Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Yupster

(14,308 posts)
38. Good luck in your research
Sun Aug 27, 2017, 12:22 PM
Aug 2017

There is quite a bit already written about Jews in the Confederacy. I think you'll find that they fought for the same patriotic reasons as their neighbors. When their states left the Union and formed a new nation, and that nation went to war, they went to war with it just like their non-Jewish friends and neighbors did.

The other thing I think needs research though is what the federal government meant to people in 1860. The relationship between the people and the federal government was so different from the world today that it needs to be understood to understand the times back then. The average person today deals with the federal government all the time, but back then, think of a world without income taxes, national parks, social security, medicare, medicaid, unemployment, food stamps and even food and drug regulations.

I have my own academic interest in the Confederacy. I have studied the Confederate Constitution. It is the only time that a group of learned men ever looked at the US Constitution and decided what to keep and what to change. They met in committees for weeks, groups of former congressmen, senators, and judges and in the end didn't make many changes. They even decided to keep the electoral college. They did decide a president can't run for reelection and got one six year term. They put in a line item veto.

Anyway, good luck in your research from this old history teacher and textbook author.

They are professional haters that's what they do Bladewire Aug 2017 #1
I made a meme about this SHRED Aug 2017 #2
Fortunately, Judah Benjamin never noticed it Pope George Ringo II Aug 2017 #3
They didn't feel threatened by Jews because so few were in the country LeftInTX Aug 2017 #17
A bit of a side note. Somewhat contra-intuitive, but South Carolina in particular seems to have GeoWilliam750 Aug 2017 #20
Probably the right sequence. Pope George Ringo II Aug 2017 #27
He held several cabinet positions before it was over. Abu Pepe Aug 2017 #30
Things were a little fluid for the CSA, it's true. Pope George Ringo II Aug 2017 #33
FUCK THEM! shenmue Aug 2017 #4
Well, yeah, if you count the murder of Leo Frank . . . . no_hypocrisy Aug 2017 #5
The march had nothing to do with Confederate Heritage oberliner Aug 2017 #6
It' is just a bunch of racists. Anybody with any pigment in their outer layer.... pangaia Aug 2017 #7
The funny thing is, I doubt very much that most of these people even know smirkymonkey Aug 2017 #28
Yes you are right. pangaia Aug 2017 #36
The Klan hated Jewish people as much as Blacks. Hoyt Aug 2017 #8
For a long time it hated Catholics too dflprincess Aug 2017 #12
I know. There is pride in something like that. Hoyt Aug 2017 #16
I think they allowed Catholics because their membership was dwindling LeftInTX Aug 2017 #19
Wonder why the KKK started accepting Catholics? keithbvadu2 Aug 2017 #25
That would be the Klan of 1915 or so Yupster Aug 2017 #21
All I can tell you is that in the 1950s and early 1960s there was a guy Hoyt Aug 2017 #37
Frankly, I don't think people give a shit either way. Behind the Aegis Aug 2017 #9
the alt-right view Jews as the arch-enemy of the white race radius777 Aug 2017 #10
These fuckers are not modern confederates GulfCoast66 Aug 2017 #11
The Confederate Secretary of State was Jewish. CanonRay Aug 2017 #13
The Hebrew Confederate Cemetery Jopin Klobe Aug 2017 #14
so to understand this heaven05 Aug 2017 #15
Hardly Yupster Aug 2017 #22
I will research heaven05 Aug 2017 #23
I'd suggest it probably has some comparison to Irish in British service Pope George Ringo II Aug 2017 #31
interesting heaven05 Aug 2017 #32
Herd instinct does strange things in predator omnivores. Pope George Ringo II Aug 2017 #35
Good luck in your research Yupster Aug 2017 #38
I'm Jewish and it was horribly eye opening to find out this did happen. mucifer Aug 2017 #26
That is horrible Not Ruth Aug 2017 #34
It is part of the KKKs heritage LeftInTX Aug 2017 #18
They hated everyone who isn't white and Protestant underpants Aug 2017 #29
So is lynching African-Americans malaise Aug 2017 #24
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Killing Jews is part of C...»Reply #38