General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsHere's what happened when I went door-knocking in Pennsylvania
Thanks to my FB friend Margaret who copied and pasted for those, like me, who dont have WP subscriptions!
Washington Post Opinion
Heres what happened when I went door-knocking in Pennsylvania
By Jane Fonda
August 30
Steve, in his 40s, had a bad day at work but was willing to speak with me. He said theres no politician who will fight for him. He doesnt trust any of them. Thats why he doesnt pay attention to any news. He voted for the Green Party last time as a protest, but he also doesnt like immigrants getting public benefits. We learned all of this because, like with every Working America conversation, we started the conversation by asking Steve what mattered to him, what was on his mind. At the end of our questions, Steve said, Can I ask you something? Why do you do this? He wanted to keep talking.
Edith is in her 50s. She likes what President Trump has done but doesnt like the way he talks sometimes. She thinks cutting government red tape is important, and shes concerned about outside interference in our elections. As we were leaving, she told us, and maybe herself, I dont talk to anyone. Why did I just talk to you?
Last year in San Diego, Sharon said she was 100 percent for Trump, but when I told her Trumps health-care bill would allow her sons insurance company to stop covering him because he has a serious preexisting condition, she seemed to stop breathing for a moment. I had no idea, she gasped. I cant let that happen.
Its voters like these we need to talk with those who are dispirited and confused like Steve; ambivalent like Edith; and uninformed like Sharon. A respectful conversation that started with their concerns and opinions hooked each of them, so when Working America goes back, the door is open to information from a new trusted messenger, which can encourage them to take action on issues they care about and vote with that new information in mind.
Authentic engagement works its a no-brainer. For years now, the researchers measuring the most effective way to win votes have told us that face-to-face contact has the biggest impact. The results in 2018 show us theres an important swingable segment of the electorate that will pull the lever for Democrats if we can reach them. And the science says voters are even more attentive to a canvasser conversation if theyre a member of the organization thats delivering the message.
Ive seen the power of face-to-face contact since I became an activist five decades ago. In Modesto, Calif., I met some of the 800 volunteers who knocked on doors for more than a year before the 2018 election, and in Scranton I met the professional organizers, many of whom are working-class people of color. They talk with people year-round, reaching out to those hungry for information and a connection.
As tangled as things seem right now, the way we get out of this mess is straightforward. We outsmart the Facebook algorithms and digital foreign meddling by holding face-to-face conversations. I've seen it. The process builds trust, and it sends a message: You matter enough that I'm here on your doorstep.
Fear can be so powerful, but what overcomes fear is connection. We dont need to choose between Democratic base voters and swing voters. All working people, no matter their race, ethnicity, gender, faith, or sexual orientation or gender identity, need a stake and a say in our society and they all need to hear that theyre part of We the People. Talking with them, not at them, is the best way to do it. Working America and other organizations are helping volunteers spend time in working-class communities around the country to have those conversations.
Ive learned over my long life as an activist that people can change. That process starts with trust, best done through person-to-person organizing. People such as Steve are looking for someone to help them sort things out and to dare to care again. We can start the process of healing and winning back our country one conversation at a time.
mopinko
(71,937 posts)until we start getting to an agreed upon set of facts, we are screwn. i think jane is right here that people want to know what is true. and she is also right that talking to people one-on-one is a good place to start.
azureblue
(2,322 posts)Tell so many lies that no one knows what the truth is any more. Then people get a "screw it all" attitude. And Don wins by inaction. Tell people how many lies Don as spewed and they refuse to believe it. We can present facts and how the facts affect us all, but if a person has bought into Don's wall of lies, they won't believe anything.
mopinko
(71,937 posts)the trumpkin in my life is getting soft. he thinks he is well informed, but i have kicked his ass so many times, that he is beginning to wonder. or at least to trust me a bit.
you really have to get them dead to rights, tho. dude is my weed dealer, and had no idea what was actually in the new illinois weed law. he spouted off about how legalization isnt good for much, cuz yada yada. every one of his yadas was included in the law. after that i got a lot more- well yeah, there's that.
