General Discussion

MichMary

(1,714 posts)

18. This is just a guess, but

Thu Jun 22, 2017, 12:09 PM

Jun 2017

for a FEW states (California, New York, etc.) this would be an overwhelmingly great idea, and readily accepted. But, much of the rest of the country is pretty evenly divided. If this were part of the party platform in solidly red states, or even in states like Wisconsin or Michigan (which actually had a voice in deciding this election) I think it would bring out the R voters like NOTHING else ever would. You would be taking power from states that don't want to give it up.

Edit history

Please sign in to view edit histories.

40 replies

= new reply since forum marked as read

Highlight:

Why are there no Dems pushing to get rid of the electorial college? [View all] LakeArenal Jun 2017 OP

I just want my vote to be able to be recounted. The Wielding Truth Jun 2017 #1

Most likely because they are in the minority and the majority brings bills to the floor. shraby Jun 2017 #2

It would require a Constitutional amendment... jberryhill Jun 2017 #3

It's the Electoral College, not the 'electorial college.' MineralMan Jun 2017 #4

Thanks Mineral Man.. LakeArenal Jun 2017 #10

My pleasure. I try to clarify, whenever I can. MineralMan Jun 2017 #11

Clarified it for me, as well.....thanks! Heartstrings Jun 2017 #15

Political capital. Act_of_Reparation Jun 2017 #5

Because you need Republican votes to do it and they won't. hrmjustin Jun 2017 #6

Because getting rid of the Electoral College is a non-starter... LesterKasai Jun 2017 #7

Exactly. But good luck convincing folks of that. We need to concentrate on GOTV Hoyt Jun 2017 #12

Excellent post & no ridicule is merited. I distinctly remember all the Dems after Coup 2000 standing UTUSN Jun 2017 #8

Do you know what it would take to get rid of the EC? MichMary Jun 2017 #9

Actions are being pursued at the state level Gothmog Jun 2017 #13

If we win back enough state govs in 2018 it will prolly happen Tiggeroshii Jun 2017 #23

I am hoping that you are right Gothmog Jun 2017 #37

Me too Tiggeroshii Jun 2017 #39

You got it Gothmog - the process is moving along:: vkkv Jun 2017 #34

I strongly support the National Popular Vote movement and plan Gothmog Jun 2017 #36

+1,000 Tiggeroshii Jun 2017 #40

I appreciate all the comments. And learned a lot. LakeArenal Jun 2017 #14

This is just a guess, but MichMary Jun 2017 #18

I am in one of those states.... LakeArenal Jun 2017 #20

In literary terms, it's called tilting at windmills... Wounded Bear Jun 2017 #16

Because it requires a constitutional amendment, which won't happen. DanTex Jun 2017 #17

Understand that it's a huge pie in the sky... LakeArenal Jun 2017 #19

Actually we are just 5 states passing laws from doing that Tiggeroshii Jun 2017 #21

Huh? How do you figure that? n/t MichMary Jun 2017 #24

States worth 170 ecs have passed laws committing their ecs to the popular vote winner Tiggeroshii Jun 2017 #25

Okay, I see, but-- MichMary Jun 2017 #26

not sure exactly which ones Tiggeroshii Jun 2017 #27

Check this site out for an update on their progress Tiggeroshii Jun 2017 #30

This message was self-deleted by its author WillowTree Jun 2017 #28

This message was self-deleted by its author ismnotwasm Jun 2017 #22

It requires an amendment to the Constitution Progressive dog Jun 2017 #29

Not quite Tiggeroshii Jun 2017 #31

States can change their own laws at any point. Progressive dog Jun 2017 #33

True enough Tiggeroshii Jun 2017 #38

Because it requires a Constitutional Amendment, and doesn't have the votes still_one Jun 2017 #32

As amazing as this seems, at this point it would be EASIER to take back the House and Senate bottomofthehill Jun 2017 #35