Do you support or oppose the H.R. 4038 American SAFE Act against refugees?

[Logical]

H.R. 4038 is known as the ‘‘American Security Against Foreign Enemies Act of 2015’’ or as the ‘‘American SAFE Act of 2015’’ . The mandate is “To require that s supplemental certifications and background investigation be completed prior to the admission of certain aliens as refugees, and for other purposes. ”

16 votes, 0 passes | Time left: Unlimited
	I support the bill as we need more "supplemental certifications and background investigation" of these refugees
	4 (25%)
	I oppose the bill as these refugees are already screened enough
	12 (75%)
	0 DU members did not wish to select any of the options provided.
Show usernames Disclaimer: This is an Internet poll

[bigwillq]

1. Support. Like gun control

It can't hurt to have strict (er) policies. I'd rather be safe than sorry.

[Logical]

2. And that is why the patroit act passed! FEAR!

[sarisataka]

10. No such thing

As too many laws to a free society

[LostOne4Ever]

3. There is no excuse for this poll not being 100% opposed!!! nt

[melm00se]

4. I know that I going to get blasted for this

but the text of the House Bill sounds (to me at least) that the FBI would be tasked with oversight to ensure that background checks are performed:

Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) shall take all actions necessary to ensure that each covered alien receives a background investigation before U.S. refugee admission.

Additionally, Congress is acting in its oversight capacity by tasking that

(the) DHS shall report monthly to Congress on the total number of admission applications for which a certification was made and the number of covered aliens for whom such a certification was not made for the preceding month. The report shall include for each covered alien for whom a certification was not made the concurrence or nonconcurrence of each person whose concurrence was required by the certification.

I have no issue with the law, in and of itself, but I will have an issue if the law is abused in its implementation.

[NCTraveler]

12. It is my understanding that both of those are currently on the books...

and have nothing to do with the odorous parts of this bill. Once we determine how many we will accept, under current law, those individuals wouldn't step foot on US soil for well over a year while check after check are done. This has nothing to do with additional checks. The legislation has to do with stopping them from coming here. FBI checks are done on every single refugee before they come here. As does a CIA check, a written report from their country of origin with additional checks, along with checks from other US and non-us agencies. That is already being done. The republicans are spinning it so people think this isn't the current reality. It is.

[geek tragedy]

16. you didn't read the actual text

A covered alien may not be admitted as a refugee until the Director of the Federal Bureau of Investigation certifies to the Secretary of Homeland Security and the Director of National Intelligence that each covered alien has received a background investigation that is sufficient to determine whether the covered alien is a threat to the security of the United States.

(b) Certification by unanimous concurrence.—A covered alien may only be admitted to the United States after the Secretary of Homeland Security, with the unanimous concurrence of the Director of the Federal Bureau of Investigation and the Director of National Intelligence, certifies to the appropriate Congressional Committees that the covered alien is not a threat to the security of the United States.

(c) Inspector general review of certifications.—The Inspector General of the Department of Homeland Security shall conduct a risk-based review of all certifications made under subsection (b) each year and shall provide an annual report detailing the findings to the appropriate Congressional Committees.

[951-Riverside]

5. I oppose any 'extra' screening because its racist

Would we subject African-American police officers to 'extra' screening because of Chris Dorner?

Absolutely not.

So, why are some so-called progressives okay with subjecting thousands of people to screenings just because of their ethnicity and religion?

I say let them all in, we already have terrorists within our country killing people everyday and they're called Gang members most of whom are of the Christian or Catholic faiths.

I honestly don't get why people get so freaked out when Muslims commits violent crimes, its as if 11,700 people haven't died this year so far due to gun violence in our own country (That's 36 people a day BTW).

[B2G]

7. Are you even SERIOUS??

"we already have terrorists within our country killing people everyday and they're called Gang members most of whom are of the Christian or Catholic faiths."

[951-Riverside]

9. Yes, why do you ask?

[NCTraveler]

13. You just won the internet. nt.

[Logical]

19. It is racist! Nt

[ileus]

6. Can you even screen folks from these areas?

After the local government offices have been destroyed and everyone scattered who/what info can actually be gathered besides a persons word for who they are?

Did they even have records in the first place?

[Logical]

18. Wow, you are sounding like bush in 2001. Nice concern. just say you are scared and....

Move on.

[Bradical79]

8. Oppose

It's my understanding that we already have strong screening and it's already a multiyear process. It doesn't make much sense for a terrorist to enter the U.S. through this method. The bill is made to play on racist fears.

[Logical]

11. +1000 nt

[geek tragedy]

14. the bill doesn't call for screening, it calls for a de facto moratorium

it asks three cabinet-level officials to personally certify that there is zero risk from EVERY SINGLE REFUGEE.

[Logical]

15. Wow, and some voted yes! disgusting!

[geek tragedy]

17. yes, it's about making life difficult for the Obama administration, but some people wallow in fear

and will follow the loud and dumb party down the xenophobic path.

[Logical]

20. Glad to see 90% of the DU are not scared of make believe. nt