Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Liberty Belle

(9,534 posts)
4. All the ways turning off power endangers lives:
Mon Jun 10, 2019, 01:55 AM
Jun 2019

Phone lines go down so people don't get emergency alerts to evacuate. Cell phones may also cease to work and in some rural areas there is no cell service so land lines are vital.

Internet goes down, too. Imagine being left with no communication and a major wildfire is approaching.

Life support equipment will fail, leaving people on home dialysis, breathing machines etc. likely to swiftly die.

Electric well pumps don't work, so you can't provide water for your household, your livestock, or to put out spot fires sparked by burning embers as many rural and backcountry residents regularly do.

Electric garage door openers fail, trapping vehicles in garages so people can't escape a fire if they are unable to climb up and manually open the door, as many elderly and disabled people cannot do.

Traffic signals fail, causing massive traffic jams just when people need clear roads to evacuate.

Air conditioning won't work, and triple digit heat can kill people.

Refrigerators and freezers shut off so after a few hours food will spoil. SDG&E has been doing power shutoffs for a while to prevent fires and has never paid for any food spoilage-- not even in a community that had a dozen outages in 2 months -- so some lost all their food over and over again, in a poor community.

Water pumping stations fail, which can leave firefighters without water to fight fires.

Outages are particularly dangerous at schools, medical facilities etc. Not all have generators.

Frequent outages are also disruptive to businesses. Some stores had all their frozen products melt or spoil. Businesses may miss critical deadlines such as filing court documents due to outages.

Being plunged into darkness can result in trips/falls and injuries.

Fires can also be caused by inexperienced people buying and using generators improperly, and this can also put surges into the lines that can electrocute utility workers when power comes back up. Generators are not a panacea though can be helpful for some who can afford them and are technically savvy enough to do so correction.

In short, allowing intentional outages, with no limits on how often and no requirements for compensating people who suffer losses, is dangerous and unconscionable. Utility companies should instead be required to fire harden their lines and assure that all equipment is as safe as it can possibly be.

They should also be made to do one good thing that SDG&E has done -- install weather stations and video cameras on power poles all across their area so that fires can be detected instantly and firefighting equipment pre-positioned when weather monitors indicate strong winds/high temps forming up. This would not have happened if SDG&E had been let off the hook for fires that it caused - they had to pay out a lot of money, not enough, but it did teach them some lessons -- some that resulted in good solutions, others bad ones that put the burden of outages on consumers, not shareholders.




Latest Discussions»Issue Forums»Environment & Energy»California utility proact...»Reply #4