General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsAuthor of recent paper about SSRI mechanism is an Anti Vaxxer. She is perturbed that right wingers
instead of left wingers have taken her paper and ran with it.
Who Is the Psychiatrist Behind the Antidepressant Study Taking Over Right-Wing Media?
Joanna Moncrieff has spent two decades questioning the efficacy of SSRIs and more recently, shes gone after Covid-19 vaccine mandates
SNIP -------
Moncrieff cites pediatric vaccine mandates in the United States as an example of the paternalism of public health interventions, and frames mental health care interventions as well as mental illness as a diagnostic category as an effort on behalf of the state to exert mind control tactics over individuals who refuse to conform to societal standards, referring to psychiatry as the arena in which the conflict between freedom and health comes most sharply into focus.
More recently, she has used her platform to publicly question mandatory Covid vaccines for health care workers in the U.K.. Last year, she was one of the signatories of an open letter from health care professionals opposed to the mandates, which, while acknowledging that they can be helpful for some people, maintained there is considerable uncertainty about the effectiveness of the Covid vaccines. In the past, she has also compared Covid vaccine mandates to forced psychiatric care. Forced treatment in psychiatry is rightly controversial and limited, but now we are forcing thousands to have Covid jab, she tweeted last December.
On at least one occasion, she inaccurately connected severe Covid-19 symptoms to antidepressant or antipsychotic use (in fact, data from an observational study suggests that taking SSRIs may actually reduce a persons risk of dying from Covid). When asked for further evidence to support this view, Moncrieff demurred, saying, I have not been following this story recently, so cant give you any more recent information on this.
While Aftab may believe it is not an accident that the paper was embraced by the right, Moncrieff is somewhat perturbed by the segment of the U.S. media currently championing her research. I am perplexed at why this story has been taken up by the right-wing media more than the left, she says. She believes that treating mental illness with medication constitutes inappropriately medicalising distress and thereby obscuring the effects of social injustice, poverty, inequality, racism, child abuse etc, [which] should be a major concern for the left.
https://www.rollingstone.com/culture/culture-news/ssri-right-wing-attack-joanna-moncrieff-1388067/
G2theD
(593 posts)I dont doubt she has a degree, but her judgement and rationale regarding vaccines seems ignorant and conspiratorial.
probably the same way a doctor who graduates last from the worst medical school does.
And, she could be that very doctor.
G2theD
(593 posts)But I also dont doubt that she knows she is spreading manure. She violates basic scientific principle. She has to know better, unless she is dumb as a rock and got her degree at Trump University.
qazplm135
(7,447 posts)are able to do one thing well enough and still suck at logic.
Look at Ben Carson...literal brain surgeon and lobotomy example simultaneously.
He always sounds like hes on ludes.
ismnotwasm
(42,014 posts)Her and her conspiracy everywhere ass. Of course the RW listens to that shit.