HomeLatest ThreadsGreatest ThreadsForums & GroupsMy SubscriptionsMy Posts
DU Home » Latest Threads » Forums & Groups » Main » Editorials & Other Articles (Forum) » Poor, White, and Republic...

Tue Feb 14, 2012, 10:36 AM

Poor, White, and Republican [View all]


F.D.R. called him “the forgotten man,” but that was long ago. By 1972, he was a member of the silent majority and had become a Democrat for Nixon (he wore a hard hat with an American-flag sticker). 1980 produced the Reagan Democrat (this time he came from Macomb County, Michigan, and was discovered by the pollster Stan Greenberg). By 1994 he had curdled into the Angry White Male (he elected the Gingrich Congress). In 2008, he was simply the working-class white—by then he was no longer forgotten, and no longer a Democrat of any kind; he was a member of the much-analyzed Republican base. The television godfather of the type, of course, is Archie Bunker, but you can also trace his lineage more darkly through the string of hard-bitten blue-collar movies that begins with “Joe” (Peter Boyle, 1970), goes on to “Falling Down” (Michael Douglas, 1993), “Gran Torino” (Clint Eastwood, 2008), and, in a rural context, “Winter’s Bone” (2010). He’s a descendant of the thirties Everyman played by Henry Fonda and Gary Cooper, except that in the intervening decades he lost his idealism and grew surly, if not violent, consumed with a hatred of hippies, immigrants, blacks, government, and, finally, himself.

This election year, he’s back and getting a lot of attention from sociologists and pundits (Charles Murray’s new book “Coming Apart: The State of White America, 1960-2010” sparked the current flurry of commentary). But in 2012 he’s no longer even working class. He’s fallen through the last restraints of decency and industriousness, down into the demoralized and pathological underclass that, in the past, Americans associated with the black poor. There, he lives on disability, is no longer fit for employment nor has any impulse to get a job, is divorced, fathers illegitimate children who grow up to do the same, gets hooked on meth or prescription drugs, does time in prison now and then, and has bad teeth.

Is it useful to make generalizations about whole classes of people? We all know the reasons why it’s not—they stoke prejudice, crush nuance, distort reality, are unkind and unfair. But just as it was wrong for a generation of liberals to reject Daniel Patrick Moynihan’s notorious 1965 report “The Negro Family: The Case for National Action,” it would be a mistake to dismiss the subject of Murray’s new book simply because it insults half of the Americans who weren’t already tarred by “The Bell Curve.” Murray has a talent for raising important questions on the way to arriving at invidious answers.

Read more http://www.newyorker.com/online/blogs/comment/2012/02/poor-white-and-republican.html#ixzz1mN3lRi00

36 replies, 10960 views

Reply to this thread

Back to top Alert abuse

Always highlight: 10 newest replies | Replies posted after I mark a forum
Replies to this discussion thread
Arrow 36 replies Author Time Post
Reply Poor, White, and Republican [View all]
xchrom Feb 2012 OP
CanonRay Feb 2012 #1
n2doc Feb 2012 #2
Liberal Gramma Feb 2012 #3
Bozita Feb 2012 #7
valerief Feb 2012 #8
TBF Feb 2012 #15
Lucky Luciano Feb 2012 #17
tblue37 Feb 2012 #5
jayschool Feb 2012 #14
tblue37 Feb 2012 #31
Zookeeper Feb 2012 #21
tblue37 Feb 2012 #30
Zookeeper Feb 2012 #32
tblue37 Feb 2012 #36
pscot Feb 2012 #29
jwirr Feb 2012 #6
qb Feb 2012 #4
craigmatic Feb 2012 #9
Auggie Feb 2012 #12
Blue_Tires Feb 2012 #10
Amonester Feb 2012 #19
Zookeeper Feb 2012 #23
xmas74 Feb 2012 #11
Recoverin_Republican Feb 2012 #13
raging_moderate Feb 2012 #16
Bozita Feb 2012 #18
Amonester Feb 2012 #20
Zookeeper Feb 2012 #24
Alcibiades Feb 2012 #28
Doctor_J Feb 2012 #35
eridani Feb 2012 #22
Doctor_J Feb 2012 #34
eridani Feb 2012 #25
jvii Feb 2012 #26
kemah Feb 2012 #27
Doctor_J Feb 2012 #33