In the discussion thread: Critizem of Bibi is no more anti-Semitic... [View all]
Response to dballance (Original post)
Wed Jan 14, 2015, 06:58 PM
Douglas Carpenter (20,226 posts)
22. if it is okay to criticize beliefs commonly held by Muslims - I really cannot understand why it is
not okay to criticize beliefs commonly held by many Jews. The notion of being a chosen people is not a marginal belief in Judaism. It is a fairly common belief. The notion that it is okay to establish a state in someone else's county because God gave it to them thousands of years ago is not a marginal belief. It is a common belief.
Okay, I realize not all Jews hold these beliefs. Just as I realize not all Muslims hold some of the less tasteful beliefs of Islam. But if we are going to be honest and say, "Okay we are not attacking Muslims - we are only attacking beliefs held by many Muslims" - Then why cannot we say, "Okay we are not attacking Jews - we are attacking beliefs held by many Jews." Surely, there has to be standard that allows attack on both systems of thinking while not attacking the individuals? |
Cannot reply in locked threads
Always highlight: 10 newest replies | Replies posted after I mark a forum
Replies to this discussion thread
![]() |
Author | Time | Post |
dballance | Jan 2015 | OP | |
JI7 | Jan 2015 | #1 | |
dballance | Jan 2015 | #2 | |
cali | Jan 2015 | #4 | |
dballance | Jan 2015 | #5 | |
PeaceNikki | Jan 2015 | #8 | |
Douglas Carpenter | Jan 2015 | #23 | |
herding cats | Jan 2015 | #6 | |
dballance | Jan 2015 | #10 | |
herding cats | Jan 2015 | #15 | |
JI7 | Jan 2015 | #16 | |
JI7 | Jan 2015 | #7 | |
dballance | Jan 2015 | #13 | |
JI7 | Jan 2015 | #14 | |
branford | Jan 2015 | #17 | |
Electric Monk | Jan 2015 | #19 | |
branford | Jan 2015 | #21 | |
cali | Jan 2015 | #3 | |
nilesobek | Jan 2015 | #9 | |
Mass | Jan 2015 | #11 | |
PCIntern | Jan 2015 | #12 | |
Electric Monk | Jan 2015 | #18 | |
A-Schwarzenegger | Jan 2015 | #20 | |
![]() ![]() |
Douglas Carpenter | Jan 2015 | #22 |
uppityperson | Jan 2015 | #24 |
Edit History
Please login to view edit histories.