Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

polly7

(20,582 posts)
108. Didn't like that, too complicated?
Wed Sep 30, 2015, 10:46 PM
Sep 2015

Sorry about that. Just answering to your lie.

Here, DU'er KoKo posted a great article you might enjoy:


How the US Helped ISIS---Recently Declassified Document Reveals


A recently declassified document again shows the United States’ complicity in the rise of ISIS.

By David Mizner

June 02, 2015 "Information Clearing House" - "Jacobin" - In October 2014, Vice President Joe Biden publicly criticized US allies for backing ISIS. The previous month, General Dempsey had told the Senate Armed Services Committee that America’s “Arab allies” were funding the group.

US officials were trying to distance themselves from the ISIS-supporting actions of their allies without harshly condemning them. Biden suggested that their arming of ISIS was unintentional and quickly apologized to them. (Responding to Dempsey, Senator Lindsey Graham actually defended them: “They were trying to beat Assad. I believe they realize the folly of their ways.”)

This mild criticism of allies came amid the effort of American officials to sell the decision to start bombing ISIS. By this time, the group was already entrenched in eastern Syria and western Iraq. But there’s no evidence that in the months and years prior, the Obama administration had made any attempt to prevent its client states from helping ISIS become a regional power.

The United States itself continued to send arms into Syria despite the certainty that some would end up in the hands of ISIS. “We have good relations with our brothers in the FSA,” said ISIS leader Abu Atheer in 2013, referring to the US-backed Free Syrian Army. He said ISIS bought anti-aircraft missiles and anti-tank weapons from the FSA.

A recently declassified US military intelligence document is further evidence of US complicity. Formerly classified as “secret,” an August 2012 Defense Intelligence Agency report was among a batch of documents obtained by the conservative group Judicial Watch.

The mainstream press and Republican politicians have focused on other documents in the collection: those related to the 2012 attack on the US Consulate in Benghazi, Libya. Largely overlooked is this document, which contradicts the official narrative not just about the rise of ISIS but also the makeup of the opposition in Syria and its relationship with foreign backers.

“The August 5, 2012 DIA report confirms much of what Assad has been saying all along about his opponents both inside and outside Syria,” says “terrorism analyst” Max Abrams.

The report concerns a period in time when the escalating violence in Iraq had ceased to be a prominent topic in the US press and when its coverage of the war in Syria — mirroring the discussion in Washington — focused on the Assad government, not the forces aligned against it. This may be hard to imagine now that ISIS has become the US government’s favorite monster, but during these months President Obama and his team gave major speeches on Syria that didn’t even mention the group.

Even after ISIS took Fallujah in January 2014, discussion of the group in establishment outlets was scarce. It wasn’t until later in 2014 — after continued battlefield victories and heavily publicized beheadings of westerners — that Islamic State became Public Enemy Number 1.

More of a Long Read at........

http://www.informationclearinghouse.info/article42026.htm

http://www.democraticunderground.com/11339855



MONDAY, MARCH 2, 2015: Noam Chomsky: After Dangerous Proxy War, Keeping...
Noam Chomsky on How the Iraq War Birthed ISIS & Why U.S. Policy Undermines the Fight Against It


(VIDEO)

As Iraq launches a new military operation to retake the city of Tikrit from the self-proclaimed Islamic State, thousands of Iraqi forces and militia fighters have converged in the city Samarra to strike nearby ISIS strongholds. The United States is expected to provide air support as part of its continued bombing campaign. The offensive comes as the Iraqi military prepares for a major U.S.-backed operation to retake Mosul from ISIS in the coming weeks. ISIS "is one of the results of the United States hitting a very vulnerable society with a sledgehammer, which elicited sectarian conflicts that had not existed," says Noam Chomsky. "It is hard to see how Iraq can even be held together at this point. It has been devastated by U.S. sanctions, the war, the atrocities that followed from it. The current policy, whatever it is, is not very likely to even patch up or even put band-aids on a cancer."

TRANSCRIPT

This is a rush transcript. Copy may not be in its final form.


