HomeLatest ThreadsGreatest ThreadsForums & GroupsMy SubscriptionsMy Posts
DU Home » Latest Threads » Forums & Groups » Topics » Religion & Spirituality » Religion (Group) » "Proof" (?) of an afterli... » Reply #90
In the discussion thread: "Proof" (?) of an afterlife [View all]

Response to cpwm17 (Reply #88)

Mon Oct 10, 2016, 04:06 PM

90. There's lots of things which differentiate me from everyone else

Physical properties like DNA are one of them, and physical changes and stored memories are another. I don't feel the need to invent some abstract concept of a soul to think of myself as unique. You use words like "conscious being" that just don't have that much different connotation than religious ideas of a soul. I am a being that happens to presently be in a state of consciousness. Eventually I'll become a being that happens to be in a state of death. For me it need not be anymore complicated.

Descartes isn't defining a "soul", he is defining the basis of knowledge which requires an assumption of a state of existence.

If you know of a reason that nature can't repeat the same process to create me again, you can tell me what it is.


Russell's Teapot says I feel no obligation to even try.

Regardless of whatever chances you think of some random person existing are, the chance of you in particular existing is pretty much 100% unless I'm incredibly high or in some other form of psychosis and just imagined you. Assuming this not to be the case and building on the fact that you're replying, I'd go one step farther and say your chance of being conscious is also 100%. To work off your lottery analogy, if you hold the ticket with the winning numbers, your chance of winning is 100%, not 5.7 e-11%. Now if you want to play the game of the monkey banging on a typewriter writing War and Peace, "you" might be physically identical to you, but you would be "reincarnated" in the same sense as a recycled ball bearing.

Russell's Teapot is intended to be far fetched. That's pretty much central to the whole point. Asserting that I'm claiming any "default" is strawman. I've already told you I never said you were wrong, just that I have no reason to believe you are right. You keep confusing those two things.

Reply to this post

Back to OP Alert abuse Link to post in-thread

Always highlight: 10 newest replies | Replies posted after I mark a forum
Replies to this discussion thread
Arrow 98 replies Author Time Post
left-of-center2012 Oct 2016 OP
grubbs Oct 2016 #1
SusanCalvin Oct 2016 #2
rug Oct 2016 #3
beveeheart Oct 2016 #6
rug Oct 2016 #8
Moostache Oct 2016 #4
Brettongarcia Oct 2016 #23
pipoman Oct 2016 #5
Doodley Oct 2016 #7
cpwm17 Oct 2016 #10
Doodley Oct 2016 #14
cpwm17 Oct 2016 #22
Doodley Oct 2016 #53
cpwm17 Oct 2016 #57
Major Nikon Oct 2016 #91
cpwm17 Oct 2016 #92
Major Nikon Oct 2016 #95
Iggo Oct 2016 #9
Bernardo de La Paz Oct 2016 #11
Brettongarcia Oct 2016 #86
stone space Oct 2016 #12
Major Nikon Oct 2016 #13
Doodley Oct 2016 #15
Major Nikon Oct 2016 #16
Doodley Oct 2016 #34
Major Nikon Oct 2016 #37
Doodley Oct 2016 #44
Major Nikon Oct 2016 #45
cpwm17 Oct 2016 #46
Major Nikon Oct 2016 #47
cpwm17 Oct 2016 #48
Major Nikon Oct 2016 #49
Doodley Oct 2016 #54
Major Nikon Oct 2016 #56
cpwm17 Oct 2016 #58
Major Nikon Oct 2016 #59
cpwm17 Oct 2016 #61
Major Nikon Oct 2016 #63
cpwm17 Oct 2016 #64
Major Nikon Oct 2016 #65
cpwm17 Oct 2016 #66
Major Nikon Oct 2016 #67
cpwm17 Oct 2016 #68
Major Nikon Oct 2016 #69
cpwm17 Oct 2016 #70
Major Nikon Oct 2016 #71
cpwm17 Oct 2016 #73
Major Nikon Oct 2016 #74
cpwm17 Oct 2016 #75
Major Nikon Oct 2016 #78
cpwm17 Oct 2016 #80
Major Nikon Oct 2016 #83
cpwm17 Oct 2016 #88
LineLineLineLineLineLineLineLineLineLineNew Reply There's lots of things which differentiate me from everyone else
Major Nikon Oct 2016 #90
cpwm17 Oct 2016 #93
Major Nikon Oct 2016 #94
Doodley Oct 2016 #85
cpwm17 Oct 2016 #89
Doodley Oct 2016 #84
Major Nikon Oct 2016 #87
Doodley Oct 2016 #96
Major Nikon Oct 2016 #97
Doodley Oct 2016 #60
Major Nikon Oct 2016 #62
Doodley Oct 2016 #50
Major Nikon Oct 2016 #51
rug Oct 2016 #72
trotsky Oct 2016 #21
Doodley Oct 2016 #35
trotsky Oct 2016 #36
Major Nikon Oct 2016 #38
trotsky Oct 2016 #39
cpwm17 Oct 2016 #43
Electron1 Oct 2016 #17
left-of-center2012 Oct 2016 #19
DetlefK Oct 2016 #18
Act_of_Reparation Oct 2016 #20
Angry Dragon Oct 2016 #24
left-of-center2012 Oct 2016 #25
trotsky Oct 2016 #33
Angry Dragon Oct 2016 #40
Mike Nelson Oct 2016 #26
cleanhippie Oct 2016 #29
Warpy Oct 2016 #27
Loki Liesmith Oct 2016 #28
left-of-center2012 Oct 2016 #31
Loki Liesmith Oct 2016 #32
still_one Oct 2016 #30
Goblinmonger Oct 2016 #41
still_one Oct 2016 #42
Chemisse Oct 2016 #52
The Wielding Truth Oct 2016 #55
whathehell Oct 2016 #76
Paula Sims Oct 2016 #77
awake Oct 2016 #79
Uben Oct 2016 #81
left-of-center2012 Oct 2016 #82
brooklynite Oct 2016 #98
Please login to view edit histories.