Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Igel

(35,270 posts)
7. It's truthy.
Sun Mar 27, 2016, 12:13 PM
Mar 2016

That's about it.

Easter is from the Germanic word for "sunrise". That a lot of the religious background is similar to what's seen in other pagan religions stands to reason. The nearness in pronunciation is an accident.

It pays to note that there are also some rather big differences between the pagan rites taken over as Easter and the pagan rights with Astarte or Ishtar. Just as there are some rather big differences between "Easter" (and how it was pronounced 1500 years ago) and "Ishtar." We see similarities when we want to show similarity; we see differences when we want to show difference.


A lot of the information found on the Internet goes back before the Internet. A lot of people forget this. In this case, I'm going to guess a significant source of a lot of this drivel is Hislop's _The Two Babylons_, who cites some even older sources. Hislop's work dates back to the 1850s. That would be the 1800s.

And, yes, Hislop often either gets his sources wrong, his sources were wrong, or Hislop has no idea how to handle the then relatively new discipline of historical linguistics. Much like many pop culture folk have no idea nowadays how to handle modern conceptions of quantum mechanics or genetics, but given a preset goal always find a way of making the newish fields say exactly what they want them to say.

And? skepticscott Mar 2016 #1
Richard Dawkins was caught in the act mental masturbation, peddling false facts Agnosticsherbet Mar 2016 #8
Hardly skepticscott Mar 2016 #13
Read the comments Cartoonist Mar 2016 #2
No it was Eastra, edhopper Mar 2016 #3
None of that matters skepticscott Mar 2016 #4
BTW edhopper Mar 2016 #5
It's also quite ironic skepticscott Mar 2016 #6
It's truthy. Igel Mar 2016 #7
OED says edhopper Mar 2016 #9
No what's foolish is to keep pedalling this crap when you know the truth. Leontius Mar 2016 #10
You don't know the timing of Easter edhopper Mar 2016 #11
Expect a Babylonian reply. nt Cartoonist Mar 2016 #12
I hate edhopper Mar 2016 #15
It would have been even more foolish skepticscott Mar 2016 #14
Well let's see, today is Sunday March 27 2016 Leontius Mar 2016 #16
Other people are linking to a years old post skepticscott Mar 2016 #17
Amazing how fixated you are on Dawkins. Leontius Mar 2016 #18
Amazing how you fail miserably skepticscott Mar 2016 #20
Well let's see, today is Sunday March 27 2016, mr blur Mar 2016 #21
Yes, we do teach that the King of the Universe struggle4progress Mar 2016 #25
QED cleanhippie Mar 2016 #27
I really hate amateur linguistics. okasha Mar 2016 #19
I really hate it too, mr blur Mar 2016 #22
Post removed Post removed Mar 2016 #23
Did you really think your post qualifies as anything skepticscott Mar 2016 #24
Actually it did qualify as something else skepticscott Mar 2016 #26
Latest Discussions»Issue Forums»Religion»Easter Is Not Named After...»Reply #7