Larrybanal
(227 posts)huh??? what has trump done? tax cut for very wealthy...imprisoned children...made fun of all our allies? the only thing he has really done is to UNDO everything obama did and or take credit for things like the economy and contracts obama signed but are now taking effect. you can teach the uneducated but you can't teach dumb
CaliforniaPeggy
(152,384 posts)The message is so important and so clear: Talk to people, find out what they want, answer their questions honestly.
Make them remember that we're part of a large community, that we care for each other and that this is the way forward.
People feel isolated and this scares them. When we show them that our community includes them, this leads to trust.
K&R
Hermit-The-Prog
(36,614 posts)If we combine babylonsister's post with egbertowillies' recent post, about how Democrats need to market their protection versus Republicans' assaults, it's a very powerful means of cutting through the cult wall of disinformation.
Edit to add link: https://www.democraticunderground.com/100212422415
Dagstead Bumwood
(5,165 posts)I can't begin to imagine what it's like for her doing that. There are still so many zealots and zealot descendants who are still pissed off at her, that I fear for her safety. Yet, she persists. Good on her.
But seriously who doesn't recognize Jane Fonda when she comes to the door? I mean, even after she calls herself Jane? Maybe I'm just old. Nah. can't be that.
mopinko
(71,937 posts)not surprised they wouldnt recognize her.
i'm sure they are fans of grace and frankie, or 9-to-5 for that matter.
DeminPennswoods
(16,347 posts)has her hair all done up. She's 81 years old. She probably looks like just another older woman canvassing the neighborhood.
DownriverDem
(6,678 posts)When I was a student at Western Michigan University, Jane came and spoke out against the Viet Nam War. She was awesome.
Sogo
(5,840 posts)in getting out and talking with these voters!
Gumboot
(531 posts)... are crucial to winning hearts and minds.
Kudos to Jane Fonda for going out and actually doing this.
bucolic_frolic
(47,531 posts)no matter what is happening, they just have an innate "everything is fine" outlook. They barely ejected Tom Corbett and Ricky Santorum. They've elected Pat Toomey twice.
I think it's because the incumbents have such strong influence in the large media markets of Philly and Pittsburgh. Philly's media were touting both-siderism when it comes to gun control, and this reflects Toomey's media connections I think.
The press should be less accommodating and more skeptical. Just spouting incumbents' doggerel is not journalism, it's propaganda, not to mention stupidity. But the journalists, minor league wannabes though they are, just go along to get along. It's all about their careers.
DeminPennswoods
(16,347 posts)opponent in 2016 who wasn't up to the task of campaigning and winning. Yet he just squeaked by her.
Trenzalore
(2,547 posts)Casey won with 58% of the vote and Wolf won with close to 55%
Toomey ran in 2010 (republican year) and 2016 (republican year mixed with a candidate that no one was excited about).
If the Hillary campaign had kept investing as heavily in PA instead of starting having illusions of a landslide and winning red states they wouldn't have gone to Trump.
bearsfootball516
(6,517 posts)spanone
(137,656 posts)PatrickforO
(15,125 posts)KPN
(16,160 posts)that regular people have legitimate concerns that we as a party are well-suited to address if only we choose to.
mountain grammy
(27,369 posts)I too am afraid for our democracy, never that strong to begin with. I am also scared for my grandchildren.
tblue37
(66,041 posts)DinahMoeHum
(22,515 posts). . .a district leader/precinct captain, you will definitely canvas in your neighborhood.
In my area, the Democratic Party at its most local levels have been working in concert with the Indivisible groups - they have been our canvas reinforcements the past 2 years. Starting 2017, we made our county and many municipalities blue and in 2018 we got the blue trifecta for New York State.
Most of that was done by hitting the pavements in our neighborhoods, talking face-to-face, leaving literature for those who were not home at the time and writing postcards in the last couple of weeks.
This year, we are working to consolidate those gains, re-elect our folks who are up for re-election and prepare for the big one in 2020.
