General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsURGENT: Please help me confirm this apparent crazy shit Trump did
Let me explain exactly how I found this so there's no confusion: the first version of this photo I saw depicted AG William Barr on the left. I right-clicked and searched Google for the image to find a higher res version. That's when I found the EXACT SAME photo, credited to the DoD in May of 2018, featuring John Bolton exactly where Barr was. It took just a moment to realize that the other three in the photo are identical down to the facial expression and clothes.
"Holy crap, they Photoshopped Bolton out," I said.
So here's what I need from GD: please help me research when the second photo with Barr first appeared in circulation, and ideally a hosted copy of the photo in an identifiable location. I want to be as sure as I can be that the Trump administration actually edited John Bolton out of a photo Josef Stalin style before I start calling reporters.
Thanks for your help! Please comment right here with anything you find.
UPDATE: Per request, here are the two still pics.
With Bolton, DoD photo May 2018
With Barr, unknown edit date
ramblin_dave
(1,546 posts)Post updated. Thanks!
dewsgirl
(14,961 posts)the photo with Igor and Lev.
Brother Buzz
(36,440 posts)citizen blues
(570 posts)They then squeezed Barr into Bolton's space without bothering to keep the pic proportional.
Brother Buzz
(36,440 posts)This is the one that circulated widely
Then this one popped up
global1
(25,251 posts)renate
(13,776 posts)Ms. Toad
(34,074 posts)The earliest I can find it is 10/4, and all instances are twitter/Imjur - some appear to be posted by progressives.
https://imgur.com/gallery/flR22uB
So I don't think it was Trump.
angka
(1,599 posts)The author of that Tweet is a former Weekly Standard employee (conservative), and that's as far as I got trying to track it down as well. There's no metadata in the image to indicate the origin but I think Twitter strips metadata.
Anyway, thanks for your help. I'm still trying to run it down.
blogslut
(38,001 posts)angka
(1,599 posts)blogslut
(38,001 posts)Last edited Tue Oct 22, 2019, 10:01 PM - Edit history (1)
The Bulwark is Bill Kristol and Charlie Sykes' website and they're both never-trumpers. I mean, it's a decent photoshop but not great. Something someone with a job in media could probably whip up on their own. The tweet went fairly viral so there's that.
Ah, looks like it was a joke and Swift fell for it
Link to tweet
Rstrstx
(1,399 posts)Maybe to give them a less harsh look under the lights or to better match the lighting from wherever Barr's picture came (bonus points if you can find the picture Barr was lifted from). Also, what's up with that vertical streak between Trump and Pompeo in the altered pic? It spoils what is kind of a decent Photoshop job. Barr looks like he just ate John Bolton and scooted right in, couldn't be more pleased with himself.
This sort of reminds me of the Meredith McIver fiasco wayyyyy back during the convention.
jberryhill
(62,444 posts)ramblin_dave
(1,546 posts)Both links you provided reference progressnowcolorado.org with pics called barrshop.png and the other boltonshop.png - so I wonder if shop refers to photoshop in some way. Also, why are both of these on the same site?
Ones with Barr...(note https removed)
://s3.amazonaws.com/s3.progressnowcolorado.org/images/barrshop.png (your link)
://www.dailykos.com/stories/2019/10/5/1890440/-Barr-Pompeo-and-Giuliani-They-ve-gone-where-subpoenas-can-lacerate-their-hearts-no-more
://god.dailydot.com/tag/mike-pompeo/
://twitter.com/DearAuntCrabby/status/1180479085417553927
://twitter.com/wgblackmonall/status/1180912080641232897
Ones with Bolton...
://s3.amazonaws.com/s3.progressnowcolorado.org/images/boltonshop.png (your link)
://www.fitsnews.com/2019/09/10/donald-trump-fires-warmonger-john-bolton/
://tcf.org/content/report/making-unmaking-syria-strategy-trump/
://mondoweiss.net/2019/01/secretary-following-elections/
The Bolton ones are oldest. Who put in Barr and why? Not necessarily the White House.
angka
(1,599 posts)StrictlyRockers
(3,855 posts)JoeOtterbein
(7,702 posts)StrictlyRockers
(3,855 posts)angka
(1,599 posts)You could be right of course, that's why I've been trying to figure it out conclusively. I personally have never represented this photo as for sure coming from the WH.
citizen blues
(570 posts)Bolton is quite a bit shorter than Barr, and Bolton's a lot shorter than Trump. The picture with Bolton is accurately proportioned. The picture with Barr is not.
While Barr carries some extra weight, he's not nearly as portly as he appears in this picture. Additionally, compare where his head is aligned with objects in the background, it matches very closely to where Bolton's head is. This is not an accurate depiction of Barr. When you look at other pictures of Barr walking with or standing next to Trump at a podium, it is clear that Barr is close to being as tall as Trump. In this picture, he is not.
Given how out of proportion Barr is in this picture with being shorter and wider, this is actually a pretty sloppy cut & paste.