Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Demovictory9

(32,456 posts)
Mon Jan 3, 2022, 05:19 PM Jan 2022

What's the Best Book of the Past 125 Years? We Asked Readers to Decide. (NYT)

In October, as we marked the Book Review’s 125th anniversary, we invited readers to nominate the best book published during that time. This was a nod to our history: In its first few decades, the Book Review often asked readers to anoint the best books, the best short stories, the best poems. We wanted this project, like those early ones, to reflect readers’ tastes and preferences.

Responses began pouring in from all 50 states and 67 countries. In November, we presented a list of the 25 most-nominated books (one per author) for a vote. After tallying more than 200,000 ballots, the winner, by a narrow margin, is …



THE WINNER
To Kill a Mockingbird
By Harper Lee



https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2021/12/28/books/best-book-winners.html

THE RUNNERS-UP
2. The Fellowship of the Ring
3. 1984
4. One Hundred Years of Solitude
5. Beloved

The story of the nominations we received is not consensus, but diversity — not just in the sheer number of books that readers nominated, but in the ways that they interpreted what “best book” meant. Of the more than 1,300 books nominated, 65 percent were nominated by only one person. And only 31 percent nominated a book that made it to our list of 25 finalists. Here are some titles that speak to the breadth of readers’ choices.

33 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
What's the Best Book of the Past 125 Years? We Asked Readers to Decide. (NYT) (Original Post) Demovictory9 Jan 2022 OP
"Asking a fiction writer to recommend his favorite book..." sir pball Jan 2022 #1
Interesting that they'd head-nod... IHaveNoName Jan 2022 #26
That would get my vote for number one Poiuyt Jan 2022 #30
One Hundred Years of Solitude Botany Jan 2022 #2
I don't think I would have a clear favorite, but I would have panader0 Jan 2022 #3
tolkien is amazing but long. Demovictory9 Jan 2022 #5
Only if you consider 200 pages to describe a sword long. Nevilledog Jan 2022 #13
LOL Demovictory9 Jan 2022 #14
I love Raymond Chandler. Johonny Jan 2022 #6
How to Shit in the Woods got snubbed. Kaleva Jan 2022 #4
My pick turned out to be the winner. And as amazing as the novel was ... 11 Bravo Jan 2022 #7
The movie is quite good Buckeyeblue Jan 2022 #12
This message was self-deleted by its author 11 Bravo Jan 2022 #8
Where was The Grapes of Wrath? El Supremo Jan 2022 #9
East of Eden is another class by Steinbeck that should have made the list Docreed2003 Jan 2022 #10
+1 Roisin Ni Fiachra Jan 2022 #24
vivid imagery... WarGamer Jan 2022 #33
Hard to argue with #s 4 and 5 tishaLA Jan 2022 #11
The Old Man and the Sea lpbk2713 Jan 2022 #15
one of my faves, too... WarGamer Jan 2022 #32
Can't argue with any of those picks, for lasting cultural impact as well as quality Withywindle Jan 2022 #16
Define "best" WarGamer Jan 2022 #17
Same problem with goodreas determining best book of the year..most widely read wons Demovictory9 Jan 2022 #18
To Kill a Mockingbird is set in a real situation, with the choices real people have to make muriel_volestrangler Jan 2022 #21
I fully support TKAM being read in schools as it's good morally/ethically. WarGamer Jan 2022 #31
My choices for the past 125 years: First Speaker Jan 2022 #19
Mine: betsuni Jan 2022 #20
I've got a slight problem ... Straw Man Jan 2022 #22
My Pet Goat didn't make the list, what the hell! Emile Jan 2022 #23
lol Celerity Jan 2022 #25
Meaningless question to ask... brooklynite Jan 2022 #27
Howard Zinn's A People's History of the United States pecosbob Jan 2022 #28
Lonesome Dove... lame54 Jan 2022 #29

sir pball

(4,742 posts)
1. "Asking a fiction writer to recommend his favorite book..."
Mon Jan 3, 2022, 05:25 PM
Jan 2022
…is a little like asking a father to pick his favorite child, like asking an adulterer to name his favorite lover. The writer will hem and haw, the father will equivocate, the adulterer will say he loves them all the same, just in different ways. Of course, we're lying. We all have a favorite: She stood "four foot ten in one sock." "She was Lola in slacks. She was Lo, plain Lo in the morning." But in our arms she will always be Lolita.
https://www.npr.org/2006/07/07/5536855/why-lolita-remains-shocking-and-a-favorite

IHaveNoName

(94 posts)
26. Interesting that they'd head-nod...
Tue Jan 4, 2022, 09:04 AM
Jan 2022

William Styron's "Sophie's Choice" in their article (although Sophie was the mother, not the father). It would be on my short-list.

Poiuyt

(18,123 posts)
30. That would get my vote for number one
Tue Jan 4, 2022, 01:20 PM
Jan 2022

You're mesmerized by the beautiful writing, but them you stop and say to yourself, "Did he just say what I think he said?"

panader0

(25,816 posts)
3. I don't think I would have a clear favorite, but I would have
Mon Jan 3, 2022, 05:43 PM
Jan 2022

One Hundred Years of Solitude ahead of the other four shown. (I never read Tolkien)
Currently reading Raymond Chandler and digging it.

