He was one of nine and without a title. Justices die all the time. Most on the bench, because (Reply #14)

In the discussion thread: A note about attendance at Scalia's Memorial [View all]

Thu Feb 18, 2016, 12:22 PM

MADem (135,425 posts)

14. He was one of nine and without a title. Justices die all the time. Most on the bench, because

they don't have the decency to retire when they feel a little wobbly.

Thurgood Marshall and Clinton and Gore AGREED on much. You can't draw a comparison to them. Also, Thurgood Marshall's SON worked in the Clinton White House. He also worked for Al Gore when Al was a Senator, AND he was a campaign manager during at least one of the Clinton-Gore elections. So, you see, it's not just a POTUS and VPOTUS thing--there's a personal relationship that precedes the WH.

Scalia couldn't carry TM's bags. TM's mark on America was positive and game-changing. Scalia's contribution codified graft and "business as usual" in the worst sense of the term into law.

Gore gave a scripture reading at that funeral. http://www.c-span.org/video/?37494-1/justice-thurgood-marshall-memorial-service It was an appropriate one.

There's no "lost opportunity" with Scalia. The maxim applies: If you can't say anything nice, don't say anything at all.

Reply to this post

Back to OP Alert abuse Link to post in-thread

Always highlight: 10 newest replies | Replies posted after I mark a forum

Replies to this discussion thread

23 replies	Author	Time	Post
A note about attendance at Scalia's Memorial [View all]	jberryhill	Feb 2016	OP
Also, Biden's got more experience at stake-driving... you know, just in case	Bucky	Feb 2016	#1
POTUS and VPOTUS have appeared together publicly at funerals.	MADem	Feb 2016	#2
Right. And the Church where the funeral service is being held is used to high profile events	onenote	Feb 2016	#5
A good reason to not attend is to make it plain that Scalia and Obama had nothing in common.	MADem	Feb 2016	#6
It's supposed to be about the office	SickOfTheOnePct	Feb 2016	#8
Office? What office? He wasn't the chief justice. He was just one dude warming the bench.	MADem	Feb 2016	#9
He was the senior member of the court, having served nearly 30 years and Obama doesn't need to speak	onenote	Feb 2016	#10
He was one of nine and without a title. Justices die all the time. Most on the bench, because	MADem	Feb 2016	#14
Since 1993, seven Justices have died. Two had funerals outside DC	onenote	Feb 2016	#18
"which is invitation only"	jberryhill	Feb 2016	#22
Giving that explanation would be far better than giving no explanation.	onenote	Feb 2016	#23
For Obama it would be overkill to go to the funeral after paying his respects at the viewing	pinboy3niner	Feb 2016	#3
The conspiracy theorists will have their field day, won't they?	MADem	Feb 2016	#7
Then the better decision would be to attend the funeral	onenote	Feb 2016	#11
Obama knows many Scalia family and friends wouldn't welcome it?	lostnfound	Feb 2016	#12
Except by not attending the funeral has in effect become a focal point of irrational hate.	onenote	Feb 2016	#13
His attendance would produce the same irrational hate.	LanternWaste	Feb 2016	#15
Yup	jberryhill	Feb 2016	#17
And if it did, it would a win for the President	onenote	Feb 2016	#19
And, here we are, talking about someone's funeral as a "win" or "loss"	jberryhill	Feb 2016	#21
Sorry, but not everything is strategy with Obama.He went because he should. He's potus.	lindysalsagal	Feb 2016	#4
All good facts. I really don't understand the kerfluffle over this issue.	Rex	Feb 2016	#16
he needs to go...it will only hinder the nomination process as it's more ammunition	Demonaut	Feb 2016	#20

Edit History

Please login to view edit histories.