Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Coventina

(28,012 posts)
Wed Aug 14, 2024, 04:06 PM Aug 2024

My experience with the deeply rooted misogyny of men in general and medicine particularly

I am having a bit of a meltdown, after seeing JD Vance saying that helping care for grandchildren is the purpose of the post-menopausal female.

Just to relate a brief history of my PURPOSE (sarcasm) in life:
I had a son, who died very young of natural causes.

I then tried for a long time to have another child, but had a string of miscarriages.

I was eventually determined to have too many uterine fibroids to ever become pregnant, and they were getting so huge that they were a serious health problem. My uterus was removed, but not my ovaries, as I was still quite young at the time and it would have slammed me into menopause.

I have a number of chronic health problems, so I see a number of different doctors pretty regularly.

After I had my uterus removed, EVERY SINGLE DOCTOR I SAW AFTER THAT (excepting my gynecologist, who was a woman, and did the surgery) asked me, "Why do you still have your ovaries?"

All of them male.

It pissed me off so badly that I started asking them, "Why do you still have your balls?"

Men, even DOCTORS, have so much ignorance and thoughtlessness about what it is to be a woman.

JD Vance doesn't even seem to think there would be a reason for me to be alive, since I will never have grandchildren.
Never mind that I'm a college professor, mid-career.
Or that I have a number of interests and hobbies.
And that I spend the money I would have spent on children and grandchildren on charities.

FUCK THESE MEN!!

MY LIFE IS WORTH LIVING DESPITE NOT HAVING CHILDREN!!!!!

DOWN WITH THE PATRIARCHY! THE FUTURE IS FEMALE!!!!

104 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
My experience with the deeply rooted misogyny of men in general and medicine particularly (Original Post) Coventina Aug 2024 OP
Vance don't know shite 617Blue Aug 2024 #1
Exactly birdographer Aug 2024 #9
He's been elevated to theoretically one-heartbeat away from the most powerful position in the world Coventina Aug 2024 #12
Shady-pants is a little, little man. Little men have been putting down women since Kittycatkat Aug 2024 #67
They demean everyone who doesn't fit into their world view Tadpole Raisin Aug 2024 #2
I'm sorry all of that happened to you senseandsensibility Aug 2024 #3
yep, well said.... democratsruletheday Aug 2024 #4
True senseandsensibility Aug 2024 #5
WITH YOU. I'm fucking livid... OneGrassRoot Aug 2024 #6
What an unfeeling asshole. I'm glad you never went back to him. raccoon Aug 2024 #83
Ever notice how birdographer Aug 2024 #7
Yes yes and yes! N/t Lulu KC Aug 2024 #16
I'm with you. I'm so sick of the patriarchy and male selfishness and control on a societal scale. Sky Jewels Aug 2024 #8
Love to you dear person! Hope22 Aug 2024 #10
So sorry for your pain Maeve Aug 2024 #11
I am not going to defend the male doctors that treated you.... Dan Aug 2024 #13
To make your point re male ignorance: Had a male gyn tell me, with a straight face & total conviction: Attilatheblond Aug 2024 #62
How about no -archy, ... returnee Aug 2024 #14
No! Cailinrain Aug 2024 #79
Kick and rec. Torchlight Aug 2024 #15
Me, too SARose Aug 2024 #17
A lot of states have markodochartaigh Aug 2024 #18
Hopefully that doesn't happen, but thankfully I live abroad róisín_dubh Aug 2024 #82
Great post! KT2000 Aug 2024 #19
This makes me purple with anger. I wonder if people like Vance have the same disrespect for the women in LoisB Aug 2024 #20
Huge kick and recommend. love_katz Aug 2024 #21
one male doctor seeing that I had had 2 spontaneous abortions (miscarriages) chewed me out demigoddess Aug 2024 #22
I'm constantly surprised by the meat golems that pass for men these days. nt Xipe Totec Aug 2024 #24
Oh MAN, this reminded me of the last "visit" to the gynecologist I USED TO have. calimary Aug 2024 #54
calimary, did you ever find out what that contraption was? dmr Aug 2024 #74
I think it was some kind of cryosurgery. calimary Aug 2024 #76
We are nothing but breeding stock to them. StarryNite Aug 2024 #23
or as my mother liked to say, barbtries Aug 2024 #28
Texas has made it clear that we can just go bleed to death. Livestock are too valuable to allow that. Hekate Aug 2024 #30
That's a good point. They would save the cow but let a woman or girl die. StarryNite Aug 2024 #31
k&r Hermit-The-Prog Aug 2024 #25
I'm with you, Coventina! evolves Aug 2024 #26
they totally should have known barbtries Aug 2024 #27
What's really awful is running into a female doctor who was trained by men Warpy Aug 2024 #29
yes!!!!!!!!! bluboid Aug 2024 #32
the man is excelling in the role of sexist pig stopdiggin Aug 2024 #33
They are stuck with that smug hillbilly Entrepreneur want to be. gordianot Aug 2024 #34
Juvenile Delinquent (JD) BattleRow Aug 2024 #42
At some point, most women have had misogynistic experiences with modern medicine dlk Aug 2024 #35
Proud to be your 100th. rec. tavernier Aug 2024 #36
Thank you for posting this, Coventina. Permanut Aug 2024 #37
It's like he wants to enrage every woman of every age everywhere. Too bad women fought and won the vote, you sorry POS. Timeflyer Aug 2024 #38
As a man, let me just say: robbob Aug 2024 #39
Uh,just a thought,but BattleRow Aug 2024 #40
It's okay when they're sterile Zoomie1986 Aug 2024 #45
It's all momma's fault BattleRow Aug 2024 #47
My fortyish female OBGYN told me that at my age I don't need hormones. Never went back. nature-lover Aug 2024 #41
There are many Men Who shouldn't have kids IbogaProject Aug 2024 #43
UR Beautiful! Jean Genie Aug 2024 #44
Us post meno women get to be the Marthas onlyadream Aug 2024 #46
The future is women like you. That gives me more hope than you can imagine. Aristus Aug 2024 #48
You're living proof that women are good for LOTS of things. Not just child-related. calimary Aug 2024 #49
Your life is OBVIOUSLY valuable to you and others. Scrivener7 Aug 2024 #50
Vance's purpose geniph Aug 2024 #75
Ewwwwwwwwwww! Scrivener7 Aug 2024 #80
amen sister BlueWaveNeverEnd Aug 2024 #51
Hopefully new awareness is taking hold Sympthsical Aug 2024 #52
Apology Jazz Jon Aug 2024 #53
DOWN WITH THE PATRIARCHY IS RIGHT! ShazzieB Aug 2024 #55
I had bad uterine fibroids too mcar Aug 2024 #56
Preach sister!!!!!!! blondebanshee Aug 2024 #57
I just lost my shit very publicly after reading that. Pacifist Patriot Aug 2024 #58
Pretty sure Vance jerks off SomedayKindaLove Aug 2024 #59
Wonderful well written rant. I enjoyed the power flowing through it. . . . . nt Bernardo de La Paz Aug 2024 #60
I had endometriosis so bad iwillalwayswonderwhy Aug 2024 #61
Yes VGuerra276 Aug 2024 #63
Can't argue with you on this... GiqueCee Aug 2024 #64
It's ironic, to produce 10 singleton children in.a year requires 10 women and 1 man lostnfound Aug 2024 #65
That little fuckwad hillbilly Vance has no business telling women what they should or shouldn't be doing. llmart Aug 2024 #66
Remember this.. raising2moredems Aug 2024 #68
Women outlive men GopherGal Aug 2024 #69
For a man supposedly so well-educated... Trueblue Texan Aug 2024 #70
just because you go to Harvard or Yale lapfog_1 Aug 2024 #77
Melania Trump is post menopause Farmer-Rick Aug 2024 #71
Going to challenge that just a bit, but I get your point oregonjen Aug 2024 #72
This message was self-deleted by its author Farmer-Rick Aug 2024 #89
This is their last gasp. Blue Full Moon Aug 2024 #73
+1... myohmy2 Aug 2024 #78
Did you see this? AKwannabe Aug 2024 #81
I'd like to hear what he thinks about 50+ year old men mainer Aug 2024 #84
For most of human history, average life expectancy was well under 40 years. Not a lot of time for grandparenting. eppur_se_muova Aug 2024 #85
Done with the patriarchy! Clouds Passing Aug 2024 #86
Amen, sister. I wrote 6 books as a postmenapausal woman. So, as they say, "How do you like those apples?" Joinfortmill Aug 2024 #87
Shady is an INCEL, plain and simple... GoldenMezzoDiva Aug 2024 #88
Stories like yours are why Elessar Zappa Aug 2024 #90
Sorry my gender can be such blind idiots at times and Prairie_Seagull Aug 2024 #91
I was agreeing with you until 'The future is female' Amishman Aug 2024 #92
that is not true Cirsium Aug 2024 #95
Thank you for proving my point Amishman Aug 2024 #98
OK Cirsium Aug 2024 #100
What a superb post! Wild blueberry Aug 2024 #93
male is the 'norm', we are abnormal. but hey, we don't have to poop daily. pansypoo53219 Aug 2024 #94
How the hell does his wife live with him???? onlyadream Aug 2024 #96
The grandparents who raised Vance TexasBushwhacker Aug 2024 #97
I love you! This is a great post. Dark n Stormy Knight Aug 2024 #99
Great post and superb comments Diamond_Dog Aug 2024 #101
Men don't get to tell women or girls what their purpose in life is at any stage. Women/girls can decide for themselves. CousinIT Aug 2024 #102
I am so sorry for your experience. Behind the Aegis Aug 2024 #103
Sorry for your loss, and glad you are speaking out against this kind of shit. mucholderthandirt Aug 2024 #104

