General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsSlate - "Hello, Justice Kavanaugh. Farewell, Roe."
Democrats had a shot at stopping Kavanaugh and saving the constitutional right to abortion access. They blew it.
By MARK JOSEPH STERN
SEPT 03, 2018 7:00 PM
https://slate.com/news-and-politics/2018/09/can-democrats-stop-brett-kavanaugh-from-overturning-roe-v-wade.html
In a few weeks, the Senate will likely confirm Judge Brett Kavanaugh to the U.S. Supreme Court, where he will serve a lifetime appointment. A few years after he joins the benchor as early as next JuneKavanaugh will cast the decisive vote in a 54 decision that will eviscerate Roe v. Wade. Within hours, days, and weeks of that ruling, a slew of states will outlaw or severely limit abortion; others will resume enforcing abortion bans that remain on the books. None of this is hypothetical or seriously debatable. The American conservative movement has spent decades waiting for this exact moment. Now that it has arrived, they are determined not to miss their opportunityand by all indications, they will not. Republicans are on the brink of achieving their long sought-after goal of abolishing the constitutional right to abortion access.
It is not surprising that conservatives have perfectly executed their well-laid plan to reverse Roe. What is remarkable, however, is how little resistance they have faced from progressives. While a majority of Democratic senators have already voiced their hostility to Kavanaugh, their base has utterly failed to mount a vigorous, sustained opposition to his nomination. If, today, liberals could channel a fraction of the outrage they will feel after Kavanaugh overturns Roe, they would have a shot at keeping him off the court. Instead, their relative apathy toward his impending confirmation has likely doomed reproductive rights for at least a generation.
Kavanaugh has not been particularly subtle about his distaste for Roe and its successor, Planned Parenthood v. Casey. In his current job on the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit, Kavanaugh attempted to manipulate these precedents in order to prevent an undocumented immigrant minor from terminating her pregnancy. Under Casey, the government cannot impose an undue burden on a woman seeking an abortion before viability. Yet the Trump administration had imposed a flat ban on abortion for undocumented minors in federally funded shelters. (It maintained that minors who wished to terminate their pregnancies should either find a sponsor in the U.S.a near impossible task for many without family hereor leave the country.) Kavanaugh held that this position did not constitute an undue burden, in a ruling which would have forced Jane Doe, a 17-year-old who was already 15 weeks pregnant, to continue her unwanted pregnancy.
There is little mystery to how all this ends.
The full D.C. Circuit swiftly overturned Kavanaughs ruling and granted Doe access to abortion. In response, Kavanaugh penned a furious dissent that brimmed over with anti-abortion rhetoric. The majority, he sneered, had granted Doe abortion on demanda phrase that, as Irin Carmon notes, is deployed by the right to denote women capriciously making decisions for themselves. He claimed that Doe was not mature enough to make this major life decision on her own, even though she had already received the necessary judicial bypass from a state court. And he asserted, incredibly, that the Trump administration was being unlawfully forced to facilitate Does abortion by merely stepping aside and letting her obtain it. (This argument is fundamentally theological, not legal.)
snip - lots more....this is really depressing - thoughts, DU???
JHan
(10,173 posts)BigmanPigman
(51,651 posts)...and call, and call, and call.....
JHan
(10,173 posts)Bettie
(16,147 posts)then the war among the "Christian" denominations over which of them gets to be in charge.
The Genealogist
(4,723 posts)Once they have cleared the nation of a certain amount of SEE-UN that they all mutually detest, they will turn on each other. It is inevitable, and one needs but a basic knowledge of world history to realize it.
Bettie
(16,147 posts)of various evangelical denominations.
They all think the others aren't "christian" enough.
And ALL the evangelicals hate the Catholics and the Mormons.
When my husband and I were planning to get married, we figured we'd make our families happy and get married in a church. His mother/sisters wouldn't come if we married in a Baptist or non-denominational church. My grandmother and family wouldn't come if we married in a Lutheran church (which wouldn't marry us anyway unless we lived apart for a year first and I did some sort of classes to become a WI Synod Lutheran). None of them would come if we got married at the Unitarian Society (which we both preferred). So, we got married in the courthouse with no relatives there at all (at 8 in the morning in the coldest day of the year).
Those evangelicals generally don't get along with each other.
donkeypoofed
(2,187 posts)Not many bothered to try to save abortion rights,which tell me not many people will be upset about their loss. Oh fucken well.
BigmanPigman
(51,651 posts)The Women's March group IS protesting. You can also write and call.
https://actionnetwork.org/letters/cancelkavanaugh?link_id=11&can_id=bfcadfa948ac07d9bf5b1038644acae5&source=email-cancelkavanaugh-update-30k-from-our-goal&email_referrer=email_411125___subject_517578&email_subject=cancelkavanaugh-update-30k-from-our-goal
Also, last weekend over 150 protests were held around the country. I posted it on DU at least 6 times...look under activist Headquarters for protests. I post them when I get the word from the various groups I belong to.
https://www.democraticunderground.com/10112506
Atticus
(15,124 posts)"At least we did not sink to their level." When they go low, we loudly say "tsk-tsk"!
Be civil, y'all!
DBoon
(22,425 posts)The government would be able to control your sex life, and mandate that sex without babies is forbidden.
Bettie
(16,147 posts)Miranda will be gone soon too, if this idiot gets confirmed.
Civil rights, worker's rights...they have their sights on it all.
lordsummerisle
(4,651 posts)will find a way to have an abortion, Roe V Wade or otherwise. I'm still waiting to hear from the women who had abortions that Trump paid for. David K Johnston has said they're out there but have been so far reluctant to come forward...
greatauntoftriplets
(175,771 posts)Freethinker65
(10,106 posts)Truly scary and depressing.
Totally Tunsie
(10,885 posts)Everything we've fought for will be lost.