Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Nevilledog

(51,198 posts)
Mon Feb 13, 2023, 07:02 PM Feb 2023

Margaret Atwood: Go Ahead and Ban My Book

https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2023/02/margaret-atwood-handmaids-tale-virginia-book-ban-library-removal/673013/

No paywall
https://archive.is/7FOGY

It’s shunning time in Madison County, Virginia, where the school board recently banished my novel The Handmaid’s Tale from the shelves of the high-school library. I have been rendered “unacceptable.” Governor Glenn Youngkin enabled such censorship last year when he signed legislation allowing parents to veto teaching materials they perceive as sexually explicit.

This episode is perplexing to me, in part because my book is much less sexually explicit than the Bible, and I doubt the school board has ordered the expulsion of that. Possibly, the real motive lies elsewhere. The conservative Christian group Focus on the Family generated the list of “unacceptable” books that reportedly inspired the school board’s action, and at least one member of the public felt the school board was trying to “limit what kids can read” based on religious views. Could it be that the board acted under the mistaken belief that The Handmaid’s Tale is anti-Christian?

The truth is that the inspiration for The Handmaid’s Tale is in part biblical: “Beware of false prophets, who come to you in sheep’s clothing but inwardly are ravenous wolves” (Matthew 7:15). The novel sets an inward faith and core Christian values—which I take to be embodied in the love of neighbor and the forgiveness of sins—against totalitarian control and power-hoarding cloaked in a supposed religiousness that is mostly based on the earlier scriptures in the Bible. The stealing of women for reproductive purposes and the appropriation of their babies appears in Genesis 30, when Rachel and Leah turn their “handmaids” over to Jacob and then claim the children as their own. My novel is also an exploration of the theoretical question “What kind of a totalitarianism might the United States become?” I suggest we’re beginning to see the real-life answer to that query.

Wittingly or otherwise, the Madison County school board has now become part of the centuries-old wrangling over who shall have control of religious texts and authority over what they mean. In its early-modern form, this power struggle goes back to the mid-15th-century appearance of the Gutenberg printing press, which allowed a wider dissemination of printed materials, including Bibles.

*snip*
41 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Margaret Atwood: Go Ahead and Ban My Book (Original Post) Nevilledog Feb 2023 OP
Kicking for Visability SheltieLover Feb 2023 #1
The bible should be banned. It's nothing but a book of propaganda and hatred! And RKP5637 Feb 2023 #2
I thought Democrats/Liberals/Progressives were against book banning. Yes? Hekate Feb 2023 #30
Sometimes you have to fight fire with fire! n/t RKP5637 Feb 2023 #39
No, censorship is surprisingly (and depressingly) popular among the left. Dr. Strange Feb 2023 #41
Well said, Ms. Atwood. Well said. nt crickets Feb 2023 #3
They banned it because it... S/V Loner Feb 2023 #4
Damn straight it does. N/t MontanaMama Feb 2023 #7
+1 Irish_Dem Feb 2023 #13
Banning her book only proves her correct. panader0 Feb 2023 #20
Madison County VA? I figured the NC border or the Shenandoah Valley. Close. paleotn Feb 2023 #5
I believe the teens in Virginia will be flocking to read her books now FakeNoose Feb 2023 #6
That always happens tavernier Feb 2023 #9
I can imagine them taking the book out from the library, or, wnylib Feb 2023 #19
We did that in high school with Terry Southern's 'Candy'. panader0 Feb 2023 #22
I was thinking the same thing while typing wnylib Feb 2023 #23
They've probably already watched it on Hulu. llmart Feb 2023 #24
They sure are. wnylib Feb 2023 #28
Exactly!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! n/t RKP5637 Feb 2023 #40
Wow Ollie Garkie Feb 2023 #8
It's like they don't get it that these days tavernier Feb 2023 #10
Unless we become like China, were everything is monitored. Irish_Dem Feb 2023 #14
You can get around it in China. Elessar Zappa Feb 2023 #25
We shall see how that works out in the long run. Irish_Dem Feb 2023 #31
Indeedy. Duppers Feb 2023 #15
Some conservatives might use it as an instructional manual IronLionZion Feb 2023 #11
KNR niyad Feb 2023 #12
We must put together a group to ban Bibles. EOM tiredtoo Feb 2023 #16
I am impressed at her level of analysis and thought SouthernDem4ever Feb 2023 #17
LOL! radical noodle Feb 2023 #32
The crazies probably flipped out because the book contains the "F" word. ShazzieB Feb 2023 #18
K&R Solly Mack Feb 2023 #21
Recommend! SalviaBlue Feb 2023 #26
She's awesome, Handmaid's Tale is a modern classic. Thanks for posting. Timeflyer Feb 2023 #27
Kick and Rec with pleasure Hekate Feb 2023 #29
What Margaret Atwood takes to be Christianity... malthaussen Feb 2023 #33
She should thank them. Banning a book is typically good for sales... Wounded Bear Feb 2023 #34
When the show first premiered in 2018 there was a flashback scene that has lead character played by Pepsidog Feb 2023 #35
Way too deep for them to understand. LiberalLovinLug Feb 2023 #36
But, yea pussy-grabbing! Huh, Gov? czarjak Feb 2023 #37
My parents lived in Madison County after they retired. It is a very, very conservative place. I can Martin68 Feb 2023 #38