birdographer

(2,528 posts)
9. Exactly
Wed Aug 14, 2024, 04:26 PM
Aug 2024

Basing any part of your feeling of self-worth on something that twit said is going down the wrong path. He's a man, republican, trump supporter, and a total moron. How is his opinion worth anything?

Coventina

(28,012 posts)
12. He's been elevated to theoretically one-heartbeat away from the most powerful position in the world
Wed Aug 14, 2024, 04:29 PM
Aug 2024

That should frighten and anger everyone.

Kittycatkat

(1,734 posts)
67. Shady-pants is a little, little man. Little men have been putting down women since
Wed Aug 14, 2024, 09:20 PM
Aug 2024

the dawn of time. Shady was never big with the ladies. Being a misogynistic white privileged male is all he has. He knows he’s a loser. A weird, little, loser. Just like donOLD.

Tadpole Raisin

(1,561 posts)
2. They demean everyone who doesn't fit into their world view
Wed Aug 14, 2024, 04:12 PM
Aug 2024

and want to insure the laws allow them to control those (worthless) lives.

Fuck em all!

Strength and support to you Coventina!!

senseandsensibility

(20,394 posts)
3. I'm sorry all of that happened to you
Wed Aug 14, 2024, 04:14 PM
Aug 2024

but you are brave to tell your story. Some, even on this board, might have trouble understanding why Vance's comment is so cruel and disgusting. Your story helps us understand that it is part of an anti-female strategy designed to divide women among themselves, to cause others to dehumanize them, and to justify taking away their rights.

democratsruletheday

(1,229 posts)
4. yep, well said....
Wed Aug 14, 2024, 04:20 PM
Aug 2024

but the OP has to consider the source. Vance is such a tool. More idiotic stuff will continue to leak out because he has a long history of this crap.

senseandsensibility

(20,394 posts)
5. True
Wed Aug 14, 2024, 04:22 PM
Aug 2024

It's important not to let this freak live in your head. Not saying the OP is doing that, but it could happen to me if I'm not careful.

