Canada: a fearfully parochial place
In the general election runup, the fuss about Michael Ignatieff's Canadian credentials points to a nation retreating in on itselfParis Gourtsoyannis
guardian.co.uk, Wednesday 13 April 2011
In 1998 Michael Ignatieff, the Canadian Liberal party leader and former globetrotting academic, said that he voted Labour in Britain's 1997election to oust the Conservatives – or in his own words, "to get the rascals out". It is looking increasingly unlikely that after the 2 May general election in Canada, Ignatieff will be able to repeat the same boast.
The Liberal campaign hardly got off to a good start, with Ignatieff's declaration that he wouldn't seek a coalition after the vote implying that the Liberals weren't interested in governing. It is the latest furore over the Liberal leader's voting record, however, that not only has the potential to hand victory to Stephen Harper's Conservatives, but also underlines the social and cultural malaise that has taken hold in the half decade of Harper's leadership.
.....(snip).....
Modern Canada seems to be retreating in on itself, clinging to the security of its own cultural stereotypes. The coincidence with Harper's leadership is difficult to escape; George Monbiot wrote powerfully in 2009 that the Conservative environmental policy had seen Canada degenerate into a "thuggish petro-state". His only inaccuracy was not seeing just how far that transformation had gone. In 21st- century Canada a Conservative incumbent candidate in Calgary can attack his Liberal opponent as being a "visitor from Toronto" simply because she attended university there – despite the fact they are both of immigrant origin. A Pakistani-born commentator can plough a furrow through the public debate, warning of the danger of radical Islamism in a country with a Muslim community making up just 2% of the total population.
This isn't George W Bush's America, this is Canada, today. It seems ludicrous, in a country that has participated in every UN peacekeeping mission in history; one whose last governor general was a Haitian refugee-turned-journalist. There is seemingly no reason for a flight to monolithic cultural values, with Canada weathering the economic storm far better than most developed countries. However, far from being comforted by economic prosperity, in the past decade Canadians have become more afraid of one another, to the extent that even lost boys like Omar Khadr and far-left pin-ups like George Galloway are deemed toxic national threats. ...............(more)
The complete piece is at:
http://www.guardian.co.uk/commentisfree/cifamerica/2011/apr/13/canada-michael-ignatieff-election