HomeLatest ThreadsGreatest ThreadsForums & GroupsMy SubscriptionsMy Posts
DU Home » Latest Threads » Forums & Groups » Topics » Religion & Spirituality » Religion (Group) » Is Atheism a Belief? » Reply #97
In the discussion thread: Is Atheism a Belief? [View all]

Response to guillaumeb (Reply #94)

Sun Mar 19, 2017, 08:00 PM

97. That's your opinion. I'll defer to scientists if you don't mind.

Conflating religious belief with science is a faulty logic. Evolution does not require belief, it is an easily proven theory. Belief in gods requires you to have faith in what cannot be proved.


Evolution is a Fact and a Theory
by Laurence Moran

When non-biologists talk about biological evolution they often confuse two different aspects of the definition. On the one hand there is the question of whether or not modern organisms have evolved from older ancestral organisms or whether modern species are continuing to change over time. On the other hand there are questions about the mechanism of the observed changes... how did evolution occur? Biologists consider the existence of biological evolution to be a fact. It can be demonstrated today and the historical evidence for its occurrence in the past is overwhelming. However, biologists readily admit that they are less certain of the exact mechanism of evolution; there are several theories of the mechanism of evolution. Stephen J. Gould has put this as well as anyone else:

In the American vernacular, "theory" often means "imperfect fact"--part of a hierarchy of confidence running downhill from fact to theory to hypothesis to guess. Thus the power of the creationist argument: evolution is "only" a theory and intense debate now rages about many aspects of the theory. If evolution is worse than a fact, and scientists can't even make up their minds about the theory, then what confidence can we have in it? Indeed, President Reagan echoed this argument before an evangelical group in Dallas when he said (in what I devoutly hope was campaign rhetoric): "Well, it is a theory. It is a scientific theory only, and it has in recent years been challenged in the world of science--that is, not believed in the scientific community to be as infallible as it once was."

Well evolution is a theory. It is also a fact. And facts and theories are different things, not rungs in a hierarchy of increasing certainty. Facts are the world's data. Theories are structures of ideas that explain and interpret facts. Facts don't go away when scientists debate rival theories to explain them. Einstein's theory of gravitation replaced Newton's in this century, but apples didn't suspend themselves in midair, pending the outcome. And humans evolved from ape-like ancestors whether they did so by Darwin's proposed mechanism or by some other yet to be discovered.

Moreover, "fact" doesn't mean "absolute certainty"; there ain't no such animal in an exciting and complex world. The final proofs of logic and mathematics flow deductively from stated premises and achieve certainty only because they are not about the empirical world. Evolutionists make no claim for perpetual truth, though creationists often do (and then attack us falsely for a style of argument that they themselves favor). In science "fact" can only mean "confirmed to such a degree that it would be perverse to withhold provisional consent." I suppose that apples might start to rise tomorrow, but the possibility does not merit equal time in physics classrooms.

Evolutionists have been very clear about this distinction of fact and theory from the very beginning, if only because we have always acknowledged how far we are from completely understanding the mechanisms (theory) by which evolution (fact) occurred. Darwin continually emphasized the difference between his two great and separate accomplishments: establishing the fact of evolution, and proposing a theory--natural selection--to explain the mechanism of evolution.

