General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsEver tried to explain the Electoral College to a non American?
I have.
They think its crazy.
They dont understand how a candidate could get more (and sometimes many million more) popular votes but still not be elected President.
Our nation is so backwards in so many ways and the current GOP wants to take us back even further.
Sigh 😔
BlueIdaho
(13,582 posts)Try explaining it this way: The framers of the constitution were deeply afraid the voters would vote for the wrong candidates and the ruling class would lose their power - so they added the EC to the process to make sure the rich and powerful would always have the final say in the process.
That works for me.
Funtatlaguy
(10,935 posts)Skittles
(153,613 posts)but now it has give us two incompetent presidents in recent history
we all have access to the same information now, the EC is antiquated
Xipe Totec
(43,915 posts)Skittles
(153,613 posts)but now it is actively harming America
Zeitghost
(3,930 posts)When you explain that the country was originally seen as being a lot more akin to something like the EU, a collection of independent States (which are different than Provinces or administrative regions) joined together for a unified economic and defense effort. It's not a perfect example, but it gives a general idea.
The Presidency and the Senate were intended to be chosen directly by and represented the interests of the various States. The House was intended to represent the people.
Funtatlaguy
(10,935 posts)Delarage
(2,190 posts)Was just talking to a native Australian today at White Clay Creek and the electoral college came up. She said that she had been talking about getting rid of it with someone, and that person said "But then Republicans would never get elected!"
Stop being crazy, then, is what she said she was thinking.
MichMan
(12,037 posts)Funtatlaguy
(10,935 posts)TheBeam19
(344 posts)MichMan
(12,037 posts)What if the Republicans win congress in the mid terms?
They could vote to replace President Biden with a Republican.
TheBeam19
(344 posts)the 2006 mid-terms.
And just as we would have ousted Trump after only two years into his term.
You could go back through history and what if countless scenarios. Do I think its a better system than the one with an un-democratic Senate (by design) and that also has a filibuster? I do.
DavidDvorkin
(19,541 posts)He was shocked and said, "So what's the point of voting, then?"
Yep.
TheBeam19
(344 posts)kacekwl
(7,047 posts)it makes sense.