Bush making health-care proposals a priority in 2006? Bush previewed three domestic themes of his upcoming State of the Union addressAbramoff and Medicare
from
John Holbo He's reading
Off Center. Here’s something from p. 87:
When the debate over prescription drug coverage picked up in the late Clinton years, the pharmaceutical lobbying group PhRMA (Pharmaceutical Research and Manufacturers Association, pronounced “Farma”) went so far as to establish a faux grassroots organization that putatively represented the elderly:
“Citizens for a Better Medicare.” Despite the lofty title, Citizens for a Better Medicare had few, if any, actual citizens on its rolls Its main activity was to spend millions of PhRMA dollars on slick ad campaigns supporting an industry-friendly drug plan. When Citizens for a Better Medicare came under fire, PhRMA switched its “grassroots” efforts over to the
United Seniors Association, a conservative direct-mail organization that had cut its teeth with frightening scare letters to senior citizens. The United Seniors Association board included, among other GOP political operatives,
Jack Abramoff …
from the
Campaign Finance Institute:
Citizens for a Better Medicare reportedly spent about $50 million on television advertising during the 1999-2000 cycle. In the 75 media markets monitored by Campaign Media Analysis Group (CMAG), CBM spent $13.8 million on advertisements praising House Republicans between June 1 and Election Day. It spent more on House races than any other interest group. According to the Brennan Center for Justice, CBM's top race was in the 49th district of California, between Rep. Brian Bilbray (R) and Susan Davis (D). The Wall Street Journal reported that CBM spent close to $800,000 praising Bilbray, while CMAG estimated the spending at close to $1.5 million. CBM ran advertisements praising several other incumbents for their record on Medicare, including Reps. Jay Dickey (R-AR), Charles Bass (R-NH), George Nethercutt (R-WA), James Rogan (R-CA), Steve Kuykendall (R-CA), Don Sherwood (R-PA), Ernie Fletcher (R-KY), Anne Northup (R-KY), Tom Tancredo (R-CO) and Collin Peterson (D-MN). CBM ran advertisements criticizing Reps. Bill Luther (D-MN), Mark Udall (D-CO), Leonard Boswell (D-IA) and Darlene Hooley (D-OR). They also targeted Montana Senate candidate Brian Schweitzer, who had made the prescription drug issue central to his campaign.
CBM was originally created as a 527 political organization; after the passage of disclosure legislation this summer, it changed its status to a 501 (c) 4 social welfare organization. CBM stopped receiving contributions after the passage of the disclosure law, so its quarterly report submitted in October did not show any contributions.
Alex Castellanos, CBM's media consultant, also worked for the George W. Bush campaign and for the Republican National Committee. from
Public Citizen:
United Seniors Association, which spent an estimated $13.6 million to influence at least 25 U.S. Senate and House races in 2002, has been active in at least 17 contests so far in 2004, including spending at least $370,500 to help Rep. Jim Gerlach (R-Pa.) and at least $141,000 to assist Rep. Phil Crane (R-Ill.).
United Seniors Association (USA) burst onto the soft money scene in 2002, when it spent $18.6 million on advertising, according to its filing with the IRS.2 Some of its expenditures paid for issue advocacy communications in the summer of that year while Congress was debating a Medicare prescription drug bill, as chronicled in this Public Citizen report: United Seniors Association: Hired Guns for PhRMA and Other Corporate Interests. But USA reserved the majority of its advertising budget for the two months before Election Day.
USA was founded by Richard Viguerie, a conservative who pioneered the art of using direct mail pitches to solicit small political contributions.6 But the group has grown increasingly reliant on large donors in recent years. USA, which had 2001 revenue of $8.6 million, posted $25.4 million in revenue in 2002; of that $20.1 million came from a single donor, according USA's filing with the IRS.7 The Pharmaceutical Research and Manufacturers of America (PhRMA), the trade association of the brand name pharmaceutical industry, said it gave "an unrestricted educational grant" to USA in 2002.8 9 Because most of USA's ads emphasized prescription drugs, it is likely that PhRMA was the $20.1 million contributor. In 2001, USA reported to the IRS that it received a $1.5 million contribution from PhRMA.10
USA's officers and consultants are steeped in Republican politics. Its president is Charles Jarvis, who served in the Reagan and George H.W. Bush administrations. Members of its board of directors have included
Jack Abramoff, who is among the foremost fundraisers for the Republican Party and a top fundraiser for President Bush, and Craig Shirley, a Republican operative whose involvement with soft money political spending dates back to at least 1988, when he played a leading role in creating the "Willie Horton" political ad. USA's lobbyist, David Keene, is chairman of the American Conservative Union, and previously worked for Vice President Spiro Agnew, Ronald Reagan, George H.W. Bush and Bob Dole.
Bush in
July 2003:
"On a piece of
legislation like this, it obviously attracts the attention of advocates, people who are willing to get involved in the process, people who work hard on behalf of the constituents they represent. Today we've got Jim Parkel and Bill Novelli. Jim is the president, Bill Novelli is the director and CEO of AARP. I'm honored you all are here. Thanks, thanks for providing such good leadership for all. (Applause.)
There's a group involved in the process called
United Seniors Association. It's headed by Charlie Jarvis. He's the chairman and CEO, and Charlie is with us today. Thank you for coming, Charlie. (Applause.)"
As he signs Medicare legislation Bush cites the
'hard work' done by Charlie Jarvis, the Chairman and CEO of United Seniors Association:
"Charlie Jarvis, the Chairman and CEO of
United Seniors Association, worked hard. Mike Maves, the Executive Vice President and CEO of the AMA, worked hard on this piece of legislation. (Applause.) Mary Martin, the Chairman of the Board of The Seniors Coalition, worked hard. The truth of the matter is, a lot of good people worked hard to get this important legislation done, and I thank you for your work. (Applause.)"