Reply #17: I think I wasn't clear.

[JerseygirlCT]

I think for the Jews protesting, this *is* partly about history. When your people have been subjected to the horrors they have, words like these are understandably frightening.

And yes, I think the ultra-conservatives that run the RCC (thanks to JPII and his stacking the deck, so to speak, with them) feel all comfie cozy with the old language that allows them to pat themselves on the back and feel all superior. They're only comfortable with absolutes.

The Mass is no less beautiful when the disrespectful prayer for the conversion of the Jews is eliminated. Replacing it may satisfy some RCs, but it will also cause pain and increase barriers between two faiths that ought to be working toward mutual respect and understanding.