OneGrassRoot

(23,443 posts)
6. WITH YOU. I'm fucking livid...
Wed Aug 14, 2024, 04:23 PM
Aug 2024

I am so sorry for all you've been through. What a nightmare.

When my infant son died and I went to the GP two months later and broke down as I relayed what happened because the last time he had seen me, I was pregnant, he said "I can see you're still upset." No shit, Einstein.

Unfuckingbelievable. I walked out and never returned.

birdographer

(2,528 posts)
7. Ever notice how
Wed Aug 14, 2024, 04:24 PM
Aug 2024

when a doctor is puzzled about a diagnosis, or too lazy to bother because you are a woman, whatever is wrong with you will go away if you lose weight? Doesn't matter if you have a cough, a headache, a scratch on your arm that is not healing--it will be fine if you just lose weight, thanks for coming in, buh bye.

Sky Jewels

(8,824 posts)
8. I'm with you. I'm so sick of the patriarchy and male selfishness and control on a societal scale.
Wed Aug 14, 2024, 04:25 PM
Aug 2024

I know, I know: "not all men," "many exceptions," "lots of good guys," etc.

Maeve

(43,021 posts)
11. So sorry for your pain
Wed Aug 14, 2024, 04:29 PM
Aug 2024

I have 4 kids, but probably will not have grandkids with my DNA (I do have an adopted grandkid and expect another). So I guess JD would devalue my existence, too.
Ignore him. He's not worth having in your head, not worth a single synapse.

Dan

(4,147 posts)
13. I am not going to defend the male doctors that treated you....
Wed Aug 14, 2024, 04:40 PM
Aug 2024

But I am honestly going to tell you that from my viewpoint, men, myself included myself don’t know a thing about the female reproductive system.

When I was in high school, they separated the males / females when they discussed sex education, reproductive issues, etc., of course that was almost fifty-five years ago.

Maybe now, male students are better informed - I know that I wasn’t. When issues come up pertaining to pregnancy, female health care, ectopic pregnancies, etc., I have to ask my significant other or look it up via the internet. I know enough to know that female health issues are best addressed between the female and her physician.

Sorry for your experiences.

Attilatheblond

(4,516 posts)
62. To make your point re male ignorance: Had a male gyn tell me, with a straight face & total conviction:
Wed Aug 14, 2024, 07:21 PM
Aug 2024

"I don't believe in PMS."

That's right, a male gyn told me HE doesn't believe in a condition most females know personally does exist, and therefore my 'issues' are all in my head. No, I did not choose this troglodyte, it was a hospital situation and I had no voice in who showed up. But in less than 3 minutes, I knew why he didn't have a private practice.

Wanted to kick him in the balls and let him know that 'It's all in your head. Balls don't have feelings!'

Best GYN I ever had was a FEMALE, board certified GYN & board certified endocrinologist. Let me tell ya all, THAT is the sort of physician a Peri-menopausal or menopausal woman really needs.

Cailinrain

(17 posts)
79. No!
Thu Aug 15, 2024, 12:50 AM
Aug 2024

How about just a *little* bit of matriarchy to right some wrongs from the past centuries of living under men’s rule?! We damn well deserve it.

Torchlight

(4,251 posts)
15. Kick and rec.
Wed Aug 14, 2024, 04:49 PM
Aug 2024

I have nothing of merit to add, but hopefully my little kick will get one more person to see your post.

SARose

(857 posts)
17. Me, too
Wed Aug 14, 2024, 04:52 PM
Aug 2024

My uterus was removed when I was 42. Endometriosis and fibroids prevented me from having children.

My female OBGYN told me she wanted me to go through menopause naturally so she left my ovaries. She told me every male doctor from now on will tell you that was a mistake.

She was right.

markodochartaigh

(2,221 posts)
18. A lot of states have
Wed Aug 14, 2024, 04:56 PM
Aug 2024

filial responsibility laws. They are rarely enforced now. But when Medicare and Social Security are defunded, and Ma and Pa have spent the money they got for selling their homes, I'm willing to bet that states will start allowing those laws to be enforced so that children are held responsible for the care of their parents.

róisín_dubh

(11,924 posts)
82. Hopefully that doesn't happen, but thankfully I live abroad
Thu Aug 15, 2024, 02:23 AM
Aug 2024

I have complex relationships with both my parents (my mother and her partner are alcoholics that are beyond help or reason). My dad and his wife have my younger half-siblings. I will likely get nothing from my parents and they can sort out their own affairs.
I'm an eldest daughter and 47 years (and counting) of their drama and trauma is quite enough, thanks.

KT2000

(20,934 posts)
19. Great post!
Wed Aug 14, 2024, 05:00 PM
Aug 2024

I too am sick of the misogyny. Now it is out in the open and men like Vance are proud of it. They had power and look what they did with it! Women dying and permanently maimed in order to comply with their sadistic, control of women laws. We do not have justify our life choices for anyone, least of all the likes of that phony Vance.

Here ya go:


LoisB

(8,942 posts)
20. This makes me purple with anger. I wonder if people like Vance have the same disrespect for the women in
Wed Aug 14, 2024, 05:03 PM
Aug 2024

their lives. As for the doctors wondering why you still have your ovaries - your response is perfect. I am so sorry for the loss of your son.

love_katz

(2,866 posts)
21. Huge kick and recommend.
Wed Aug 14, 2024, 05:09 PM
Aug 2024

We are not just incubators for a man's sperm!

