NYT movie review, "Stop-Loss": Back From Iraq, on a Road Going Nowhere

[DeepModem Mom]

Movie Review
Stop-Loss (2007)
Back From Iraq, on a Road Going Nowhere
By A. O. SCOTT
Published: March 28, 2008

“Stop-Loss,” Kimberly Peirce’s long-awaited follow-up to “Boys Don’t Cry,” arrives in theaters in the wake of some dispiriting milestones. We have just marked the fifth anniversary of the United States-led invasion of Iraq and the 4,000th American military death since the war began. The level of violence appears to be creeping up again, and troop levels are likely to stay where they are, at least until the next president’s inauguration.

So in some ways, there is a grim, accidental timeliness in the release of “Stop-Loss,” which focuses on the ordeal of American soldiers in and out of combat. Not that the movie’s topicality will necessarily draw crowds. For many viewers (and some critics as well), the prospect of another Iraq movie, like so much else about the war, is likely to be more wearying than galvanizing. The commercial failure of last autumn’s crop of high-profile Iraq-themed movies — Paul Haggis’s “In the Valley of Elah” and Brian De Palma’s “Redacted” among them — has hardened into conventional wisdom about the moviegoing public’s reluctance to engage the war on screen. But those movies did not necessarily deserve their fate, and it would be a shame if “Stop-Loss” were to follow them into oblivion.

I say this partly because Ms. Peirce’s movie, which she wrote with Mark Richard, is not only an earnest, issue-driven narrative, but also a feverish entertainment, a passionate, at times overwrought melodrama gaudy with violent actions and emotions. The sober, mournful piety that has characterized a lot of the other fictional features about Iraq — documentaries are another matter — is almost entirely missing from “Stop-Loss,” which is being distributed by Paramount’s youth-friendly label MTV Films. Not that the movie is unsentimental — far from it — but its messy, chaotic welter of feeling has a tang of authenticity. Instead of high-minded indignation or sorrow, it runs on earthier fuel: sweat, blood, beer, testosterone, loud music and an ideologically indeterminate, freewheeling sense of rage.

Most of these elements are present in the very first scenes, which show mock-amateur video of young soldiers at rest and on duty. Their teasing is raucous and rude, and it is clear from the start that they are neither saints nor monsters, but rather the impure products of American pop culture. With exaggerated bravado, they sing “Courtesy of the Red, White and Blue (The Angry American),” Toby Keith’s anthem of 9/11 payback, which threatens righteous whuppings for America’s enemies: “And it feels like the whole wide world is raining down on you.” Instead, the world comes crashing down on the soldiers. Staff Sgt. Brandon King (Ryan Phillippe) and his squad, supervising a checkpoint in Tikrit, are drawn into a firefight that leaves some of them dead, others horribly wounded, and the rest badly shaken, both by the loss of their friends and by the deaths of Iraqi civilians. After the trauma of that battle, Brandon and his best pal, Steve Shriver (Channing Tatum), are especially relieved to be done with their tours, and they return home to Brazos, Tex., looking forward to a normal life of Lone Star hell-raising.

As their fellow Texan Steve Earle — the Toby Keith of the left — puts it in one of his songs, somebody somewhere had another plan. Brandon discovers that the military has invoked its stop-loss policy, extending his contract and requiring him to go back to Iraq for another tour....

http://movies.nytimes.com/2008/03/28/movies/28stop.html

[peacetalksforall]

1. Look at the slant of the NYT -

"Not that the movie’s topicality will necessarily draw crowds. For many viewers (and some critics as well), the prospect of another Iraq movie, like so much else about the war, is likely to be more wearying than galvanizing. "

"The sober, mournful piety that has characterized a lot of the other fictional features about Iraq — documentaries are another matter ...."

Some may find this review objective, I see the put down of dealing with anything critical of Dear Dick..

[DeepModem Mom]

2. I'm not sure that's fair. I've never, ever seen any slant among the NYT movie critics.

"But those movies did not necessarily deserve their fate, and it would be a shame if 'Stop-Loss' were to follow them into oblivion." I don't think any film critics are pleased with the box office failure of the Iraq movies that have come out in the last year or so. But not to acknowledge their disappointing lack of success is being less than honest. I think Scott is hoping this one will succeed.

And I'm afraid he's right with his point about people maybe not wanting to see Iraq movies. If people no longer want this war, and they don't, they may not want to see a movie about it.

[peacetalksforall]

3. I can see your point. I guess I'm so prejudiced against the NYT that I'm

ready to see stuff in their movie reviews.

I'm not sure about people not wanting to see things Iraq.

I am trying to see everything with an emphasis on documentaries.

I beg people to see Taxi to the Dark Side. Even DUers who know a lot disjointedly - seeing it put together like this is essential.

I never get tired of Holocaust movies or Vietnam or WW 2 - as long they pass my credibility test.

I learn. I reinforce. And can't understand why Dick Cheney didn't learn what I did - war is useless to all normal people who believe that we were put here to rise above raw, brutal, torturous murder of brothers and skin, bone, organ, mind, and future breaking crimes, beatings, torture for pleasure or infromation.

One part of the Christian faith followers believe that the body is the temple of the soul.

I never drempt I would spend the beginning years of this century like this.

[DeepModem Mom]

4. An eloquent and very moving post, higher class. I wish people would see these films...

and the documentaries. Maybe it's a matter of "out-of-sight-out-of-mind" -- which is the goal the Bush cabal is after with such as not even honoring our Iraq dead with views of their flag-draped homecomings.

Cheney, and others, seem somehow to be "wired" differently. I don't know what's wrong with them. I have noticed that even some supporters among the other side can't stomach Cheney.