Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

NutmegYankee

(16,199 posts)
40. FAIL
Sat Dec 21, 2013, 12:08 AM
Dec 2013
Name of a nuclear plant, is it not?

So... you like them nukes? Even took on the name of one, eh?

You're thinking of Vermont Yankee Nuclear Power Station. Vermont is a state in northern New England. Nutmegger = nickname of a resident of Connecticut. My username means Connecticut Yankee. As in I'm a Connecticut Yankee. This state is a little south of Vermont.

Here ya go; Does the water used in nuclear plants steam cycles get irradiated? Why yes, it does!! This idea of yours that water can be purified of nuke contamination by distillation is not very smart. Otherwise nuke plants would just clean up their mess via distillation, and viola! They'd be a little safer. They are not.


Jesus H Christ, where to start with that pile... Distillation concentrates waste left behind when water has boiled off, leaving a heavy brine solution full of metals and other contaminants. For drinking systems, that is discharged back to sea. In a nuclear power plant, that would have to be handled as waste.

Now there are two types of reactors - BWR and PWR. BWR boils water into steam and uses that to drive turbines and then condenses it back to water and recycles it through the reactor. That water does get lightly radioactive due to contaminants from piping that have been bombarded with neutrons becoming radioactive and leaching into the water. (remember, it's very pure water, so metal wants to leach into it)

Now a PWR, which is far more common, keeps the primary coolant loop under very high pressure to raise the boiling point so that the water remains a liquid at temperatures well above 212℉. That water never gets boiled. However that water never touches the turbines as it goes into a shell and tube style heat exchanger and boils a secondary loop. So the turbines don't get contaminated.

The problem you have is you have mixed up your view on nuclear power with my simple discussion of water purification processes. You are exhibiting confirmation bias to simply reject any science that is contrary to the view you hold. That you incorrectly associated my user name with a nuke plant just demonstrates the epic level you had to go to in your mind to attempt to discredit my science discussion. It's the same approach a creationist takes when confronting a biologist.
The Japanese stock market is doing great! another_liberal Dec 2013 #1
What am I missing? hog Dec 2013 #2
When I was in the nuclear Navy in the 90's (on a surface ship called a sub tender) DisgustipatedinCA Dec 2013 #3
"On a whim, the friends decided to get checked for radiation." bananas Dec 2013 #13
The navy isn't even keeping complete records for the sailors bananas Dec 2013 #14
No one told them RobertEarl Dec 2013 #4
That's fucked up davidpdx Dec 2013 #5
Agreed. olddad56 Dec 2013 #22
I hope the 4 that were denied are appealing davidpdx Dec 2013 #23
I would expect the reverse osmosis process to remove the radiation. NutmegYankee Dec 2013 #6
They were powering through a cloud of fallout. kristopher Dec 2013 #7
Well, if you are going to be so rude... NutmegYankee Dec 2013 #8
I know that's in the article, so are a lot of other facts. kristopher Dec 2013 #10
Ship's Captain is an idiot? RobertEarl Dec 2013 #9
Still flying that false flag? kristopher Dec 2013 #11
What false flag? RobertEarl Dec 2013 #15
truly, I doubt everyone was clueless loveandlight Dec 2013 #16
That's why they allow us to sue in court RobertEarl Dec 2013 #28
I don't think of radioactivity in those terms. Can you explain this to me, please? freshwest Dec 2013 #19
The filters are designed to only allow water molecules through NutmegYankee Dec 2013 #24
What little I can find on Nimitz-class carriers seems to say "no RO units." Igel Dec 2013 #20
That's even cleaner. NutmegYankee Dec 2013 #25
No. Not cleaner. RobertEarl Dec 2013 #31
You'll have to supply a link for that. NutmegYankee Dec 2013 #32
Really? RobertEarl Dec 2013 #33
LOL. At a few thousand degrees they do NutmegYankee Dec 2013 #34
Yep RobertEarl Dec 2013 #37
LOL. NutmegYankee Dec 2013 #38
Nutmeg Yankee RobertEarl Dec 2013 #39
FAIL NutmegYankee Dec 2013 #40
Sorry 'bout that RobertEarl Dec 2013 #41
Airborne contamination could have been present. NutmegYankee Dec 2013 #42
Ha ha ha. Bonobo Dec 2013 #44
Perhaps they were just using evaporaters to desalinate? nt adirondacker Dec 2013 #53
Cha-ching! nt Bonobo Dec 2013 #12
Say what??? RobertEarl Dec 2013 #17
Many people that have doctor's records bring shady lawsuits. Bonobo Dec 2013 #18
So you made up your mind? RobertEarl Dec 2013 #27
Well the lawsuit was dismissed. Bonobo Dec 2013 #29
My preconceptions? RobertEarl Dec 2013 #30
The lawsuit was dismissed. Bonobo Dec 2013 #35
Yes it was RobertEarl Dec 2013 #36
It was dismissed on jurisdiction, not on facts. bananas Dec 2013 #47
Experts on the effects of radiation say that they should no longer be Bonobo Dec 2013 #48
That's only because facts aren't involved at this stage. FBaggins Dec 2013 #52
I'm wondering a couple of things... olddad56 Dec 2013 #21
kick (nt) muriel_volestrangler Dec 2013 #26
yet more hysteria anasv Dec 2013 #43
We have an expert here? RobertEarl Dec 2013 #45
dont worry - this never happens Locrian Dec 2013 #51
TV: 70 Navy sailors in new Fukushima lawsuit - They rode right into plume, could be thousands more bananas Dec 2013 #46
Thanks Bananas RobertEarl Dec 2013 #49
Chernobyl's Aftermath: The Pompeii of the Nuclear Age mitty14u2 Dec 2013 #50
Latest Discussions»Latest Breaking News»USS Ronald Reagan sailors...»Reply #40