The pukes efforts to reduce us to mere vessels and servants is the same exact kind of tactics that are used to try and justify the oppression of any marginalized group.

We Are Not Going Back!

to you for what you have been through.

Our individual stories may be different, but as the #metoo movement shows, our overall experiences have too many similarities to be written off as coincidence.

demigoddess

(6,675 posts)
22. one male doctor seeing that I had had 2 spontaneous abortions (miscarriages) chewed me out
Wed Aug 14, 2024, 05:10 PM
Aug 2024

for paying for those abortions. Apparently he did not know the medical term for miscarriage.

calimary

(84,575 posts)
54. Oh MAN, this reminded me of the last "visit" to the gynecologist I USED TO have.
Wed Aug 14, 2024, 06:43 PM
Aug 2024

I was much younger and my mom took all the doctors’ referrals from her friend whose husband was an MD.

I went to my appointment and this male gyno started to examine me and then left the examining room for a moment. The door opened again and in he comes, followed by his nurse who was wheeling some big ungodly metal tank with tubes coming out of it. No explanation, no conversation, no nothing to describe why that was there and/or what he thought I needed it for. And I took one look at it and literally passed out.

Evidently, that’s when everything came to a dead stop and when I came to, they advised me to get dressed again and then come to his office. He was shocked. I remember noticing how honestly incredulous and flabbergasted he was. And he told me, completely taken aback, that: “I didn’t know I had to EXPLAIN what I was going to do…” He was bewildered.

I tell you, THAT was THE END of him, for me! WTF do you mean you didn’t know you had to EXPLAIN things to me!!!!! How the hell would you expect me to react when you wheel this big contraption, with tubes and wires coming out of it, but don’t bother to tell me what it is, in the first place, and why you need to use it on me????? And how many patients do you have where you wheel in this mystery machine to use on them? Do they just lie there and take it? (And is that what you think women are supposed to do, ANYWAY???)

From that moment on, I switched to women doctors!

dmr

(28,663 posts)
74. calimary, did you ever find out what that contraption was?
Wed Aug 14, 2024, 11:27 PM
Aug 2024

I would've freaked out, too! For the life of me, I can't imagine what it was for. I'm 72, so I've been around a while, and I have never heard of this thing!

I think it was 40 years, or more ago, I've only chosen female doctors. Only on rare occasions I've had to settle with a male.

They may be highly educated physicians, but many either don't know how to talk to women, or they lack understanding of the female anatomy.

I'm certain there are plenty of well qualified male physicians, but I'd rather play it safe with a fellow woman.

calimary

(84,575 posts)
76. I think it was some kind of cryosurgery.
Wed Aug 14, 2024, 11:44 PM
Aug 2024

Where they freeze the tissues they’re going to work on or remove, if it looks suspicious. Pre-cancerous in my case. It’s been a long time, though.

And SHEESH! I can STILL get pissed off, thinking about it.

I haven’t regretted finding a new doctor. Not for a single second. And I’ve resolved: it will ALWAYS be a female doctor if I have ANY choice in the matter. Dentists - not as much of an issue, as long as they’re user-friendly.

StarryNite

(10,899 posts)
23. We are nothing but breeding stock to them.
Wed Aug 14, 2024, 05:15 PM
Aug 2024

If we aren't birthing or rearing kids we have no value to them.

Hekate

(95,208 posts)
30. Texas has made it clear that we can just go bleed to death. Livestock are too valuable to allow that.
Wed Aug 14, 2024, 05:34 PM
Aug 2024

StarryNite

(10,899 posts)
31. That's a good point. They would save the cow but let a woman or girl die.
Wed Aug 14, 2024, 05:35 PM
Aug 2024

It their eyes we are replaceable.

evolves

(5,597 posts)
26. I'm with you, Coventina!
Wed Aug 14, 2024, 05:27 PM
Aug 2024

Gloria Steinem said, "Expecting everyone who has a uterus to be a mother is like expecting everyone with vocal cords to be an opera singer."

barbtries

(29,943 posts)
27. they totally should have known
Wed Aug 14, 2024, 05:27 PM
Aug 2024

why you still had your ovaries.

You are not childless. You are a bereaved mother and you have done exceedingly well in your life in spite of your loss. JD Vance is an opportunistic idiot who hasn't figured out that people hate what he's saying.

fuck the patriarchy.

?si=-JTnj1S43S1XaOkq

Warpy

(113,131 posts)
29. What's really awful is running into a female doctor who was trained by men
Wed Aug 14, 2024, 05:30 PM
Aug 2024

and struggled to be one of the boys to the extent she's just as big a misogynist. I've had the misfortune to run into several of those.

The practice of viewing women as small, imperfect men has taken a horrendous toll on your health since most drugs that are being used were never tested on women and our reaction to them can be drastically different.

Fellow nurses have always noted that no ovary is ever good enough to leave in and no testoc;e os ever bad enough to come out because it's still men's medicine.

I don't know how long it will take to rid ourselves of all this backwards thinking. It has to happen.

And JD Vance doesn't know jack shit about anything except how to lie. I guess his Mama taught him that much, addicts are great at it.

bluboid

(705 posts)
32. yes!!!!!!!!!
Wed Aug 14, 2024, 05:38 PM
Aug 2024

Please take care of yourself - we need your voice, & all female voices, to speak our Truth.

stopdiggin

(12,988 posts)
33. the man is excelling in the role of sexist pig
Wed Aug 14, 2024, 05:40 PM
Aug 2024

Too bad, in the case of Vance, that we will never have any idea if any of it is genuine ...
(as we've already established that this individual is completely lacking in any sort of moral center or true conviction.)