Kaleva

(36,299 posts)
4. How to Shit in the Woods got snubbed.
Mon Jan 3, 2022, 05:44 PM
Jan 2022

"Hailed in its first edition as “the most important environmental book of the decade” by Books of the Southwest,"

https://www.amazon.com/How-Shit-Woods-3rd-Environmentally/dp/1580083633

11 Bravo

(23,926 posts)
7. My pick turned out to be the winner. And as amazing as the novel was ...
Mon Jan 3, 2022, 06:27 PM
Jan 2022

the movie damned near eclipsed it.

Buckeyeblue

(5,499 posts)
12. The movie is quite good
Mon Jan 3, 2022, 08:18 PM
Jan 2022

The older I get the less I like the novel, which seems to say, if we all love Boo Radley everything will work out just fine. But it didn't work out just fine for Tom.

Response to Demovictory9 (Original post)

WarGamer

(12,444 posts)
32. one of my faves, too...
Tue Jan 4, 2022, 02:16 PM
Jan 2022

I was kinda' afraid to say it because he isn't "proper" in the 21st Century for many...

Withywindle

(9,988 posts)
16. Can't argue with any of those picks, for lasting cultural impact as well as quality
Mon Jan 3, 2022, 09:44 PM
Jan 2022

I can give a nerdy quibble though: The Lord of the Rings is not a true trilogy, never has been, never was meant to be. It was divided into three volumes because of post-war paper rationing in the UK in the 1950s (and concern that something so long was a huge risk if it didn't sell).

Publishers and filmmakers have kept the tradition of treating it like one, but it's one continuous story, so it makes no sense to pick just the first third of it.


Anyway Jan 3rd is good ol' JRRT's birthday so raise your glass to The Professor!

WarGamer

(12,444 posts)
17. Define "best"
Mon Jan 3, 2022, 09:56 PM
Jan 2022

But one thing I will say...

TKAM only finished in 1st because it's read by a large segment of the population in High School.

Great book... but not top 5 or 10 material.

Back to defining GREAT.

GREAT as in an author who paints the most vivid picture on a page?? Where you can smell the dust as in Steinbeck or see the words written by Hemingway?

Or GREAT meaning a story told by someone of such impact and life experience like Nelson Mandela and "Long walk to freedom"?

Or GREAT meaning a book written that impacted the MOST people, like Marx's "Communist Manifesto"??

Anne Frank?

Wealth of Nations?

The Republic?

Darwin, "On the Origins..."?

"The Tattooist of Auschwitz"??

"Night" by Wiesel??





So, TKAM the greatest book ever?

Hardly.

Maybe the "widest read"??








Demovictory9

(32,456 posts)
18. Same problem with goodreas determining best book of the year..most widely read wons
Tue Jan 4, 2022, 01:34 AM
Jan 2022

Accurate method wpuld be voting by only those who read every book

muriel_volestrangler

(101,316 posts)
21. To Kill a Mockingbird is set in a real situation, with the choices real people have to make
Tue Jan 4, 2022, 05:37 AM
Jan 2022

While the Holocaust books you mention are obviously real, they're a record of what happened in a situation you hope will never occur again. TKAM is about racism and community in a setting that has continuing relevance to an American readership.

WarGamer

(12,444 posts)
31. I fully support TKAM being read in schools as it's good morally/ethically.
Tue Jan 4, 2022, 02:13 PM
Jan 2022

But it is far from top 10 material

First Speaker

(4,858 posts)
19. My choices for the past 125 years:
Tue Jan 4, 2022, 02:21 AM
Jan 2022


Fiction:

1. The Great Gatsby
2. The Lord of the Rings.
3. The Complete Sherlock Holmes. (Technically, this goes back to 1887.)
4. Invisible Man. (Ellison, not Wells.)
5. Foundation Trilogy.

Non-Fiction:

1. Winston Churchill, The Second World War
2. Charles Galton Darwin, The Next Million Years
3. Prefaces, H. L. Mencken
4. Explaining Hitler, Ron Rosenbaum
5. Lawrence Ritter, The Glory of Their Times

betsuni

(25,519 posts)
20. Mine:
Tue Jan 4, 2022, 03:54 AM
Jan 2022

"Tropic of Cancer" Henry Miller
"The Diaries of Anais Nin 1931-1934"
"Gentlemen Prefer Blondes" Anita Loos
"The Great Gatsby" F. Scott Fitzgerald
"Nausea" Jean-Paul Sartre
"Leaving Home" Garrison Keillor
"Dandelion Wine" Ray Bradbury
"A Moveable Feast" Ernest Hemingway
"The Philosophy of Andy Warhol"
Collected works of M.F.K. Fisher
"The Autobiography of Alice B. Toklas" Gertrude Stein


Straw Man

(6,624 posts)
22. I've got a slight problem ...
Tue Jan 4, 2022, 06:05 AM
Jan 2022

Last edited Tue Jan 4, 2022, 09:23 PM - Edit history (1)

... with The Fellowship of the Ring, because that's one third of a book. Tolkien wrote the Lord of the Rings "trilogy" as one book, and it was split up by his publishers.

brooklynite

(94,561 posts)
27. Meaningless question to ask...
Tue Jan 4, 2022, 09:31 AM
Jan 2022

Other than Shakespeare or Sherlock Holmes, most people haven’t read many booked more than 100 years old.

Latest Discussions»General Discussion»What's the Best Book of t...