NOAM CHOMSKY: Patrick Cockburn, who has done by far the best reporting on this, describes it as an Alice in Wonderland strategy. The U.S. wants to destroy ISIS, but it’s opposing every force that’s fighting ISIS. So, the main state that’s opposed to ISIS is Iran. They support the Iraqi government, the Shiite government. But Iran is, you know, on our enemies list. Probably the main ground forces fighting ISIS are the PKK and its allies, which are on the U.S. terrorist list. That’s both in Iraq and in Syria. Saudi Arabia, our major ally, along with Israel, is both traditionally, for a long time, the main funder of ISIS and similar groups—not necessarily the government; rich Saudis, other people in the emirates—not only the funder, but they’re the ideological source. Saudi Arabia is committed, is dominated by an extremist fundamentalist version of Islam: Wahhabi doctrine. And ISIS is an extremist offshoot of the Wahhabi doctrine. Saudi Arabia is a missionary state. It establishes schools, mosques, spreading its radical Islamic version. So, they’re our ally. Our enemies are those who are fighting ISIS. And it’s more complex.

ISIS is a monstrosity. There’s not much doubt about that. It didn’t come from nowhere. It’s one of the results of the U.S. hitting a very vulnerable society—Iraq—with a sledgehammer, which elicited sectarian conflicts that had not existed. They became very violent. The U.S. violence made it worse. We’re all familiar with the crimes. Out of this came lots of violent, murderous forces. ISIS is one. But the Shiite militias are not that different. They’re carrying out—they’re the kind of the—when they say the Iraqi army is attacking, it’s probably mostly the Shiite militias with the Iraqi army in the background. I mean, the way the Iraqi army collapsed is an astonishing military fact. This is an army of, I think, 350,000 people, heavily armed by the United States and trained by the United States for 10 years. A couple of thousand guerrillas showed up, and they all ran away. The generals ran away first. And the soldiers didn’t know to do. They ran away after them.


http://www.democracynow.org/2015/3/2/noam_chomsky_on_how_the_iraq


By Mnar Muhawesh @mnarmuh | September 9, 2015

Editor’s note: This article has been updated to reflect recent Wikileaks revelations of US State Department leaks that show plans to destabilize Syria and overthrow the Syrian government as early as 2006. The leaks reveal that these plans were given to the US directly from the Israeli government and would be formalized through instigating civil strife and sectarianism through partnership with nations like Saudi Arabia, Turkey, Qatar and even Egypt to break down the power structue in Syria to essentially to weaken Iran and Hezbolla. The leaks also reveal Israeli plans to use this crisis to expand it’s occupation of the Golan Heights for additional oil exploration and military expansion.

While there’s certainly a conversation taking place about refugees — who they are, where they’re going, who’s helping them, and who isn’t — what’s absent is a discussion on how to prevent these wars from starting in the first place. Media outlets and political talking heads have found many opportunities to point fingers in the blame game, but not one media organization has accurately broken down what’s driving the chaos: control over gas, oil and resources.

Indeed, it’s worth asking: How did demonstrations held by “hundreds” of protesters demanding economic change in Syria four years ago devolve into a deadly sectarian civil war, fanning the flames of extremism haunting the world today and creating the world’s second largest refugee crisis?


This “civil war” is not about religion

Foreign meddling in Syria began several years before the Syrian revolt erupted. Wikieaks released leaked US State Department cables from 2006 revealing US plans to overthrow the Syrian government through instigating civil strife, and receiving these very orders straight from Tel Aviv. The leaks reveal the United State’s partnership with nations like Saudi Arabia, Turkey, Qatar and even Egypt to use sectarianism to divide Syria through the Sunni and Shiite divide to destabilize the nation to weaken Iran and Hezbolla. Israel is also revealed to attempt to use this crisis to expand it’s occupation of the Golan Heights for additional oil exploration.

According to major media outlets like the BBC and the Associated Press, the demonstrations that supposedly swept Syria were comprised of only hundreds of people, but additional Wikileaks cables reveal CIA involvement on the ground in Syria to instigate these very demonstrations as early as March 2011.


But it’s important to note the timing: This coalition and meddling in Syria came about immediately on the heels of discussions of an Iran-Iraq-Syria gas pipeline that was to be built between 2014 and 2016 from Iran’s giant South Pars field through Iraq and Syria. With a possible extension to Lebanon, it would eventually reach Europe, the target export market.

Perhaps the most accurate description of the current crisis over gas, oil and pipelines that is raging in Syria has been described by Dmitry Minin, writing for the Strategic Cultural Foundation in May 2013: ..........



