Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Xithras

(16,191 posts)
27. Not Telenav, but otherwise dead on. It's the worst, and iPhone users will be unhappy.
Tue Jun 12, 2012, 04:04 PM
Jun 2012

Google Maps originally used mapping data from a Dutch company called Tele Atlas (not Telenav, which is a different company). Tele Atlas is a subsidiary of TomTom. Mapquest was also heavily built on Tele Atlas data, as was the Microsoft mapping engine used by Bing and its predecessor MSN Maps.

The mapping data was so bad that Google bailed on their five year contract less than 18 months after their last renewal, instead using a combination of their own mapping data and data from Navteq and Telenav. Mapquest followed suit a year later, abandoning them for Navteq, and Microsoft dumped them in 2009. All cited the same thing...inaccurate mapping data.

It's wierd that Apple chose Tele Atlas as their mapping data source, as they have a reputation of having one of the worst mapping datasets for North America. Nearly anyone with a Tom Tom can tell you a horror story about being turned the wrong way down a one way road, or being directed into a parking lot that the software thought was a street, or being directed to drive their car down a walking path or unpaved road...or, in my case, being told that I had "reached my destination" as I was in the middle lane of an 8 lane freeway (my destination was in a business park alongside the freeway that could only be accessed by taking the PREVIOUS exit and following a frontage road). I trashed my TomTom in exchange for Google Maps specifically because Google was more accurate.

Basing the new iOS map application on TomTom is going to come back to bite Apple in the ass. The quality will be far below what Apple users have come to expect.

I mean, the data is so bad that even Microsoft wouldn't use it anymore. That's gotta say SOMETHING!

Big Brother Google high density Jun 2012 #1
So Google should control all data? onehandle Jun 2012 #8
I love watching people respond to statements that weren't even made. (nt) Posteritatis Jun 2012 #11
Why can't they let the consumer decide ChromeFoundry Jun 2012 #12
Im sure you will be able to download any app you want FreeState Jun 2012 #14
Google Maps will still be 'free' on the iPhone. onehandle Jun 2012 #15
I think between Google and Facebook, Facebook has way more personal data. joshcryer Jun 2012 #17
Google is much better at turning that info into income KurtNYC Jun 2012 #19
Google maps sucks on the iPhone proud2BlibKansan Jun 2012 #2
I fall on the Apple side, but this is a clash of titans. We're just potential collateral damage. GodlessBiker Jun 2012 #3
Samsung Galaxys will still have them dipsydoodle Jun 2012 #4
i have such jealousy for those with the samsung galaxy La Lioness Priyanka Jun 2012 #21
:P Vehl Jun 2012 #22
hi fellow liberal hindu atheist La Lioness Priyanka Jun 2012 #23
It definitely will Vehl Jun 2012 #26
I got mine October 2010 dipsydoodle Jun 2012 #30
Glad I got G3--- roody Jun 2012 #5
So what happens with the half dozen (or more) apps I have that integrate with Google Maps? hlthe2b Jun 2012 #6
Google will have to submit their own map app later this year when iOS 6 comes out. onehandle Jun 2012 #7
Pucker up fanboyz tridim Jun 2012 #9
What's an iPhone? They_Live Jun 2012 #10
Don't worry, it's all just a fad. n/t PassingFair Jun 2012 #13
Facebook? Who cares. They're just ad spammers. mathematic Jun 2012 #16
I use the Google Nav app on my android phone quite a bit fujiyama Jun 2012 #18
In other words, welcome to three years ago Apple :) the Google maps is light years ahead Vehl Jun 2012 #20
Gosh, you're right. Apple is doomed. They could never catch up with Google. onehandle Jun 2012 #24
Reading comprehension 101 fail Vehl Jun 2012 #25
Not Telenav, but otherwise dead on. It's the worst, and iPhone users will be unhappy. Xithras Jun 2012 #27
Ah TeleAtlus, not TeleNav , typo :) thanks for correcting. Vehl Jun 2012 #28
There has to be more to it than we're hearing. Xithras Jun 2012 #29
Stay tuned. onehandle Jun 2012 #31
Latest Discussions»Latest Breaking News»Apple kicks Google Maps o...»Reply #27