- Stephen J. Gould, " Evolution as Fact and Theory"; Discover, May 1981


http://www.talkorigins.org/faqs/evolution-fact.html


Reply to this post

Back to OP Alert abuse Link to post in-thread

Always highlight: 10 newest replies | Replies posted after I mark a forum
Replies to this discussion thread
Arrow 110 replies Author Time Post
trotsky Mar 2017 OP
Act_of_Reparation Mar 2017 #1
nolabels Mar 2017 #2
Lordquinton Mar 2017 #3
trotsky Mar 2017 #4
Angry Dragon Mar 2017 #5
Angry Dragon Mar 2017 #6
AtheistCrusader Mar 2017 #7
Angry Dragon Mar 2017 #8
AtheistCrusader Mar 2017 #9
guillaumeb Mar 2017 #13
AtheistCrusader Mar 2017 #14
guillaumeb Mar 2017 #17
edhopper Mar 2017 #21
AtheistCrusader Mar 2017 #25
uriel1972 Mar 2017 #48
beam me up scottie Mar 2017 #49
guillaumeb Mar 2017 #56
beam me up scottie Mar 2017 #57
guillaumeb Mar 2017 #58
beam me up scottie Mar 2017 #59
guillaumeb Mar 2017 #60
beam me up scottie Mar 2017 #61
guillaumeb Mar 2017 #62
beam me up scottie Mar 2017 #63
guillaumeb Mar 2017 #68
beam me up scottie Mar 2017 #72
guillaumeb Mar 2017 #74
beam me up scottie Mar 2017 #78
guillaumeb Mar 2017 #80
beam me up scottie Mar 2017 #82
guillaumeb Mar 2017 #83
beam me up scottie Mar 2017 #85
guillaumeb Mar 2017 #86
beam me up scottie Mar 2017 #88
guillaumeb Mar 2017 #90
beam me up scottie Mar 2017 #93
guillaumeb Mar 2017 #95
beam me up scottie Mar 2017 #99
Goblinmonger Mar 2017 #65
guillaumeb Mar 2017 #69
Goblinmonger Mar 2017 #70
guillaumeb Mar 2017 #71
beam me up scottie Mar 2017 #73
guillaumeb Mar 2017 #75
beam me up scottie Mar 2017 #79
guillaumeb Mar 2017 #81
beam me up scottie Mar 2017 #84
guillaumeb Mar 2017 #87
beam me up scottie Mar 2017 #89
guillaumeb Mar 2017 #91
beam me up scottie Mar 2017 #92
guillaumeb Mar 2017 #94
LineLineLineLineLineLineLineLineLineLineReply That's your opinion. I'll defer to scientists if you don't mind.
beam me up scottie Mar 2017 #97
guillaumeb Mar 2017 #98
edhopper Mar 2017 #100
guillaumeb Mar 2017 #101
edhopper Mar 2017 #102
Goblinmonger Mar 2017 #103
guillaumeb Mar 2017 #104
Goblinmonger Mar 2017 #105
guillaumeb Mar 2017 #107
edhopper Mar 2017 #15
Doodley Mar 2017 #27
edhopper Mar 2017 #33
bobalew Mar 2017 #36
LostOne4Ever Mar 2017 #39
edhopper Mar 2017 #40
LostOne4Ever Mar 2017 #44
Warpy Mar 2017 #54
uriel1972 Mar 2017 #10
kwassa Mar 2017 #11
Goblinmonger Mar 2017 #42
trotsky Mar 2017 #109
hrmjustin Mar 2017 #45
guillaumeb Mar 2017 #12
edhopper Mar 2017 #16
guillaumeb Mar 2017 #18
edhopper Mar 2017 #19
guillaumeb Mar 2017 #20
edhopper Mar 2017 #22
guillaumeb Mar 2017 #55
edhopper Mar 2017 #64
guillaumeb Mar 2017 #67
trotsky Mar 2017 #110
edhopper Mar 2017 #23
dchill Mar 2017 #28
Warpy Mar 2017 #77
bobalew Mar 2017 #37
The Sand Reckoner Mar 2017 #106
Jonny Appleseed Mar 2017 #29
Lordquinton Mar 2017 #24
Bretton Garcia Mar 2017 #41
beam me up scottie Mar 2017 #51
Doodley Mar 2017 #26
Jonny Appleseed Mar 2017 #31
uriel1972 Mar 2017 #66
edhopper Mar 2017 #34
Laffy Kat Mar 2017 #30
Lunabell Mar 2017 #32
JenniferJuniper Mar 2017 #35
edhopper Mar 2017 #38
beam me up scottie Mar 2017 #43
uriel1972 Mar 2017 #46
beam me up scottie Mar 2017 #47
hrmjustin Mar 2017 #50
beam me up scottie Mar 2017 #52
hrmjustin Mar 2017 #53
Motley13 Mar 2017 #76
Eko Mar 2017 #96
Iggo Mar 2017 #108
Please login to view edit histories.