Note the purple line which traces the proposed Qatar-Turkey natural gas pipeline and note that all of the countries highlighted in red are part of a new coalition hastily put together after Turkey finally (in exchange for NATO’s acquiescence on Erdogan’s politically-motivated war with the PKK) agreed to allow the US to fly combat missions against ISIS targets from Incirlik. Now note which country along the purple line is not highlighted in red. That’s because Bashar al-Assad didn’t support the pipeline and now we’re seeing what happens when you’re a Mid-East strongman and you decide not to support something the US and Saudi Arabia want to get done. (Map: ZeroHedge.com)

Divide and conquer: A path to regime change: ( ........... read more.)


Refugee’s assist a fellow Refugee holding a boy as they are stuck between Macedonian riot police officers and refugees during a clash near the border train station of Idomeni, northern Greece, as they wait to be allowed by the Macedonian police to cross the border from Greece to Macedonia, Friday, Aug. 21, 2015. Macedonian special police forces have fired stun grenades to disperse thousands of refugees stuck on a no-man’s land with Greece, a day after Macedonia declared a state of emergency on its borders to deal with a massive influx of refugees heading north to Europe. (AP Photo/Darko Vojinovic)

http://www.mintpressnews.com/migrant-crisis-syria-war-fueled-by-competing-gas-pipelines/209294/


The Wicked War on Syria

by Rick Sterling / September 29th, 2015

This description is widespread but misleading. In his 2007 article Seymour Hersh exposed the U.S. promotion of Sunni fundamentalists to undermine Syria and Iran. In 2010 Secretary of State Clinton pressed Syrian President Bashar al Assad to comply with Israeli and US calls to stop supporting the Lebanese resistance and break relations with Iran. Was Clinton especially hostile to the Syrian President because he did not comply with her requests/demands and soon after forged an agreement with Iran? She makes no mention of this in her book but it is obviously relevant to the issue of Syria-USA relations.

Regarding the so-called peaceful protesters, in fact, there was a violent element from the start. In Deraa in March 2011 several police were killed. In the original “capital of the revolution”, Homs, a very credible eye-witness reported armed demonstrators initiating the violence.


The solution is not impossible. What is wicked is the devastation of Syria by some of the wealthiest and most powerful countries in the world. What is wicked is the justification of this on a “humanitarian” pretense. The solution simply requires countries such as the USA and allies to stop their illegal and destructive efforts to overthrow any government they don’t like. It’s up to the people of Syria to determine their government. It’s time for the United Nations and genuine humanitarian organizations to demand the end of this war so that Syrians can start reconciliation and rebuilding.


Full article: http://dissidentvoice.org/2015/09/the-wicked-war-on-syria/


And another little video for you:

