Eowyn - hotter than Arwen, not as hot as Galadriel.

[Rabrrrrrr]

No one's as hot as Galadriel.

Even in the books, Galadriel was always the hottest of all hotties to me. With Eowyn second runner-up.

The casting for the movies was perfect.

[democracyindanger]

1. Galadriel is too creepy

You really wanna go out with a girl who can read your mind?

[Rabrrrrrr]

2. Dude, you couldn't begin to imagine the hots I have for her

woof! woof!!!

[democracyindanger]

11. picture this

You're taking a nice Sunday afternoon nap. Suddenly, she appears as a glowing apparition in your dream, saying, "Rabrrrrr...you must arise and prepare for the coming of my parents...take thee now to Supercuts and get a haircut, and do not tarry...forget not to stop at Safeway for a pint of Dreyer's...and be sure to use the coupon...tomorrow, you will be desirous of relations with me, but it is not destined, for you will do something shameful in front of my parents, so forget it..."

Gimme the wild child Eowyn. :evilgrin:

[bilgewaterbill]

14. That's the funniest thing I read all day! nt

[GOPBasher]

28. HAHAHAHA That has me laughing my ass off. Thanks! nt

[DS1]

19. Only if she kept saying "Okay"

:evilgrin:

[Rabrrrrrr]

22. ROTFL!!

Can always count on DS1 for just the perfect response.

:-)

You can be damn sure my thoughts would almost constantly be of the type that I'd want her to be saying "okay". But on the other hand, my hope is that she'd be so much into the "okay" range that it would actually fall to me to say no occasionally, to slow us down.

[eyesroll]

3. I went to junior high with a Galadriel, and to college with an Arwen.

I don't actually remember what either of them looked like.

[lastknowngood]

4. If you enjoyed the films be sure to read Bored of the Rings by

the harvard lampoon. Get a six pack and some chips and laugh your ass off.

[Rabrrrrrr]

7. I read that in Junior High! Hilarious!

"It's my party and I'll snub who I want to".

I really should read it again. It's been a long time.

[mondo joe]

5. Eowyn is emotionally unstable

She's all over the map - falling for Aragorn, sneaking off the war thhen being afraid, seeming masterful then uncertain.

For my money THE most clumsy character in the movies.

Sure Arwen is sort of goth-mopey girl, but at least she's consistent.

[tigereye]

25. I dunno

I'd call Eowyn spunky and normal. And she swings a mean sword.

Eowyn kicks ass the old-fashioned way with no spirit or Elvin advantages. That gives her the edge in my book, she's the most "normal" woman of the bunch. :)

[mondo joe]

39. I seriously don't find unstable people like her appealing

Honestly - she needs a mood stabilizer.

Now I'm in love, now I'm not, now I'm scared, now I'm a master swordswoman, now I'm scared again.

She could have been a great character (in the movie anyway), but Jackson had her all over the map. If I knew her I'd keep my distance.

[tigereye]

40. I really don't think that qualifies as unstable

Young, confused, dramatic heroine- speak, perhaps

but that's just me. :)

[ZenLefty]

31. How come nobody likes Rosie Cotton?

:loveya:

[Mike Daniels]

34. I have issues with women that have more foot hair than me

and that's Hobbit or not.

[ZenLefty]

35. Dude, she owns a bar!

I can get past foot hair for that. :beer:

[Radical Activist]

37. lol

That's a plus, but she still comes up a little short.

[realisticphish]

6. yeah

galadrial is hot, and uber-powerful. and eowyn is badass, she fought a naz gul, for christ's sake

[sportndandy]

8. None compares to Luthien Tinuviel

A Elbereth Gilthoniel
Siliveren penna miriel

We still remember
we who dwell
in this far land beneath the trees
the sunlight on the western seas

[ashmanonar]

15. yea, i have to say...

gimme a luthien any day. she gave up immortality, man. that's commitment.

[Rabrrrrrr]

20. Aye, but so did Arwen. But I can't take Luthien because she's Tolkien's.

It's on his wife's tombstone.

[ashmanonar]

23. heh.

true.

i'm still torn on the other two tho. arwen is of the line of luthien, so that's something: but eowyn is a hardass...

then again, in the movie, arwen is too. :shrug:

[Rabrrrrrr]

24. Maybe we should just take all three, and not be choosy

:evilgrin:

[ashmanonar]

32. yea, i could deal with that.

:grouphug:

:evilgrin:

[AllegroRondo]

38. O Luthien, O Luthien

a liar like all elves and men

[Fenris]

9. I prefer Eowyn

Hot blonde with a sword! :D

[tigereye]

26. kudos for you Fenris!

:)

[YankeyMCC]

10. Eowyn

Was always my favorite. Something about a sword wielding horse riding hieress I guess :) (Although I was never a Xena fan).

Arwen was a close second for me. Galadriel was a little to ethereal for me.

[Rabrrrrrr]

13. Mmmm... I'm totally into Ethereal and the wisdom of countless eons

But Eowyn is very close. I'd be happy with either. I'd even be happy with Arwen.

But I'd rather have G or E.

I also like the wildness and spirit of entrepreneurship of Eowyn. Not to mention her beauty, and her willingness to wield a sword and defend her people, while still remaining fairly feminine.

[YankeyMCC]

17. I think we're pretty close to agreement

just a slight matter of degree that changes the order of our picks. :)

[jpgray]

12. Cate Blanchett always seemed very attractive to me

And Miranda Otto is way better-looking than Liv Tyler, so I'd agree with you on the order there. Reading the books I didn't make any attributions of hotness whatsoever.

:P

[ashmanonar]

16. hey, waht about legolas?

she was hot, man...


wait...


OH MY GOD!















:7

[YankeyMCC]

18. LOL!

:cry:

[Rabrrrrrr]

21. What?! You mean Taylor Hanson is a guy?! OMG! But, I have

all those magazines.... OMG!!

[Arkana]

41. Heh, heh...all right.

Giggity giggity giggity giggity goo!

[blindpig]

27. um, the age thing?

She's what, at least 5, 6 thousand years old? All of those Valinor in-jokes might become tedious.

[GOPBasher]

29. Galadriel is like 600 yrs old, but yeah, she's still the hottest.

I agree with you. Galdriel's the hottest, followed Eowyn and then Arwen. Thought Arwen is still pretty hot, just as much as the other two.

[kodi]

30. try 6,000 plus, she is the mother of elrond's wife,

i take eowynover the others.

[ashmanonar]

33. yep.

not about the eowyn thing, but about galadriel. she's as old as time, essentially. basically there from the first. she is second generation i believe, daughter of finwe. ALL of her brothers were kings in middle-earth.

[Radical Activist]

36. I'll take Eowyn any day of the week

The curly blonde hair and blue eyes. And she can kick ass when needed. :loveya: