Reply #17: Interesting post

[naaman fletcher]

Your post is interesting for how completely illogical it is.

Example 1:

so there shouldn't be any more stuidies...

No where did the poster say that there should not be any more studies.

Example 2:

according to your magical thinking, everything is all OK.

Nowhere did the poster say everything is ok. The poster said that the statement "we killed it" was false, which it obviously is as despite all the damage there is still plenty of wildlife and sealife.

Example 3:

Toxic dispersant is used by BP to cover up the amount of oil spilled- Abracadabra! There is no damage.

Nowhere did the poster say that there was no damage.

Is it possible that you meant to send this reply to another thread where somebody said the gulf experienced no damage, everything is ok, and there shouldn't be anymore studies?