I'm not sure I am unhappy about all of this. I think we should let the Russian's own it. stevenleser Sep 2015 #1
ISIS was created by the power vacuum induced by the catastrophic polly7 Sep 2015 #9
...! KoKo Sep 2015 #13
Yes they were. And? nt stevenleser Sep 2015 #16
And ........... polly7 Sep 2015 #17
No hypocrisy. Obama did not invade Iraq. We don't need another quagmire. stevenleser Sep 2015 #18
'The quagmire' was caused by the brutal destruction of a nation long on polly7 Sep 2015 #19
Your posts are a rapidly accelerating gish gallop of unfocused points and accusations. stevenleser Sep 2015 #22
And your posts are a rapidly accelerating attempt to polly7 Sep 2015 #27
LOL, good luck with that interpretation. nt stevenleser Sep 2015 #29
Yes, it's all a huge laugh. polly7 Sep 2015 #30
As always, trying to mischaracterize other folks posts laughing at your lack of logic stevenleser Sep 2015 #32
Nah ................ I don't really care about anyone laughing at me, polly7 Sep 2015 #34
that's good because LOL once again uhnope Sep 2015 #88
Just Gross. polly7 Sep 2015 #100
you didn't answer. Is Assad, like Gaddafi was, a good guy in your book uhnope Sep 2015 #102
I never said Gaddafi was a 'good guy'. Stop lying. polly7 Sep 2015 #103
oh jeez. a huge dump that was. Okay to play your game.... uhnope Sep 2015 #107
Didn't like that, too complicated? polly7 Sep 2015 #108
so you won't answer. LOL. Omission is a LIE also, did you know that? uhnope Sep 2015 #111
I don't answer to your ugly lies and innuendo. polly7 Sep 2015 #112
you were an apologist for Gaddafi and now for Assad. And for the homophobic fascist Putin uhnope Sep 2015 #113
You're disgusting. Period. nt. polly7 Sep 2015 #115
Very graphic jamzrockz Sep 2015 #118
Thanks jamzrockz ... polly7 Sep 2015 #119
It's stunning how people refuse to admit Bush started this. It would be too hard to bettyellen Sep 2015 #37
WHO refused to admit Bush started this??? polly7 Sep 2015 #38
For some folks, when the truth doesn't suit their agenda, it's OK to just make stuff up. stevenleser Sep 2015 #39
Yes ........... exactly. polly7 Sep 2015 #42
I'm not the one who can't get right the group that started the Iraq war. You've changed it several stevenleser Sep 2015 #47
ZZZZZzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz. polly7 Sep 2015 #48
Yep! The "west" instead of Bush is willfully deceptive..... bettyellen Sep 2015 #49
Lmfao. nt. polly7 Sep 2015 #50
Who mentioned any of that? polly7 Sep 2015 #52
You need to calm down. We've seen dozens of posts here laying this all at HRC and BO's feet with no bettyellen Sep 2015 #56
And you need to stop making shit up that wasn't mentioned. It's dishonest polly7 Sep 2015 #57
Just agreeing with Steve that this "the West" stuff is bullshit.... bettyellen Sep 2015 #58
Ok, Bush and PNAC represented the East. polly7 Sep 2015 #59
It's nice you're willing to be specific when pressed, thanks! bettyellen Sep 2015 #60
It's disappointing an adult would believe Bush represented the east, polly7 Sep 2015 #61
Not sure why you heard that one- a delusion I guess. bettyellen Sep 2015 #65
Are you hearing things? I'm not. polly7 Sep 2015 #67
Happy? angry? You flatter yourself. And babble on about the east as if someone bettyellen Sep 2015 #69
You're boring. nt. polly7 Sep 2015 #71
You're usually mildly amusing. Not this time, but often! bettyellen Sep 2015 #77
Slowly I turned ... step by step ... inch by inch... betsuni Sep 2015 #104
Good for you. polly7 Sep 2015 #105
Clean your mirror. nt. polly7 Sep 2015 #120
Agree with you. 840high Sep 2015 #41
Thank you. :) nt. polly7 Sep 2015 #43
Yeah, that was a stupid game of semantic nit-picking. Comrade Grumpy Sep 2015 #72
And getting stupider and stupider all the time. polly7 Sep 2015 #74
Much gallop today! bettyellen Sep 2015 #78
And without a point. Reread that persons posts and see if you can detect an overall stevenleser Sep 2015 #82
Awwies ............. polly7 Sep 2015 #106
The point is to derail towards some imaginary conversation they'd prefer to have. bettyellen Oct 2015 #125
Snooze. nt. polly7 Sep 2015 #109
Russia is bombing the fuck out of opponents to the brutal dictator Assad uhnope Sep 2015 #87
"Russia is bombing the fuck out of opponents to the brutal dictator Assad" Jesus Malverde Sep 2015 #92
Russia is bombing the moderates uhnope Sep 2015 #95
Moderate terrorists Jesus Malverde Sep 2015 #96
you think it's funny that moderate opponents are being slaughtered and you call them terrorists? uhnope Sep 2015 #97
There are no moderates only zealots fighting Assad, Jesus Malverde Sep 2015 #98
The Russians are next in line for a failed unconventional war. Rex Sep 2015 #84
Yep, let 'em have it with our compliments stevenleser Sep 2015 #86
Russia is bombing anti-Assad forces but not ISL denbot Sep 2015 #2
^^^ moondust Sep 2015 #11
^^^ ellisonz Sep 2015 #62
based on our actions and who is funding ISIS GreatGazoo Sep 2015 #3
