Baker soon called me back. He had looked into it. The boys were being charged with something called obstructing government administration, which basically amounts to resisting arrest.
The police hadnt done anything wrong, Baker said. I dont know what your wife saw, he explained, but a police car did not hit a kid.
So I went back to my wife and asked her, Are you sure? She was sure. It happened right in front of her. Still, memories are fallible. So I went into nearby storefronts and asked if anyone had seen anything the night of Halloween.
Yeah, I saw a cop car hit a kid, a waiter told me. He said he had a clear view of it: A handful of kids were running. One of them jumped out into the street and got hit by the police car, probably going faster than he should have been. He saw the boy roll over the hood and fall to the ground: It sounded like when people hit concrete. It made a horrible sound.
I spoke to four witnesses, including my wife. All of them said they saw the same thing. When I called Baker back, he told me that my wife and the three others were mistaken. The car hadnt hit the kid. The kid had hit the car.