Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

True Blue Door

(2,969 posts)
38. Your analogy between direct democracy and participation in representative democracy
Wed Oct 1, 2014, 01:45 PM
Oct 2014

is fallacious. You're comparing apples and coconuts. People don't participate very much in elections because their decision is so far removed from seeing the results that some people don't see the value - they're asked to cast a ballot once or twice every few years in order to pick a person who will fly hundreds or thousands of miles to a distant city and maybe, possibly, at some point in the ensuing 2, 4, or 6 years might mention the things they care about.

That's something radically different from people in their own communities, coming together to discuss what concerns them on a regular basis, and reach resolutions.

Moreover, you seem to be making some pretty severely circular arguments about the prevalence of such assemblies. "If they could be more prevalent, they would be" is a ludicrous position to take, and a definitively conservative attitude that shuts off all possibility of ever improving anything.

"Look, Mr. Franklin, the world is full of monarchies. With few exceptions, it always has been. Clearly that's the kind of government that works, and that's the government we need here in America. What you are proposing - this bizarre and laughable experiment in elective republic - would be doomed to chaos and failure."

People have no experience with assembly democracy. You have no basis to say they would reject it once they did, and in fact your examples argue against that conclusion: The evidence is that people who get a taste of it, want to keep doing it. Otherwise, why haven't those towns where it's practiced long ago just resigned their town meetings to elected officials? It's because free people don't do that when they know they're free. Only when politics becomes so far removed from their everyday lives that they see no difference between participating and not participating, and that's never the case when they're the ones making decisions.

Why not start direct democracy cities? [View all] True Blue Door Oct 2014 OP
Because Democracy means 500 million different things to 300 million citizens? randome Oct 2014 #1
That's kind of the point. True Blue Door Oct 2014 #2
Buying land, setting up infrastructure, all that costs money. randome Oct 2014 #3
I wasn't proposing working against the system. True Blue Door Oct 2014 #9
Sounds a lot like political messaging to me. Which is a good thing. randome Oct 2014 #11
Indeed, Occupy is the inspiration for the idea. True Blue Door Oct 2014 #16
That's a good idea, but where does the money come from MineralMan Oct 2014 #4
There are any number of ways. True Blue Door Oct 2014 #10
OK. Then I suggest you get started on this project. MineralMan Oct 2014 #14
Sorry, I'm poor. No property for me. True Blue Door Oct 2014 #17
Herding cats would be easier...nt greytdemocrat Oct 2014 #5
A new political party may be birthed: the Demo-cat-ic Party! randome Oct 2014 #6
Only if it fell victim to the counterculture BS I mentioned. True Blue Door Oct 2014 #12
people had to go back to school and it got cold outside snooper2 Oct 2014 #7
Heh, yeah that's pretty much the long and short of it. True Blue Door Oct 2014 #13
And the new iPhone came out nt Dreamer Tatum Oct 2014 #19
I don't think these experiments work out very well. DemocratSinceBirth Oct 2014 #8
Athens worked exceedingly well, for a while. True Blue Door Oct 2014 #15
I'm not sure I saw your definition of "direct democracy" anywhere in that word salad Dreamer Tatum Oct 2014 #18
I don't see how a literate adult could see it as "word salad". True Blue Door Oct 2014 #20
You have some writing skills, I'll grant you that. Dreamer Tatum Oct 2014 #22
Direct democracy: Open assemblies of citizens regularly debating and voting. True Blue Door Oct 2014 #24
That is clear as mud, and I am unfamiliar with the laws that currently forbid assembly. Dreamer Tatum Oct 2014 #25
There are no such laws. That's the point. True Blue Door Oct 2014 #26
I suspect you want people forcibly assembled. Dreamer Tatum Oct 2014 #27
Of course not. I want them to understand the value of the option. True Blue Door Oct 2014 #28
Isn't that called a ballot initiative tabbycat31 Oct 2014 #21
They're a start, certainly. True Blue Door Oct 2014 #23
Current human nature makes that sort of model difficult. NuclearDem Oct 2014 #29
As I note, we can experiment with different formulations. True Blue Door Oct 2014 #31
You may not be aware of this, but such a system already exists MineralMan Oct 2014 #30
Ah, thanks. I was only vaguely aware of it. True Blue Door Oct 2014 #32
You may be missing my point. MineralMan Oct 2014 #33
In more complex cities, it could function as a branch of government True Blue Door Oct 2014 #35
I am almost certain that a system like you describe will MineralMan Oct 2014 #36
Your analogy between direct democracy and participation in representative democracy True Blue Door Oct 2014 #38
But we do have experience with "assembly democracy." MineralMan Oct 2014 #41
If you know for certain that communities changed, how many? True Blue Door Oct 2014 #46
I don't have those numbers. You'll have to look them up yourself. MineralMan Oct 2014 #48
I wouldn't know where to look, and I suspect neither do you. True Blue Door Oct 2014 #49
How many people can participate in Direct Democracy...and how many want to? brooklynite Oct 2014 #34
The "how" comes after the decision to do it, not before. True Blue Door Oct 2014 #37
No, it doesn't brooklynite Oct 2014 #39
"Multi-layered"? That isn't what I said at all. It's as flat as a pancake. True Blue Door Oct 2014 #43
Not true NobodyHere Oct 2014 #42
No, it's like being born and THEN deciding what your career is going to be. True Blue Door Oct 2014 #44
Of all forms of govt I am aware of..... NCTraveler Oct 2014 #40
I don't think representation is mutually exclusive with direct democracy. True Blue Door Oct 2014 #45
Direct democracy never works tuhaybey Oct 2014 #47
How many words you just used are derived from the language of the Athenian Greeks? True Blue Door Oct 2014 #50
You aren't countering anything I said tuhaybey Oct 2014 #52
Take over an abandoned military base. hunter Oct 2014 #51
Or resort. KamaAina Oct 2014 #53
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Why not start direct demo...»Reply #38