I hate Strong Female Characters [View all]
Sherlock Holmes gets to be brilliant, solitary, abrasive, Bohemian, whimsical, brave, sad, manipulative, neurotic, vain, untidy, fastidious, artistic, courteous, rude, a polymath genius. Female characters get to be Strong.
http://www.newstatesman.com/culture/2013/08/i-hate-strong-female-characters
Are our best-loved male heroes Strong Male Characters? Is, say, Sherlock Holmes strong? In one sense, yes, of course. He faces danger and death in order to pursue justice. On the other hand, his physical strength is often unreliable strong enough to bend an iron poker when on form, he nevertheless frequently has to rely on Watson to clobber his assailants, at least once because hes neglected himself into a condition where he cant even try to fight back. His mental and emotional resources also fluctuate. An addict and a depressive, he claims even his crime-fighting is a form of self-medication. Viewed this way, his willingness to place himself in physical danger might not be strength at all it might be another form of self-destructiveness. Or on the other hand, perhaps his vulnerabilities make him all the stronger, as he succeeds in surviving and flourishing in spite of threats located within as well without.
Is Sherlock Holmes strong? Its not just that the answer is of course, its that its the wrong question.
What happens when one tries to fit other iconic male heroes into an imaginary Strong Male Character box? A few fit reasonably well, but many look cramped and bewildered in there. Theyre not used to this kind of confinement, poor things. Theyre used to being interesting across more than one axis and in more than two dimensions.
...
Chuck Wendig argues here that we shouldnt understand strong as meaning, well, strong, but rather as something like well-written. But I simply dont think its true that the majority of writers or readers are reading the term that way. How else to explain the fact that when the screenwriters of The Lord of the Rings decided to (clumsily) expand Arwens role from the books, they had her wander on screen, put a sword to her boyfriends throat and boast about how shed sneaked up on him? (It took Liv Tyler to realise later you dont have to put a sword in her hand to make her strong). Why else did Paul Feig, as Carina Chicano notes here, have to justify the fact that Bridesmaids hinges on a complex, interesting female character who appeared rather weak?
Personally, I wasted a lot of ink in my writing trying to make sure the female characters were "strong" before I realized it was getting in the way of making them, you know,
actual characters in the story.