HomeLatest ThreadsGreatest ThreadsForums & GroupsMy SubscriptionsMy Posts
DU Home » Latest Threads » Forums & Groups » Topics » Religion & Spirituality » Religion (Group) » Sam Harris’ detestable cr...

Sun Dec 27, 2015, 11:15 PM

 

Sam Harris’ detestable crusade: How his latest anti-Islam tract reveals the bankruptcy of his ideas [View all]

Harris' haughty ignorance & chauvinism are on full display in his new book, a "dialogue" with a former radical

Sunday, Dec 27, 2015 07:30 PM EST
Omer Aziz

There are few get-rich-quick schemes left in modern publishing, but one that persists could be called Project Islamic Reformation. Writing a book that fits in this category is actually quite easy. First, label yourself a reformist. Never mind the congratulatory self-coronation the tag implies; it is necessary to segregate oneself from all the non-reformists out there. Second, make your agenda clear at the outset by criticizing what is ailing Islam and Muslims. The Qur’an is a good place to start because Muslims, especially in the Middle East, surely treat their holy book more like a military instruction manual than anything else. Third, propose a few solutions. Lest you be accused of nuance, the more vague and generic these are, the better. Fourth, soak up the inevitable publicity that awaits, and with it, your hard-earned cash. Voilà!

The books that make up Project Islamic Reformation are not works of scholarship or even well-crafted popular texts. They are almost exclusively political pamphlets of a very personal nature that often begin as biography and end as self-help, except the “self” in this case includes a quarter of the world’s people, and the “help” may or may not come at the end of a missile. Ayaan Hirsi Ali—who deserves empathy for her personal ordeals but not her conclusions—released such a book earlier this year with neat, Manichean categories delineating good and bad Muslims, as well as the expected checklist of proposed reforms. More tracts will certainly follow because publishers love a good Reformist, and the affluent Western audience that consumes these books loves having most of their pre-existing beliefs confirmed rather than challenged.

It is in the context of Project Islamic Reformation that the atheist neuroscientist Sam Harris and the redeemed radical Maajid Nawaz have published their latest book, “Islam and the Future of Tolerance,” put out by no less a publishing house than Harvard University Press. The book is structured as a conversation between Harris and Nawaz, who go back and forth over issues ranging from polling data suggesting Muslims support corporal punishment to the Islamic justifications for jihad. Compressed into its 128 pages is the entire Reformation Project, except that the book’s contents are as thin as its subject is grand. For a work whose title includes the words “Islam” and “future of tolerance,” the Harris-Nawaz pamphlet consistently veers from the ahistorical into the nonsensical and back again, almost always at Harris’s urging.

What is right in the book can be attributed solely to Maajid Nawaz. In fact, one can skip over everything Sam Harris says because he is merely repackaging ideas he has articulated many times before. Among the elementary truisms Nawaz points to: addressing the grievances many young Muslims feel, changing the narrative the Islamist demagogues have mastered, injecting a dose of cultural liberalism into conservative societies to induce progress on women’s rights and free speech, raising the low expectations held by too many Americans about supposedly thin-skinned Muslims who cannot take a joke and must be coddled. Well and good, and self-evident enough, except to the most benighted ideologues.

http://www.salon.com/2015/12/28/sam_harriss_detestable_crusade_how_his_latest_anti_islam_tract_reveals_the_bankruptcy_of_his_ideas/

48 replies, 6961 views

Reply to this thread

Back to top Alert abuse

Always highlight: 10 newest replies | Replies posted after I mark a forum
Replies to this discussion thread
Arrow 48 replies Author Time Post
Reply Sam Harris’ detestable crusade: How his latest anti-Islam tract reveals the bankruptcy of his ideas [View all]
rug Dec 2015 OP
Nyan Dec 2015 #1
rug Dec 2015 #2
Nyan Dec 2015 #3
cpwm17 Dec 2015 #5
cleanhippie Dec 2015 #6
Goblinmonger Dec 2015 #7
Nyan Dec 2015 #9
Goblinmonger Dec 2015 #10
Nyan Dec 2015 #15
cpwm17 Dec 2015 #18
Jim__ Dec 2015 #19
cpwm17 Dec 2015 #21
Goblinmonger Dec 2015 #25
cpwm17 Dec 2015 #27
rug Dec 2015 #11
Lordquinton Dec 2015 #12
rug Dec 2015 #13
Lordquinton Dec 2015 #14
rug Dec 2015 #16
Lordquinton Dec 2015 #17
DonCoquixote Dec 2015 #4
Goblinmonger Dec 2015 #8
DonCoquixote Dec 2015 #24
Goblinmonger Dec 2015 #26
DonCoquixote Dec 2015 #28
MisterP Dec 2015 #20
rug Dec 2015 #22
MisterP Dec 2015 #23
MisterP Dec 2015 #29
Humanist_Activist Dec 2015 #30
kwassa Dec 2015 #32
Humanist_Activist Jan 2016 #33
rug Jan 2016 #36
Humanist_Activist Jan 2016 #37
rug Jan 2016 #39
kwassa Jan 2016 #38
Humanist_Activist Jan 2016 #40
Goblinmonger Jan 2016 #35
kwassa Jan 2016 #41
Humanist_Activist Jan 2016 #42
kwassa Jan 2016 #43
Humanist_Activist Jan 2016 #46
Goblinmonger Jan 2016 #44
kwassa Jan 2016 #45
Humanist_Activist Jan 2016 #47
Goblinmonger Jan 2016 #48
Goblinmonger Dec 2015 #31
Warren Stupidity Jan 2016 #34