Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

General Discussion

In reply to the discussion: H2O Man Survey #39 [View all]

Zorra

(27,670 posts)
17. Purest speculation, but I believe it is worth considering...
Sat Jul 25, 2015, 12:14 AM
Jul 2015

Last edited Sun Jul 26, 2015, 02:09 AM - Edit history (2)

Never before in the known history of the planet has any land been such a "melting pot" of differing strains of DNA as the US. People from almost every geographical region of the planet interbreed here, and have been doing so for hundreds of years.

mtDNA is passed from mother to daughter

YDNA is passed from father to son

Autosomal DNA is passed 50% from the mother and 50% from the father. Siblings get different mixes of their parents autosomal DNA. Meaning your sisters and brothers did not inherit the same mixes of DNA from your parents that you did. And none of your siblings have the same mix of autosomal DNA that each other does. Every child is different, regardless of the genetic makeup of the parents.

Anyway, could the rapid and repeated mixing of different autosomal DNA that originated in so many different geographical areas be responsible for causing genetic "wiring" malfunctions in certain people's brains when they get a certain autosomal mix?

I don't believe anything near like this long term sustained amount of mixing so many varieties of autosomal DNA at such a rapid rate as ever been done before.

If mutated autosomal dna can cause disease, why can't it flat out cause a propensity toward violence, or a propensity toward violence that can be triggered by stress or other environmental factors in certain individuals with the gene or genes that cause an environmentally triggered violence reaction?

Mother: Her father was Scottish, German, Romanian, and Russian. Her mother was Finnish, Italian, Greek, and Jewish.

Father: His father was Irish, Basque, Serbian, and Japanese, His mother was Native American, French, Estonian, and Tunisian.

Child: a wild mix of a whole bunch of different autosmal dna from all over the place, 50% of which comes from the mother, and 50% of which comes fro the father. Then the offspring with the wild mix of autosomal DNA mates with another offspring with a different wild mix of autosomal DNA, has offspring, and on and on and on.

And this kind of thing has been going on for hundreds of years in the US, and is diversifying exponentially each generation. And I don't believe anything remotely like this has happened before in human history.

No one can possibly know what all the potential effects of the different autosomes are, and how they could affect the human body, and our national population is growing rapidly, so the expression of a "wiring malfunction", a "violence gene" would be much more widespread today than it was 40 years ago. Canada is not really comparable, due to far less mixing and population, so there's nowhere in the world except for the US that has ever experienced this phenomenon.

Again, don't quote me on this, it's just pure speculation, an outside the box idea to consider.

H2O Man Survey #39 [View all] H2O Man Jul 2015 OP
I feel strongly that acknowledging and changing the way this country feels about race, its culture Brickbat Jul 2015 #1
Great answer -- thanks! H2O Man Jul 2015 #3
Definitely lots of overlap -- which makes it hard, because so many people just want to focus on one Brickbat Jul 2015 #8
Very important points. H2O Man Jul 2015 #36
Cultural and very little Motown_Johnny Jul 2015 #2
Interesting and well-said. H2O Man Jul 2015 #7
Too many people NV Whino Jul 2015 #10
there are far more densely populated places than here Motown_Johnny Jul 2015 #37
I have been to countries far more dense and a lot less violent.in fact USA is wide open spaces Person 2713 Jul 2015 #53
I think it is lack of economic opportunity notadmblnd Jul 2015 #4
Huge. H2O Man Jul 2015 #9
Part of it is always demographics, part of it is likely environmental lead Warpy Jul 2015 #5
Interesting. H2O Man Jul 2015 #38
Yeah, imagine being a cop, belt loaded with gear to abuse your fellow citizens, Warpy Jul 2015 #41
Right. H2O Man Jul 2015 #45
I'll give it a go. There is a high level of stress in this country right from shraby Jul 2015 #6
Good answer! H2O Man Jul 2015 #39
Great questions! Its economics, with unregulated capitolism, IMHO. kydo Jul 2015 #11
Gun ownership is just too fucking simple in too many places... catnhatnh Jul 2015 #12
heck, the planet's actual murder capital feels sorry for us at this point MisterP Jul 2015 #13
I think there's quite a few reasons. F4lconF16 Jul 2015 #14
Funny and true routine, thanks! Warpy Jul 2015 #28
I have to fall back on Justice Louis Brandeis. Downwinder Jul 2015 #15
I found some interested statistics.... CajunBlazer Jul 2015 #16
Purest speculation, but I believe it is worth considering... Zorra Jul 2015 #17
Man is an adaptable creature... kentuck Jul 2015 #18
IMO part of it is the way we educate our young in today's United States. Tommymac Jul 2015 #19
Every man a king in his own right... ellisonz Jul 2015 #20
IMO, it's a genetic issue. We have a too varied genetic pool and our melting CK_John Jul 2015 #21
A lot of good replies in this thread Hydra Jul 2015 #22
Sometimes I hate you as much as I love you for what you make me address. herding cats Jul 2015 #23
Gun violence sets us apart from our cultural peers. hay rick Jul 2015 #24
Depends on who you consider our "cultural peers" Recursion Jul 2015 #31
I suggest we look first to Lord of the Flies... Thespian2 Jul 2015 #25
And A Brave New World awoke_in_2003 Jul 2015 #50
Good point Thespian2 Jul 2015 #51
We also have to look into police violence. Unknown Beatle Jul 2015 #26
Many other countries also have better health care outcomes (and for far less money). merrily Jul 2015 #27
Culturally, we're a nation of toddlers. blogslut Jul 2015 #29
We aren't particularly world standouts for violence rates Recursion Jul 2015 #30
What Brickbat said plus malaise Jul 2015 #32
We have a cottage industry of hate in this country. Vinca Jul 2015 #33
Many poignant and profound contributions PuraVidaDreamin Jul 2015 #34
A major problem: the existence of the Second Amendment. Nay Jul 2015 #35
I'm not sure about that CajunBlazer Jul 2015 #44
Lead JonLP24 Jul 2015 #40
don't know the primary causes G_j Jul 2015 #42
Inequality of Income and Depression of Citizen's Rights. KoKo Jul 2015 #43
Testosterone n/t Holly_Hobby Jul 2015 #46
Clever apes in complex systems Fairgo Jul 2015 #47
We have looked at the issue carefully nadinbrzezinski Jul 2015 #48
If a politician is receiving funds fadedrose Jul 2015 #49
The US has literally always been at war. guillaumeb Jul 2015 #52
America has been an aggressively violent country since day one MrScorpio Jul 2015 #54
I may be ridiculed for my comment but at least am honest! akbacchus_BC Jul 2015 #55
I think it is, for the most part, a cultural problem. LWolf Jul 2015 #56
This message was self-deleted by its author Alkene Jul 2015 #57
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»H2O Man Survey #39»Reply #17