RKP5637

(67,112 posts)
2. The bible should be banned. It's nothing but a book of propaganda and hatred! And
Mon Feb 13, 2023, 07:13 PM
Feb 2023

weird drug laced stories, The Book of Revelation.

paleotn

(17,962 posts)
5. Madison County VA? I figured the NC border or the Shenandoah Valley. Close.
Mon Feb 13, 2023, 07:28 PM
Feb 2023

West of Culpepper. Just outside the DC orbit. Trumplandia. I guess they just don't like Atwood sharing their plans.

FakeNoose

(32,766 posts)
6. I believe the teens in Virginia will be flocking to read her books now
Mon Feb 13, 2023, 07:40 PM
Feb 2023

Especially "The Handmaid's Tale." Margaret Atwood is a treasure.

wnylib

(21,611 posts)
19. I can imagine them taking the book out from the library, or,
Mon Feb 13, 2023, 08:50 PM
Feb 2023

if it isn't available there, they will order it online and pass it around among their friends.

It will become the most popular book in the school.



wnylib

(21,611 posts)
23. I was thinking the same thing while typing
Mon Feb 13, 2023, 09:04 PM
Feb 2023

my last post. I read a copy of Candy that my cousin had. Don't know where or how she got it.

llmart

(15,552 posts)
24. They've probably already watched it on Hulu.
Mon Feb 13, 2023, 09:57 PM
Feb 2023

These people who want to ban stuff like this from high school students are so out of touch with reality of these times.

tavernier

(12,401 posts)
10. It's like they don't get it that these days
Mon Feb 13, 2023, 07:57 PM
Feb 2023

you can get anything on the Internet.
Go ahead and tell a kid he’s not allowed to read something.

Elessar Zappa

(14,063 posts)
25. You can get around it in China.
Mon Feb 13, 2023, 10:00 PM
Feb 2023

One of our DUers posts from there and he uses a VPN to access websites that the CCP blocks.

Irish_Dem

(47,406 posts)
31. We shall see how that works out in the long run.
Tue Feb 14, 2023, 07:42 AM
Feb 2023

And he is not a Chinese national.

Even if you can "work around" something in China doesn't mean
you are not being monitored.

SouthernDem4ever

(6,617 posts)
17. I am impressed at her level of analysis and thought
Mon Feb 13, 2023, 08:34 PM
Feb 2023

And I really think she based Aunt Lydia on Sarah Sanders.

ShazzieB

(16,515 posts)
18. The crazies probably flipped out because the book contains the "F" word.
Mon Feb 13, 2023, 08:38 PM
Feb 2023

Among many other things of course, but I'll bet that's a big one. The narrator, Offred, uses it to describe what the Commander is doing to her during the monthly ritual of trying to impregnate her, and I honestly can't think of a better word for what is happening during that scene. None of the common euphemisms apply, really, because she's describing an utterly impersonal, completely animal act. I guess that's what the book banners consider "sexually explicit," lol.

They'd probably consider the book "sexually explicit" even without that, though. After all, it's pretty clear that sex is what the handmaids are there for, the reason they even exist. People like these VA book banners don't want their kids to read anything that even implies that sex can happen in any context other than between a husband and wife in a heterosexual marriage. Mustn't give the kiddies any "ideas," you know!

malthaussen

(17,216 posts)
33. What Margaret Atwood takes to be Christianity...
Tue Feb 14, 2023, 11:24 AM
Feb 2023

... is exactly anti- to the thing being practiced under the name of Christianity, as I am sure she understands.

-- Mal

Pepsidog

(6,254 posts)
35. When the show first premiered in 2018 there was a flashback scene that has lead character played by
Tue Feb 14, 2023, 11:59 AM
Feb 2023

Elizabeth Olson to a time when women first began losing their rights. For context, the plot features a dystopian future following the Second American Civil War wherein a theonomic, totalitarian society subjects fertile women, called "Handmaids," to child-bearing slavery. (from wiki). The flashback was Olson remembering a time before the war when Olson left for work. Before walking out of the house, she reminds her husband to sign her birth control prescription. Without the husband’s consent she had no right to birth control. I told my wife and two daughters about this and warned them don't be surprised if this doesn't happen in some states soon. All three looked at me like I was nuts. Crazy Dad being an alarmist, that could never happen here in NJ. The fact is that NJ is a Dem state, but after Dobbs and Bruen every horrific possibility is on the table which should scare the crap out of us all, not just women.

Martin68

(22,890 posts)
38. My parents lived in Madison County after they retired. It is a very, very conservative place. I can
Tue Feb 14, 2023, 03:37 PM
Feb 2023

guarantee the county probably has more Trumpists per acre than most places in the US.

Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Margaret Atwood: Go Ahead...