Welcome to DU!
The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards.
Join the community:
Create a free account
Support DU (and get rid of ads!):
Become a Star Member
Latest Breaking News
General Discussion
The DU Lounge
All Forums
Issue Forums
Culture Forums
Alliance Forums
Region Forums
Support Forums
Help & Search
Economy
In reply to the discussion: STOCK MARKET WATCH -- Friday, 1 June 2012 [View all]Demeter
(85,373 posts)5. Barney Frank: Obama Rejected Bush Administration Concession to Write Down Mortgages
http://www.nakedcapitalism.com/2012/05/barney-frank-obama-rejected-bush-administration-concession-to-write-down-mortgages.html?utm_source=feedburner&utm_medium=email&utm_campaign=Feed%3A+NakedCapitalism+%28naked+capitalism%29
Heres Barney Frank, in an exit interview recently in New York Magazine, revealing unwittingly that Obama during the transition rejected a Bush administration concession to write down mortgages. Heres what Barney said.
This is consistent with other accounts. There were policy debates within Obamas economic team about what to do about the mortgage crisis. The choices were to create some sort of legal entity to write down mortgage debt or to allow the write-down of mortgage debt through a massive wave of foreclosures over the next four to six years. He choice the latter. That choice was part of what led to roughly $7 trillion of middle class wealth gone, with financial assets for the elites re-inflated.
Since I pointed out that the growth of income inequality under Obama is worse than that under Bush, many people have responded by saying that somehow this is not Obamas responsibility, that it was an inherited crisis and structural problems that caused a widening of inequality. They simply do not want to accept that policy matters, or, if it does, that Obama had any choice in the policy choices he made.
In fact, crisis response is the single most significant policymaking time imaginable, because all structural barriers are swept away. Think about it this was literally a deal offered by Hank Paulson one guy to Barack Obama, with a multi-trillion dollar impact. No 60 votes in the Senate. No hearings. No confirmations. Just a handshake, basically. In other words, policy does matter, and Obama had a variety of choices and leverage, and he did what he thought was best. He did not want to write down mortgages, even though he was offered that choice by the Bush administration and Barney Frank. So he didnt.
So yes, Barack Obama is worse than George Bush on economic inequality. While Paulson didnt want to write down mortgages, the single biggest factor in determining whether the American middle class has any stored wealth, Paulson was willing to do so in response to pressure. Barack Obama was not.
Heres Barney Frank, in an exit interview recently in New York Magazine, revealing unwittingly that Obama during the transition rejected a Bush administration concession to write down mortgages. Heres what Barney said.
The mortgage crisis was worsened this past time because critical decisions were made during the transition between Bush and Obama. We voted the TARP out. The TARP was basically being administered by Hank Paulson as the last man home in a lame duck, and I was disappointed. I tried to get them to use the TARP to put some leverage on the banks to do more about mortgages, and Paulson at first resisted that, he just wanted to get the money out. And after he got the first chunk of money out, he would have had to ask for a second chunk, he said, all right, Ill tell you what, Ill ask for that second chunk and Ill use some of that as leverage on mortgages, but Im not going to do that unless Obama asks for it. This is now December, so we tried to get the Obama people to ask him and they wouldnt do it.
This is consistent with other accounts. There were policy debates within Obamas economic team about what to do about the mortgage crisis. The choices were to create some sort of legal entity to write down mortgage debt or to allow the write-down of mortgage debt through a massive wave of foreclosures over the next four to six years. He choice the latter. That choice was part of what led to roughly $7 trillion of middle class wealth gone, with financial assets for the elites re-inflated.
Since I pointed out that the growth of income inequality under Obama is worse than that under Bush, many people have responded by saying that somehow this is not Obamas responsibility, that it was an inherited crisis and structural problems that caused a widening of inequality. They simply do not want to accept that policy matters, or, if it does, that Obama had any choice in the policy choices he made.
In fact, crisis response is the single most significant policymaking time imaginable, because all structural barriers are swept away. Think about it this was literally a deal offered by Hank Paulson one guy to Barack Obama, with a multi-trillion dollar impact. No 60 votes in the Senate. No hearings. No confirmations. Just a handshake, basically. In other words, policy does matter, and Obama had a variety of choices and leverage, and he did what he thought was best. He did not want to write down mortgages, even though he was offered that choice by the Bush administration and Barney Frank. So he didnt.
So yes, Barack Obama is worse than George Bush on economic inequality. While Paulson didnt want to write down mortgages, the single biggest factor in determining whether the American middle class has any stored wealth, Paulson was willing to do so in response to pressure. Barack Obama was not.
Edit history
Please sign in to view edit histories.
131 replies
= new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight:
NoneDon't highlight anything
5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
RecommendedHighlight replies with 5 or more recommendations
Barney Frank: Obama Rejected Bush Administration Concession to Write Down Mortgages
Demeter
May 2012
#5
Missed the greatest opportunity this nation has seen in almost a century.
Egalitarian Thug
Jun 2012
#90
You'd think they'd learn how to make better tasting jelly after all these years.
Fuddnik
Jun 2012
#44
Retirement: Where Corporate Executives Make the Real Big Bucks by: California Labor Federation
Demeter
Jun 2012
#16
Anyone willing to bet that the US markets finish in the black today, though? esp. after Europe close
Roland99
Jun 2012
#39
U.S. adds 69,000 jobs in May; jobless rate 8.2% (March and April *both* revised down)
Roland99
Jun 2012
#34
JOBS REPORT DISASTER: JUST 69K NEW JOBS CREATED, UNEMPLOYMENT RISES, DOW PLUNGES 2.2%
xchrom
Jun 2012
#43
Good Gawd! It got worse there! It's like arguing with a Republican 10 years ago over WMDs!
Roland99
Jun 2012
#105
The price of a do-nothing Congress: Government layoffs, budget cuts making matters worse
Demeter
Jun 2012
#98
17 min. left for the rescue and still languishing just a bit above the daily lows.
Roland99
Jun 2012
#117
It's one of those "well, I really know better but couldn't resist" kinda things
Roland99
Jun 2012
#116