histories.