|
to control someone could work, is lack of knowledge or ability to have perspective by average voters in the population.
If one joke, or bad thing, can be used to smear people, it requires a group that will judge the person based on that alone. Sometimes you even see reports of comments from hearsay used to define people. The ability for people too believe it defines the whole character of a person, is one of the faults of society. In a healthy society, such things only work when it supports an already held belief, so only works if it was a small part of a larger evaluation of character. If it was a pattern of behavior and truly defining, then it has meaning.
However, the wiretapping alone is not the problem, it is that it can be used as a weapon, and who holds that weapon that is the problem. Quite simply the group that has control over that information could gain more power then deserved through intimidation. But the push back is to prosecute those that allowed it to happen, or for people, since many people have access to the system, to share its misuses to the population.
In theory if the information is meant to protect people from violence and corruption, then a use of such information for political gain, would be struck down by the vary people that have the information, for using such things for politics(like the J Edgar Hoover files were said to do) for using it for politics lowers the integrity of groups that defend for sake of justice. For example, J Edgar had some successes with his info, but lowered the respect of the organization by his tactics.
The reason wire tapping is wrong, without court order, is because of how easy it can be missued. But if it can not be removed, then the only solution would be to make information on everyone available to everyone. This removes secrecy. However it shifts the problem of information outside of perspective being gathered, to who has the megaphone to spread that information. Just making it a new problem of information flow and learning of the population.
Imagine if everything a person ever said could be mined for one sentence, then the entire person is defined by that sentence. (Rev Wright is a good example of this happening). But the knowledge that that is being done changes it to the smearer looking bad. As people realize what is being done.
The people that use gossip and smear for self gain, do something without integrity or honor, and in that, the gain of some believing it, is far less then the loss of even more that realize the wrong that was done, and in the end leads to the demise of those that used those tactics. Which is interesting also.
|