Misleading growth statistics give false comfort

[flashl]

Prepositions matter. The recent government report that US gross domestic product increased 0.6 per cent in the first quarter was very misleading. It implied that economic activity was rising in January, February and March. But the increase actually refers to the rise from the average level in the fourth quarter of 2007 to the average level in the first quarter. Monthly data since January indicate that economic activity and GDP have been declining since the start of this year.

Private sector payroll employment peaked last November and has fallen five months in a row, shedding more than 300,000 jobs. Industrial production was lower in March than in December and January. Real personal income net of taxes and transfers is also lower than in January. Real retail sales have fallen since the start of the year. Private housing starts are down 13 per cent in just the two months since January and 36 per cent from a year ago.

...

The misstatement that the economy expanded in the first quarter creates an inappropriately sanguine view of the months ahead and therefore reduces the prospect of strong action to prevent the deep decline that may otherwise occur. Carlos Gutierrez, the commerce secretary, whose department produces the GDP estimates, said the 0.6 per cent increase supported the administration’s view that growth would be slower but positive in the first half. The administration predicts that after this slowdown the economy will grow more rapidly in the second half and in 2009.

...

Because US mortgages are “no-recourse” loans (lenders have no recourse to the house’s owner beyond the value of the house), individuals with negative equity have an incentive to default. There are now an estimated 8m negative-equity mortgages – more than 15 per cent of all outstanding mortgages. Defaults are rising and foreclosures are now at twice the rate of a year ago. A downward spiral in house prices would cause a fall in household wealth and in the capital of financial institutions, potentially resulting in a deeper and longer recession than any seen in the past several decades.