General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsThis Speech Expert Thinks Trump Has A Disorder – Here’s Why (VIDEO)
For nearly 30 years, I was a licensed, certified speech/language pathologist. I spent hours analyzing the expressive language of my patients. Im retired now, without a license, but I havent forgotten what I did every day.
I havent examined Donald Trump (R-N.Y.), but let me explain why I think Trump has either a language disorder, or another neurological problem.
1. Word Finding; Misusing Words
The first thing Ive noticed with Trump is that he tends to slightly misuse words. In speech/language pathology, this is a word finding issue. In the current speech, Trump began by calling the Convention as a beautiful event. He complimented the speakers, saying:
So many of the speakers were so amazing and really ground setting. Just ground setting.
Clearly he meant ground breaking, but he didnt notice.
Later he said that former Secretary of State, Hillary Clintons (D-N.Y.) people swamped Senator Bernie Sanders (D-Vt.). He seemed to mean that they mistreated him, which isnt what swamped means.
2. Word Finding; Empty Words
People with word finding deficits rely on words with little meaning. They use phrases like by the way, or believe me. They depend heavily on empty words like really and very, and use a restricted list of adjectives. Trump uses the words tremendous,amazing, and nice, none of which tells us anything.
People with this disorder repeat themselves a lot.
A small sample from today:
Thank you very much. We had an amazing convention. It was one of the best. [
] Ivanka was incredible last night.[
] It has been just an incredible four days.[
] Tiffany was amazing.
So, I will tell you, I think were gonna get a lot of his voters. Because of the trade issue. Because they understand. Because of the trade issue, I think were gonna get a lot of his voters.
3. Expressive Language Organization
To speech/language pathologists, this means expressing one thought. It means beginning a thought and getting to the end. Trump speaks in sentence fragments. He begins a thought, but drops it and simply jumps ahead.
For example:
Honestly, he should have done it. Because
.nobody cares. And he would have been in better shape for four years from now if hes
I dont think
I dont see him winning frankly anyway.
/snip
http://www.liberalamerica.org/2016/07/22/this-speech-expert-thinks-trump-has-a-disorder-heres-why-video/
MineralMan
(146,288 posts)"Doc, I've had this trump on my junk for a couple of months. Could it be cancer?"
Photographer
(1,142 posts)Doodley
(9,088 posts)Nitram
(22,794 posts)mopinko
(70,092 posts)loyalsister
(13,390 posts)maybe he has just gotten by without having social or other consequences for acting like a jerk? There was never a possibility that he would get fired, permanently thrown out of school, or that people would break loyalty since he could instantly fire them.
Then, he made a profession out of it. Right now there is no need to have manners or self monitor because he's the star of his own show.
The bigger problem with pathologizing this is letting people who act like him off the hook with a diagnosis. Ordinary people say the kind of stuff he says all the time. They aren't sick. They are rude, and seem to not worry about offending people. Nothing is too outrageous. Aside from the bigotry, another aspect of this pathology fetish is- would we really want that kind of behavior to be protected under ADA?
world wide wally
(21,742 posts)Vinca
(50,269 posts)That seems to fit into #2 - word finding. Personally, I think he's got a combination of narcissistic personality disorder and early senile dementia, but since my medical education comes from google I'll defer to the speech pathologist.