But then - I suppose we're all aware that the insults, the deliberate offense, and the overall circus - is all part of the script?

gordianot

(15,532 posts)
34. They are stuck with that smug hillbilly Entrepreneur want to be.
Wed Aug 14, 2024, 05:40 PM
Aug 2024

He serves as inflection point for women and men who reject Misogyny.

BattleRow

(1,255 posts)
42. Juvenile Delinquent (JD)
Wed Aug 14, 2024, 05:54 PM
Aug 2024

Vance is ,himself,unfortunately well beyond the term limit for legal abortion.

dlk

(12,466 posts)
35. At some point, most women have had misogynistic experiences with modern medicine
Wed Aug 14, 2024, 05:41 PM
Aug 2024

And I’m very sorry for your loss. Everyone deserves to be treated with dignity and respect by their medical providers.Unfortunately, even some of the most highly educated individuals can be stupefyingly ignorant.

When they ask, “why?” we need to answer “why not”?

Permanut

(6,713 posts)
37. Thank you for posting this, Coventina.
Wed Aug 14, 2024, 05:46 PM
Aug 2024

This 78 year old guy salutes your courage for doing your part to expose the systemic misogyny that started with Adam.. Or when ramapithecus first climbed down out of the trees.

I have not, and never will walk a mile in your shoes. Thank you for telling your story

Timeflyer

(2,712 posts)
38. It's like he wants to enrage every woman of every age everywhere. Too bad women fought and won the vote, you sorry POS.
Wed Aug 14, 2024, 05:47 PM
Aug 2024

And it will be women who take him and the Gilded Turd down in November, like a lady pack of killer whales (which are among the few animals beside human primates who go through menopause.)

robbob

(3,642 posts)
39. As a man, let me just say:
Wed Aug 14, 2024, 05:47 PM
Aug 2024

JD Vance is such a piece of shit. Right out of central casting for the handmaidens tale. I hope woman and thinking feeling men of all backgrounds show up in droves this November and finally put the last nail in the MAGAT coffin.

BattleRow

(1,255 posts)
40. Uh,just a thought,but
Wed Aug 14, 2024, 05:49 PM
Aug 2024

what about men who are sterile and can't procreate?
Do their votes carry more weight?

 

Zoomie1986

(1,213 posts)
45. It's okay when they're sterile
Wed Aug 14, 2024, 06:05 PM
Aug 2024

Because they'll find a way to blame it all on a woman. His mommy didn't get him the Tonka truck for his birthday. A girl won the reading award in 5th grade that he thought was his. Another rejected him for the senior prom. All of those offenses made his sperm dry up and blow away, donchaknow?

nature-lover

(1,718 posts)
41. My fortyish female OBGYN told me that at my age I don't need hormones. Never went back.
Wed Aug 14, 2024, 05:50 PM
Aug 2024

Went to a hormone replacement specialist instead. Quite happy with the results.

IbogaProject

(3,751 posts)
43. There are many Men Who shouldn't have kids
Wed Aug 14, 2024, 05:55 PM
Aug 2024

T45, JD Prance, etc. That is all facsists have is to devide us and turn us against each other. I support all humans, with the exception of killers, rapists, polluters, and toads in support ignorance and greedy capitalists.

Jean Genie

(417 posts)
44. UR Beautiful!
Wed Aug 14, 2024, 05:56 PM
Aug 2024

Brava! Well said!
You are beautiful! Your life has purpose! You are important. You are more than a mommy or a granny, or a caregiver.
Fuck the patriarchy!

onlyadream

(2,221 posts)
46. Us post meno women get to be the Marthas
Wed Aug 14, 2024, 06:09 PM
Aug 2024

This guy JD Vance is all over the place. Another grifter without any ideals. I feel sorry for his non trad wife.

calimary

(84,575 posts)
49. You're living proof that women are good for LOTS of things. Not just child-related.
Wed Aug 14, 2024, 06:20 PM
Aug 2024

Everyone can help create a better world. Everybody has something valuable to contribute, and I’m not just talking money-related.

Scrivener7

(53,148 posts)
50. Your life is OBVIOUSLY valuable to you and others.
Wed Aug 14, 2024, 06:21 PM
Aug 2024

The real question is, what is JD Vance's purpose?

Really. I can't come up with anything.

I'm sorry about your son.

Sympthsical

(10,391 posts)
52. Hopefully new awareness is taking hold
Wed Aug 14, 2024, 06:31 PM
Aug 2024

I'm doing clinicals this semester (going for NP eventually). And during all this, our instruction has been incorporating a lot of women-specific and minority-specific literature and studies to increase the awareness of healthcare providers.

For example, we were going over pain levels in care. And during this, the instructor made sure to make us aware that women - particularly Black women - are more often discounted when it comes to pain and do not have doctors' attention drawn to it in a timely manner for treatment or medication.

She emphasized that we can't be defensive about our own unconscious biases. She had a good bit where she told us (paraphrasing), "People like to say they don't see color. In this case, I want you to see color to check that you are administering the same level of care. Awareness is an active interrogation of blind spots."

I loved that.

Jazz Jon

(130 posts)
53. Apology
Wed Aug 14, 2024, 06:39 PM
Aug 2024

I apologize for men. I am one. Men can be real shit heads. Its not all men though. Maybe 65%. That leaves millions of men who dont hate women.

ShazzieB

(18,924 posts)
55. DOWN WITH THE PATRIARCHY IS RIGHT!
Wed Aug 14, 2024, 06:45 PM
Aug 2024

Last edited Thu Aug 15, 2024, 01:12 PM - Edit history (1)

First of all, I want to express my heartfelt condolences for your losses, Coventina, including the loss of your son and your multiple pregnancy losses. I feel your pain and I ache for you.

