Religion
In reply to the discussion: New Religions: (1) the United Church of Bacon [View all]Yorktown
(2,884 posts)Preachers Who Dont Believe The Scandal of Apostate Pastors
THURSDAY March 18, 2010
Are there clergy who dont believe in God? That is the question posed by a new report that is certain to receive considerable attention and rightly so. Few church members are likely to be disinterested in whether their pastor believes in God.
The study was conducted by the Center for Cognitive Studies at Tufts University, under the direction of Daniel C. Dennett and Linda LaScola. Dennett, of course, is one of the primary figures in the New Atheism the newly aggressive and influential atheist movement that has gained a considerable hearing among the intellectual elites and the media.
Dennett is a cognitive scientist whose book, Breaking the Spell, suggests that belief in God must have at one point served an important evolutionary purpose, granting an evolutionary advantage to those who had some belief in an afterlife as compared to humans without such a belief. The reality of death, Dennett surmises, might well have been the precipitating factor. In order to make life meaningful in the face of death (and thus encourage reproduction), Dennett suggests that primitive humans invented the idea of God and the afterlife. Now, he argues, we have no more need of such primitive beliefs.
Interestingly, Dennett also proposes a new interpretation of theological liberalism. Noting that many modern people claim to be Christians while holding to virtually no specific theological content, Dennett suggests that their mode of faith should not be described as belief, but rather as believing in belief.
Given Dennetts own atheistic agenda, we can rightly assume that he would be thrilled to see Christian ministers and believers abandon the faith. Indeed, the New Atheists have made this a stated aim. Thus, this new research report, Preachers Who Are Not Believers, should be read within that framework. Nevertheless, it must be read. This report demands the attention of anyone concerned with the integrity of the Christian church and the Christian faith.
Dennett and LaScola undertook their project with the goal of looking for unbelieving pastors and ministers who continue to serve their churches in secret disbelief. Their small and self-selected sample of ministers represents a microcosm of the theological collapse at the heart of many churches and denominations.
In their report, Dennett and LaScola present case studies of five unbelieving ministers, three from liberal denominations (the liberals) and two from conservative denominations (the literals).
Wes, a Methodist, lost his confidence in the Bible while attending a liberal Christian college and seminary. I went to college thinking Adam and Eve were real people, he explained. Now, he no longer believes that God exists. In his rendering, God is a word that can be used very expressively in some of my more meditative modes and a kind of poetry that is written by human beings.
His church members do not know that he is an atheist, but he explains that they are somewhat liberal themselves. His ministerial colleagues are even more liberal: Theyve been de-mythologized, Ill say that. They dont believe Jesus rose from the dead literally. They dont believe Jesus was born of a virgin. They dont believe all those things that would cause a big stir in their churches.
http://www.albertmohler.com/2010/03/18/clergy-who-dont-believe-the-scandal-of-apostate-pastors/