...! KoKo Sep 2015 #12
So we underestimated Assad or Puzzledtraveller Sep 2015 #91
see post #8 for a more complete picture of ISIS GreatGazoo Sep 2015 #99
Hands were tied. Xolodno Sep 2015 #4
Or, with luck, those radicals will go back to KSA ozone_man Sep 2015 #7
We did a lot more than just train the rebels - we flew bombing missions just like Russia and karynnj Sep 2015 #5
...! KoKo Sep 2015 #14
Russia has had troops in Syria since 1971 and they just added to them GreatGazoo Sep 2015 #21
Even before the first shot was fired in Daraa on 3/18/11, the opposition was armed leveymg Sep 2015 #64
Thank you for dissecting the convenient narrative of all this all began. Comrade Grumpy Sep 2015 #114
Thank you, leveymg. nt. polly7 Sep 2015 #116
Putin isn't doing this to "fight ISIS" Blue_Tires Sep 2015 #6
it may not be Putin's top reason but fighting ISIS is part of the mix GreatGazoo Sep 2015 #20
The Uses of ISIS polly7 Sep 2015 #8
...! KoKo Sep 2015 #15
Thank you KoKo! nt. polly7 Sep 2015 #40
Seems about right. ozone_man Sep 2015 #51
Thank you ozone_man. :) nt. polly7 Sep 2015 #53
+1 GreatGazoo Sep 2015 #85
Thanks for the article GreatGazoo! nt. polly7 Sep 2015 #101
this is not america's affair... best to take this opportunity to stay far away... KG Sep 2015 #10
if Russia wants to run the Afghanistan/Vietnam/Iraq playbook in hopes geek tragedy Sep 2015 #23
Exactly what I was saying upthread. Have at it Vladimir Vladimirovich. stevenleser Sep 2015 #24
please proceed, president for life nt geek tragedy Sep 2015 #25
Yes, take it with our blessing. What will be interesting going forward is... stevenleser Sep 2015 #28
they've already excused Assad's abuses, they still insist he's innocent geek tragedy Sep 2015 #31
Yep. I really expect very little good or honesty from that crowd. stevenleser Sep 2015 #46
Russia appears to be doing exactly the same thing we are in Syria. Comrade Grumpy Sep 2015 #55
Russia is there to shore up Assad. There's little sign they're going after ISIS as opposed geek tragedy Sep 2015 #66
I don't particularly care which jihadists they're bombing. Comrade Grumpy Sep 2015 #73
Agree with you 100%. nt. polly7 Sep 2015 #75
Assad is their last remaining asset in the region. geek tragedy Sep 2015 #76
To be fair, it's difficult to have an open and democratic society killbotfactory Sep 2015 #110
The Ba'ath regime in Syria has been around for decades geek tragedy Sep 2015 #117
This war has nothing to do with human rights. killbotfactory Oct 2015 #122
Thank you. nt. polly7 Oct 2015 #123
I do not share your eagerness to make excuses geek tragedy Oct 2015 #124
I make no excuses for the actions of Bush or Cheney. nt killbotfactory Oct 2015 #127
No, you only make excuses for Assad and Putin. nt geek tragedy Oct 2015 #128
I opposed the Iraq War, too. I guess that makes me a Saddam apologist. killbotfactory Oct 2015 #129
I opposed the Iraq war, and I don't lick the boots of Assad and Putin. geek tragedy Oct 2015 #130
The option here is secular dictatorship vs. radical Islamic caliphate. killbotfactory Oct 2015 #131
That's the current choice because that's how Assad engineered it. geek tragedy Oct 2015 #132
most governments will try to maintain power when faced with violent revolution. killbotfactory Oct 2015 #133
Assad used violence against peaceful protestors. geek tragedy Oct 2015 #134
Better Russia than us. I am very concerned about the innocents still_one Sep 2015 #26
If Russia can handle it, so be it. romanic Sep 2015 #33
I'm with you Puzzledtraveller Sep 2015 #93
At one point Proud Liberal Dem Sep 2015 #35
Not only Congress, but the American people as well. Some of us have "selective" memories, or.... Tarheel_Dem Sep 2015 #80
Let it be Pooty Pott's problem treestar Sep 2015 #36
They are. 840high Sep 2015 #44
Actually, it's the Russians who just sat on their hands for too long. KamaAina Sep 2015 #45
you wrote underthematrix Sep 2015 #54
You got my quote correct then made a weird left turn into no man's land GummyBearz Sep 2015 #63
Message auto-removed Name removed Sep 2015 #68
Russia won't hit ISIS directly davidn3600 Sep 2015 #70
I have a couple of posts with my thoughts fadedrose Sep 2015 #79
One despicable dictator covering the ass of another. Who coulda guessed? Tarheel_Dem Sep 2015 #81
It is strange watching a dictator clean up an unruly mess made by the Bush administration. Rex Sep 2015 #83
Our current admin stoked the flames too. Puzzledtraveller Sep 2015 #90
We need to figure out why the hell we are still in Afghanistan. Rex Oct 2015 #121
Russia indeed has more of an interest in seeing Isis squashed. Puzzledtraveller Sep 2015 #89
The monster was created by our friends. Jesus Malverde Sep 2015 #94
Since it turned out that whacking Saddam and Gaddhafi Jake Stern Oct 2015 #126
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Russia has started bombin...»Reply #108