General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsA Bogus Deal on Nafta - By The NYT Editorial Board
President Trumps agreement with Mexico will hurt American workers, not help them.
The editorial board represents the opinions of the board, its editor and the publisher. It is separate from the newsroom and the Op-Ed section.
Sept. 2, 2018
The North American Free Trade Agreement is a nearly 25-year-old agreement that needs to be modernized to address new technologies, update intellectual property rights and protect American industry and workers from unfair competition. Instead, President Trump has proposed replacing Nafta with something worse, a vague agreement that could hurt American workers and raise prices for American consumers while antagonizing Americas neighbors.
In the Trumpian worldview, Canada isnt a friendly neighbor but a frosty enemy bent on ruining our steel, auto and dairy industries while cutting down forests in British Columbia and trucking the lumber across the border. Fiends! Likewise, as he sees it, Mexico ships tequila, produce and people north, and imports our higher-paying manufacturing jobs. Desperados! Yet his solutions would simply add complications with few benefits.
Under the revised, dont-call-it-Nafta bilateral deal with Mexico that he awkwardly announced last week, 75 percent of the value of vehicles exported to the United States would have to come from North American-made parts, up from the current 62.5 percent. And 40-to-45 percent of the value would have to be made by workers who earn at least $16 an hour, even though no Mexican autoworkers earn $16 an hour, and none will. Otherwise, Mexican-assembled vehicles would be subject to a 2.5 percent tariff.
The logic here is that auto-related jobs would supposedly flood back to the United States as labor costs rise in Mexico. That logic is dubious. Automakers in Mexico would rather pay the 2.5 percent tariff, figuring it would not raise prices enough to hurt sales seriously. If it did, they could stop making those cars for the American market.
Mr. Trump has particular animus for the dairy industry in Canada. Theres no question that protectionist constraints keep milk prices there high and farmers profitable. The Canadians have pointed to subsidies that American farmers get and are resisting Mr. Trumps no-compromise demand to throw their cows under the bus. Mr. Trump also wants Canada to join Mexico in agreeing to drop Chapter 19 of Nafta, a dispute resolution protocol. Canada has used it to fight off tariffs on its softwood and paper products. Mr. Trumps softwood and paper tariffs are hurting Canadian industry, but also are raising lumber prices in the United States so much that the housing market has slowed. Isnt that a great deal?
more
https://www.nytimes.com/2018/09/02/opinion/trump-nafta-deal.html
Achilleaze
(15,543 posts)republican lies are dangerous for America
republican lies are dangerous for America
republican lies are dangerous for America
republican lies are dangerous for America
republican lies are dangerous for America
republican lies are dangerous for America
republican lies are dangerous for America
republican lies are dangerous for America
republican lies are dangerous for America
republican lies are dangerous for America
republican lies are dangerous for America
republican lies are dangerous for America
republican lies are dangerous for America
republican lies are dangerous for America
republican lies are dangerous for America
Jarqui
(10,130 posts)He knows the numbers and that Canada's trade numbers are not that bad - US trade surplus except on energy.
A tough position in the media on NAFTA - creating a 'fake fight' that looks like he is standing up for American workers - helps Trump again in the Rust Belt
Trump doesn't give a shit about anyone else. This is all about saving his ass from impeachment in the midterms - making these overtures to shore up votes.
Canada is a perfect target because a lot of their media freely spills across the border and it's all in English (unlike Mexico). It's free election advertising.
matt819
(10,749 posts)A bogus deal on (Fill in the blank).
North Korea
Tariffs
NAFTA
Helsinki Summit
Health Care
Immigration
Care to add more?
The NYT Editorial Board should be sure to keep the template for that editorial. It applies to everything the buffoon-in-chief does.
All bogus. All republican lies. All Fake all the time (R).