Kentonio
(4,377 posts)DinahMoeHum
(22,515 posts)zentrum
(9,866 posts)....is needed. Year round. Like the Democratic Party had years ago.
But Dean's plan was dumped by the DNC.
not_the_one
(2,227 posts)Sometimes you wonder whose side they are on...
brooklynite
(96,882 posts)Who do you think picked the new DNC Chair?
progressoid
(50,786 posts)GulfCoast66
(11,949 posts)Now many proponents of the 50 state Strategy lament the Democratic Majority in the House being more moderate. Best example is the anger that so many Democratic Representatives dont support impeachment.
But that is what the 50 State Strategy is. Elect Democrats that reflect where they live.
DinahMoeHum
(22,515 posts)Hekate
(95,208 posts)Stuart G
(38,726 posts)Title: Here is What I Found When I went Door Knocking in Pennsylvania:
https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/jane-fonda-the-only-way-to-take-our-country-back-is-one-person-at-a-time/2019/08/30/50cf9dd2-ca96-11e9-be05-f76ac4ec618c_story.html
JudyM
(29,536 posts)Many people just dont have the facts, time or personal inclination to think things through, especially when theyre being fed lies constantly by the faux media.
AnnieBW
(11,341 posts)When people realized who she was? I mean, I grew up in Pennsyltucky. All I knew about Jane Fonda was that she was a "traitorous b*tch" (according to most) who sold out "our boys" in Vietnam. Of course, now I know better. But, when she came out with her aerobics tape in the '80's, a lot of folks wouldn't buy it because it was, well, her.
Ferryboat
(1,053 posts)These techniques on our coworkers family and friends.
The tide can be turned.
Demovictory9
(33,943 posts)PoindexterOglethorpe
(26,825 posts)The Sharons of the world deserve what happens. If they can't be bothered to find out what Trump really intends, then fuck them. They can live with the consequences.
Unfortunately, all the rest of us also have to live with the consequences of her vote.
SunSeeker
(54,008 posts)Everyone should try it.
OnDoutside
(20,672 posts)Mc Mike
(9,173 posts)radical noodle
(8,800 posts)but I tried that approach with a "best friend" who went crazy over trump after having voted for Obama. She is so screwed up that her "truth" is nothing like reality. She no longer believes facts. Trying to talk reasonably with her and listening to her just tore us apart.
Snake Plissken
(4,103 posts)That is your typical Republican ... fuck everyone except for me, they will fully support Trump as he ruins people's lives as long as their life is not among the lives he is ruining.
FakeNoose
(35,981 posts)What has happened to us? The Blue Wave isn't going to happen until we start talking to our neighbors, our friends, and strangers at the supermarket. We can't rely on MSNBC to "educate" people, because that's not gonna happen.
I don't tell people that I'm a liberal or a progressive, I just say that I want everyone's vote to be counted. The judicial system can't be based on a certain judge's political leanings. Health care needs to be available and affordable for everyone. Every child should have a safe school with excellent teachers. I find that people don't want to be lectured, but if you ask a thoughtful question politely, they will usually open up.
Maybe I feel safe because I live in a city where almost everyone is a Democrat. Scranton is in the northeastern corner of Pennsylvania, on the edge of the Poconos, and the area is much more conservative than Pittsburgh is. But if Jane Fonda can go to Scranton and knock on doors, I believe we all can do it literally or metaphorically.
NoMoreRepugs
(10,638 posts)The future of your children and grandchildren hangs in the balance. If the Dotard wins in 2020 this country is DOOMED.
SleeplessinSoCal
(9,733 posts)He always complains about regulations killing his business. That is why he voted for Trump. But he also trashes AOC on Facebook. Manages to read the right wing propaganda. I think he is killing himself with stress smoking. He is a wonderful guy. So considerate. A loving husband, strict father. Poopoos climate change. All together I just step away from a real discussion. Working America may never reach him. But I am going to check out their methodology. Where can I do that?