JD Vance would probably think I'm useless, too. I do have one child, but I'll never have grandchildren, so I guess I'm just a waste of space at this point, according to him.

We "planned" to have at least two kids, but infertility had other ideas. It took us years and endless trips to multiple doctors to conceive our daughter, and once we had her, I just couldn't face going through all that stress all over again. So we said "all done" at one.

She's in her late 30s now and determinedly childfree. She has never wanted kids, never had any interest in them, wouldn't even play with baby dolls when she was little. Kids are simply not her thing.

When it gradually became clear that she was never going to be interested in motherhood, I accepted it. I wanted her to do what was best for her, not put her wishes aside to please me. I've always had a great dislike of parents (usually moms) who hassle their grown kids about giving them grandkids and an even greater dislike of people who push the idea that everybody has to have kids, and I was not about to be one of those people.

Instead, I chose to focus on developing a variety of thobbies and interests that give me satisfaction and joy. I feel that I have a very full life, and although I would have welcomed a grandchild or two, I do not need them to make my life worth living or to make me feel that I have worth as a human.

Furthermore, I know for a fact that all of our lives have worth and value. That goes for your life, Coventina, my childfree daughter's life, and my life as a non-grandmother. We all have our own special gifts and our own contributions to make, all of which are part of the rich tapestry of life.

People like JD Vance, who think having babies is the only thing that gives a young woman's life value and grandchildren are the only thing that can give worth to the life of an older woman, are full of crap and need to stfu about things of which they obviously know nothing. At this point, I'm already sicker of JD than I am of the Orange Hellbeast, sick of his condescension and his know it all attitude and his freaking 19th century views about women!

ALL women have value, whether we are mothers, grandmothers, both, or neither. Each of us has something special to contribute and we need to celebrate that and celebrate each other!

P.S. Fuck Shady Vance and the couch he rode in on!

mcar

(43,619 posts)
56. I had bad uterine fibroids too
Wed Aug 14, 2024, 06:45 PM
Aug 2024


The bleeding was horrendous. I did manage to have 2 kids, 10 years apart. After the 2nd, my female gynNP recommended a hysterectomy, saying you don’t need your uterus anymore.

I asked her if she’d tell a man to have his dick cut off because he didn’t want more children. I found another solution, doing my own research. She ended up recommending other women do the same.

Had my ovaries removed some years later, on my own terms. I am now a proud Nana of 2. Wasn’t easy, but I got there.

I also still run my own business.Fck Vance. What a weirdo.

Pacifist Patriot

(24,912 posts)
58. I just lost my shit very publicly after reading that.
Wed Aug 14, 2024, 06:54 PM
Aug 2024

He wouldn't last 5 seconds in a room with me and still be able to procreate.

iwillalwayswonderwhy

(2,666 posts)
61. I had endometriosis so bad
Wed Aug 14, 2024, 07:17 PM
Aug 2024

I was continuously anemic.

The doctor said I really needed a hysterectomy, but I was still child bearing age. I told him I had 3 children and was a single mother.

He honest to goodness told me I was attractive, would probably remarry, and that my future husband would probably want children. What? A fictitious future husband has a say in my medical care?

2 years later, hysterectomy happened, woman gynecologist.

VGuerra276

(55 posts)
63. Yes
Wed Aug 14, 2024, 07:58 PM
Aug 2024

You are saying exactly how I feel. The fury is real. May it overwhelmingly be so on election day.

GiqueCee

(1,489 posts)
64. Can't argue with you on this...
Wed Aug 14, 2024, 08:25 PM
Aug 2024

... but not all men sniveling, self-absorbed imbeciles. LOTS, to be sure, but not all. Even crusty old septuagenarians like me are capable of finding enlightenment.
I'm on your side.
But the attitudes you describe are the bedrock of conservatism, which I consider a mental disorder on the sociopathy spectrum. Sadly, it is not the exclusive domain of Republicans, though they're far more vocal – and dirt stupid – about it.

lostnfound

(16,708 posts)
65. It's ironic, to produce 10 singleton children in.a year requires 10 women and 1 man
Wed Aug 14, 2024, 08:26 PM
Aug 2024

They think that makes the men important or something. But by their logic, it makes 9 of them expendable.

Wait, what? It’s not just about biologically producing kids, it’s about being breadwinners? Well what do you know. I guess having a career CAN make a person valuable.

llmart

(16,331 posts)
66. That little fuckwad hillbilly Vance has no business telling women what they should or shouldn't be doing.
Wed Aug 14, 2024, 08:50 PM
Aug 2024

I do have one grandchild and she is absolutely beautiful and kind and smart as a whip. My daughter had IVF in order to have a child. She will be the only grandchild I have. Having said that, I don't think my role as a grandmother is to take care of my grandchild. Quite frankly, I have enough to do with my own life and responsibilities and volunteer work and just plain fun things to do and occasionally some travel.

I had two children and they didn't know their grandparents. My parents died before I had the children so I had no one to help me with all that is involved in childrearing. It was 24/7/365 until they were old enough to occasionally stay home by themselves for a few hours. I enjoyed being a mother and always wanted to be but I am so over the responsibility of that. When other grandmothers talk about how they watch their grandchildren, it never sounds like they truly enjoy it but feel like they should. I just tell them that I don't want to be tied down in my retirement years. At least I'm honest about it.

Fuck Vance and the patriarchy!

raising2moredems

(714 posts)
68. Remember this..
Wed Aug 14, 2024, 10:12 PM
Aug 2024

And I do wish I had kept the newspaper article - every woman should be a bitch:

Be
In
Total
Control of
Herself

Fuck JD Vance - gads half my family are/were hillbillies and he ain't a damn hillbilly.

GopherGal

(2,401 posts)
69. Women outlive men
Wed Aug 14, 2024, 10:27 PM
Aug 2024

(at least in societies where there isn't considerable fatality due to childbirth).

