Luke Skywalker vs. Paul Atreides

[pokerfan]

Who would win?

[laconicsax]

1. Win what?

[pokerfan]

2. whatever you want

[Chovexani]

3. I think Paul

Can the Force block the Voice, though?

[Lethe]

4. ugh. .....ugh.... ....shiat. ...... Paul

although they both were on desert planets

"LONG SUBJECTS REQUIRE PERIODIC SPACES" ... bitch dont tell me how to write my subject line.

[The Animator]

5. Luke's a whinny bitch like his father before him.

Fett could take em' both.

[CGowen]

6. Arthritis n/t

[Richard Steele]

7. One of their stupid whiney asses would die; therefore, we ALL win. nm

[Orsino]

8. Luke has already won.

No one will ever make a movie about Paul again.

[Dr. Strange]

11. Guess again...

Peter Berg is working on a another Dune: http://io9.com/337135/dune-remake-will-be-budget+killer

[Orsino]

12. This movie won't be made...

...and if it is, no one will see it. :7

[Dr. Strange]

13. Paul will see it.

He's already seen it with his prescient vision. In fact, he used his prana-bindu training to leave the movie during the opening credits.

[mainegreen]

9. Oh please. Paul would.

Luke is a Jedi, but Paul is a MESSIAH, and nearly the pinnacle of human perfection (I think technically the mantle of human perfection fell to his son).

[underpants]

10. Ooh blind but he can control his metabollism!!!WOW!

Luke wins

[YankeyMCC]

14. War geared and raging Atreides of course

oh wait I was thinking of Paul's cousins Menelaus and Agamemnon

[Nicholas D Wolfwood]

15. Atreides, hands down.

[noonwitch]

16. Luke's got more loyal back-up in Leia and Han

Not to mention Chewie and the spirits of Obi-wan, Yoda and his dad. And the whole planet of ewoks, but I guess that's more akin to having the tribbles on your side.

[unpossibles]

17. Paul

Luke is nothing but a bad rip-off copy of Paul anyway. Plus he has no Gurney Halleck or Duncan Idaho.

[pokerfan]

18. Duncan was played by Solo, Obi-wan played Gurney

at least that's the way I see it.

[Dr. Strange]

19. Feyd Rautha shot first.

I don't care what Lucas says!

[pokerfan]

20. Feyd cheated!

BTW, this deserves a repost:
Star Wars according to a 3 year old