Jim Jenal | Run On Sun.com
Elon Musk is a visionary and a showman, but occasionally his enthusiasm for his vision gets way out ahead of reality. Nowhere was that disconnect more on display than this past week when he made his much talked about announcement of the Tesla Powerwall battery storage system. While we share the vision for the potential of battery systems (such as the one Enphase Energy is set to release later this year, albeit in a far more understated fashion), when 38,000 people go online to order a product that doesnt yet exist, it is time to debunk some of the more exorbitant claims made by Musk.
Here are the three biggest whoppers that Musk made during his Powerwall presentation.
Whopper #3 - Power for an ice storm or other significant grid failure event
Musk touted the peace of mind that would come from having the Powerwall, and said, if theres a cut in the utilities youre always gonna have power, particularly if youre in a place thats very cold, now you dont have to worry about being out of power if theres an ice storm.
The Powerwall unit that Musk was talking about that was designed for daily cycling was a 7 kWh unit that is priced at $3,000. The average home in the Run on Sun service area uses 25 kWh/day. So a single Powerwall unit provides roughly one quarter of the energy demand of an average home. If your desire for peace of mind means running your home for a full day in normal fashion, you will need to purchase 4 Powerwall units (assuming you have the wall space to mount them) and that will cost you $12,000.
Of course, many outages last longer than a day. The longer you want to stay powered, the more units you will need...
snip
Whopper #2 - Powerwall will work with existing solar systems
Musk insisted that Powerwall has been designed to work with solar systems, right out of the box." (See video at 8:25.)
Except
that the Powerwall is designed to fit between existing solar panels and the DC-AC inverter(s) in the system (i.e., on the DC side of the system). But heres the thing - the vast majority of inverters are what are known as grid-tied, which means if the grid goes down, the inverter shuts off, and stays off until the grid comes back...
Whopper #1 - You can go off grid
for $3,500!
Warming to his subject, Musk really brought down the house with his most outrageous claim of all:
"You could actually go, if you want, completely off-grid. You can take your solar panels, charge the battery packs and thats all you use. So it gives you safety, security, and it gives you a complete and affordable solution. And the cost of this is $3,500." (Gasps and applause from audience.)
No. No you cannot.
Lets unpack his statement...
Read More:
http://runonsun.com/~runons5/blogs/blog1.php/ranting/elon-musk-s-3-biggest-powerwall-whoppers
Elon Musk is a con artist. His companies wouldn't be in business without government handouts. His batteries are yesterday's tech. Japan is perfecting home fuel cells.