A postulated reason for this to have come about via evolution is that the contributions of older (post-childbearing age) women to their descendants' survival tend to increase the persistence of the genes of the long-lived women.

So basically, superior female lifespan may be an evolutionary consequence of women having something more to give than just the physical production of future generations; namely to contributions to nurturing the welfare of those future generations. At the risk of sounding misandristic, it may be that the wisdom of old women is more valuable to the survival of the younger generations than the contributions of old men.

And,, yeah, okay, fellas, it's also possible that, due to the physiology of human reproduction, there is less uncertainty about kinship on the female side, so a woman's resources/wisdom that benefit the younger generations can be more certain to be deployed to the benefit of her own genetic offspring. This might be another way in which genes promoting longer female lifespans might be more heritable than those promoting longer male lifespans.

Either way, those who are not/no longer physically reproducing can undoubtedly contribute to the welfare of society

lapfog_1

(30,231 posts)
77. just because you go to Harvard or Yale
Thu Aug 15, 2024, 12:03 AM
Aug 2024

does not imply you are either intelligent or educated.

On average... yes. but there are always the very endpoints of any bell curve

Farmer-Rick

(11,532 posts)
71. Melania Trump is post menopause
Wed Aug 14, 2024, 10:50 PM
Aug 2024

How many grandchildren is she taking care of?

The average age of menopause for women in the US is 51. Melania is 54. Despite if she's taking estrogen or not, she's still considered post menopause. So tell us Vance, how many grandchildren is that woman taking care of?

oregonjen

(3,500 posts)
72. Going to challenge that just a bit, but I get your point
Wed Aug 14, 2024, 10:57 PM
Aug 2024

She might not be post menopausal yet. Women as late as their sixties can still menstruate.

Response to oregonjen (Reply #72)

Blue Full Moon

(1,302 posts)
73. This is their last gasp.
Wed Aug 14, 2024, 11:11 PM
Aug 2024

I think they over estimated their hand. Letting project 2025 out and having everyone see their plans has worked against them. They know they are going down. Every woman's worth isn't birthing. I liked a comment I had seen. That JD Vance has no convections and that trump has 34 of them. So remember that and what he says amounts to a hill of beans. You, me and just about every woman I know will go vote for Kamala. Then trump and vance will see who is irrelevant.

mainer

(12,193 posts)
84. I'd like to hear what he thinks about 50+ year old men
Thu Aug 15, 2024, 07:34 AM
Aug 2024

What is their purpose in life? You can bet it has nothing to do with child care.

eppur_se_muova

(37,636 posts)
85. For most of human history, average life expectancy was well under 40 years. Not a lot of time for grandparenting.
Thu Aug 15, 2024, 08:25 AM
Aug 2024

Vance is one of those people who forms recklessly extrapolated opinions from a very small set of wobbly premises, and thinks he's a genius for doing so. Worse, he is not restrained by any sense of empathy or simple human decency. He believes being brutally harsh is good for the peons whose lives he feels entitled to command.

Joinfortmill

(16,605 posts)
87. Amen, sister. I wrote 6 books as a postmenapausal woman. So, as they say, "How do you like those apples?"
Thu Aug 15, 2024, 08:47 AM
Aug 2024

GoldenMezzoDiva

(110 posts)
88. Shady is an INCEL, plain and simple...
Thu Aug 15, 2024, 09:31 AM
Aug 2024

The worst kind because he hides behind a wife and kids. But the proof of the pudding is the company that he keeps. Boo-hiss-hiss!

Elessar Zappa

(16,068 posts)
90. Stories like yours are why
Thu Aug 15, 2024, 09:58 AM
Aug 2024

Gen Z women are the most liberal demographic in history. They’re tired of conservative males trying to dictate their lives for them. And Gen Z men better get on board if they ever hope to be in a relationship that doesn’t involve palms, couches, or rubber dolls.

Prairie_Seagull

(3,817 posts)
91. Sorry my gender can be such blind idiots at times and
Thu Aug 15, 2024, 10:10 AM
Aug 2024

as a very supportive husband and father of daughters, I am personally working for a better future for everyone with additional focus on evening the playing field. That said, there will be 'growing pains'. My daughters (univ. educated) think that we all can just snap our fingers and make it so. From my perspective this will take a generation or 3.

Keep working the long standing problem. You have my (and many others) support.



On Edit- The irony is not lost on me.

Amishman

(5,832 posts)
92. I was agreeing with you until 'The future is female'
Thu Aug 15, 2024, 10:11 AM
Aug 2024

Think about what says to young men.

No wonder the right is making inroads with Gen Z males.

Misogyny by some, especially those in power, does not justify marginalizing all men.

If we want men to vote blue, shame and scorn is not a good idea.

Cirsium

(1,121 posts)
95. that is not true
Thu Aug 15, 2024, 11:34 AM
Aug 2024

That is no more true than the idea that Black Lives Matter alienates whites. "Think about what Black Lives Matter says to whites! No wonder the right is making inroads with white people!"

No men are being marginalized. No one is being shamed and scorned. The right wingers claim that somehow discussing racism makes them feel guilty and therefore we shouldn't discuss racism. You are suggestig the same idea in regards to misogyny. That is reactionary claptrap, dragged out and put on display every time opposition to oppression of a group of people is being discussed.

Misogyny is not a matter of personal individual preferences or beliefs any more than racism is. It is a social issue, deeply embedded in our economics, institutions and social relations. Taking discussions of racism and misogyny personally is a way to trivialize and dismiss the issue.

Amishman

(5,832 posts)
98. Thank you for proving my point
Thu Aug 15, 2024, 01:26 PM
Aug 2024

So many can't get past the abstract philosophical justification for this stance and appreciating the actual human response and how alienating lectures like that can be.

Cirsium

(1,121 posts)
100. OK
Thu Aug 15, 2024, 02:16 PM
Aug 2024

So you would have us stop talking about misogyny and racism because some people (white men) might take it personally and might then have hurt feelings and that might hurt the electoral chances for Democratic candidates?

White men are not being harmed by these discussions. That's fact. How about you explain that fact to any people you come across who express the silly idea that white men are somehow being harmed rather than pandering to their ignorance?

Beyond that I don't think those who make the claim of harm even believe that they are being harmed. It is just a ruse, a ploy, a product on the worst right wing propaganda.

Wild blueberry

(7,260 posts)
93. What a superb post!
Thu Aug 15, 2024, 11:18 AM
Aug 2024

Thank you.
You channeled your righteous fury well.
I laughed out loud at "Why do you still have your balls?" Perfection!

As I'm sure you know, none of this is new. I'm reading "The Benevolent Society of Ill-Mannered Ladies" by Alison Goodman, set in 1812 London. (Sensing you might enjoy it, too.)

onlyadream

(2,221 posts)
96. How the hell does his wife live with him????
Thu Aug 15, 2024, 12:16 PM
Aug 2024

It's like women's sole purpose is ONLY around rearing children. His wife is a lawyer! He should know that many women, those with children and without, feel a calling to something other than motherhood. It's about choice, not obligation.

When I was 20, a guy I worked with told me I was responsible to have two children (to replace myself and my future husband). Even though I always wanted 2 children, the statement of obligation really made me angry. Fuck him. Fuck JD Vance.

TexasBushwhacker

(20,727 posts)
97. The grandparents who raised Vance
Thu Aug 15, 2024, 12:22 PM
Aug 2024

also raised his drug addicted mother. Maybe if they had raised her better they wouldn't have had to raise him and his sister. His lack of self awareness is amazing.

Dark n Stormy Knight

(10,046 posts)
99. I love you! This is a great post.
Thu Aug 15, 2024, 01:26 PM
Aug 2024

I'm sorry and angry, though of course not surprised, at the misogynistic treatment thrust upon you by professionals who ought to know better.

I'm inspired by your post because you speak the truth of your specific personal experiences and that of all women to one degree or another. And you say "No fucking way! " to the RWBS

I'm with you. DOWN WITH THE PATRIARCHY! THE FUTURE IS FEMALE!!!!

Diamond_Dog

(35,118 posts)
101. Great post and superb comments
Thu Aug 15, 2024, 02:35 PM
Aug 2024

Vance can go fuck off. He is an ignorant asswipe. All women deserve choice and dignity.

CousinIT

(10,464 posts)
102. Men don't get to tell women or girls what their purpose in life is at any stage. Women/girls can decide for themselves.
Thu Aug 15, 2024, 03:19 PM
Aug 2024

I find that men who are so controlling are typically the abusive types. Misogynists, yes, and abusive.

Harris and Walz talk about freedom. They are partially referring to the freedom of women and girls to decide their own path in life and to discover their own purpose—whether it includes marriage and children or not, and whatever stage in life they are at. There is no right or wrong. Every woman should be free to live the life she wants, which is right for her, regardless of her circumstances or stage in life.

Those freedoms are being threatened and taken away, and no self-respecting woman should stand for it. They should be angry as hell! It's justified.

And add the "childless cat lady" and "post-menopausal women" taunts. IT'S ABUSE! That is abusive language.

Fucking anger is JUSTIFIED. STOMP E'M AT THE BALLOT BOX!

Behind the Aegis

(54,922 posts)
103. I am so sorry for your experience.
Thu Aug 15, 2024, 03:22 PM
Aug 2024

As a gay man, I have had my share of run-ins with the medical profession. I have a brother who is a doctor and he has strived to be open to listening to his patients and understanding their needs, especially geriatric (another group often dismissed out of hand) and the GLBT community, given he has a 'mo for an older brother. But sadly, what you describe is still the reality. Is it getting better? I don't know. My hair stylist was pregnant and started spotting. She called it in asking to be seen; she was dismissed and told to come in when she was 6 weeks along. Two days later, she miscarried. The person who shooed her away was a woman, but when a profession is dominated by a certain group, sometimes, even those "subjugated" fall into the bad habits they see.

I am sorry for your experience, but it did remind me of something. I hope you don't see this as trivializing your situation (is so, let me know and I will remove it). Did you ever watch "The Golden Girls"? If you did, you may remember this, if not...



Some things never seem to change or do so slowly as to be glacial.

mucholderthandirt

(1,201 posts)
104. Sorry for your loss, and glad you are speaking out against this kind of shit.
Fri Aug 16, 2024, 09:08 AM
Aug 2024

My husband used to have bad kidney stones, and once we were waiting for some xrays when this young fool who was shunting DH (d is for dumb) around the hospital turned to me, overcome with my DH's pain, and told me, for true, that having kidney stones was just like being in labor.

I just looked at him for a second, looked at the baby DH moaning and crying, and said "Come back when you've been in labor four days with a breach baby."

He had the grace to look shamed, and apologized.

On a side note, the next time DH was in the hospital with kidney stones, they put him on morphine. I decided at the last minute one day to stop by before work and check in on him. Hadn't been there the day before, due to work and taking care of the two kids. I walked in, DH barely breathing, pretty much out of it. Oxygen not working. I pressed the call button and had to bully the nurse to come check.

Turns out the idiot DH was allergic to morphine and would have died within minutes if I hadn't come. He was getting no oxygen, either. For years people would ask me why I just didn't turn around and walk off. My response was, "I'm better than him. That's something he would do.".

Latest Discussions»General Discussion»My experience with the de...