Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

mahatmakanejeeves

(57,425 posts)
Mon Sep 19, 2016, 09:57 AM Sep 2016

Jill Stein: Trump may have 'memory problem'

Source: Politico

Jill Stein: Trump may have 'memory problem'

The physician turned Green Party candidate sees signs of health, mental, cognitive issues in the man atop the GOP ticket.

By Glenn Thrush

09/19/16 05:01 AM EDT

Jill Stein is a Harvard-trained internist, a doctor who diagnosed thousands of patients for a quarter-century in Boston and Chicago before making the late-career switch to Green Party presidential candidate and could-be Hillary Clinton spoiler. ... So, as we settled in for our “Off Message” podcast interview last week in a drab hotel conference room in Baltimore (she had a rally there last Friday), I asked Stein -- as a clinician used to making snap assessment -- whether she agreed with that Donald Trump “will be the healthiest individual ever elected to the presidency,” as declared by his Bruce Vilanch-esque personal physician, Harold Bornstein.

“You know, I don't pretend to be able to do TV diagnosis, but I think the guy has a problem,” said the 66-year-old candidate, who is averaging somewhere between 2 and 5 percent in most national and state polls, enough (Clinton people say) to put a scare into the Democrat in too-close-to-call states. “The guy has a lot of problems -- physical, mental, emotional, cognitive,” Stein said of Trump. ... As proof of his (alleged) pathology, she pointed to his position-hopping on a range of issues, which she cast as erratic rather than calculating -- from his fuzzy Iraq positions over the years, to his brief “softening” on immigration last month, to his decision (on the day we spoke) to suddenly renounce birtherism after five years of banging a drumbeat of lies.

“It's hard to, you know, to think too hard about anything Donald Trump says because he will change his mind in the next hour, if not the next day, or whatever,” she added. “Today, suddenly, after five years, he became convinced that it's not an issue. Yesterday it was an issue. It will probably become an issue again for him. You know, the guy may have a memory problem. Who knows what it is? But he's incapable of having a consistent thought or policy.”

Stein also thinks he’s getting a free pass because he spent his career in private business, and wants Trump – along with everybody else – to release his tax returns. “At least with Clinton, you know, there was some degree of transparency,” she said. “But what's going on with Trump, you can't even get at and what he said was that even to clarify 15 out of these 500 deals, these are just like the most frightening mafiosos around the world. He's like -- he's a magnet for crime and extortion.”

Read more: http://www.politico.com/story/2016/09/jill-stein-trump-may-have-memory-problem-228346



I hear that a lot of people are saying this. Smart people, the brightest people. Lots of them. A cognitive disorder, which, possibly, a growing number of people think Trump has, is disqualifying, don't you think? I myself have no way of knowing whether this is true or not, but it is on the internet. It's certainly worth looking into.
31 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Jill Stein: Trump may have 'memory problem' (Original Post) mahatmakanejeeves Sep 2016 OP
A vote for Stein is a vote for Trump Gothmog Sep 2016 #1
Trump doesn't have a memory problem. Nitram Sep 2016 #2
Agree. He has a well-recognized personality disorder. Hortensis Sep 2016 #16
It's a true test of her intellectual honesty. Nitram Sep 2016 #21
She will, Nitram. She's a mental health professional Hortensis Sep 2016 #25
A very stressful occupation, but one that is desperately needed. Nitram Sep 2016 #28
She actually said something negative about Trump? bluestateguy Sep 2016 #3
"Jill, Vlad is one line one!" ProudToBeBlueInRhody Sep 2016 #4
I thought the same thing. NWCorona Sep 2016 #7
A science denying doctor isn't someone I'd look for medical advise from. n/t Tempest Sep 2016 #5
Jull Stein has some memory problems too Renew Deal Sep 2016 #6
Only 'memory problems' I see are Bernie supporters who are supporting Jill Stein LynneSin Sep 2016 #8
Your dig has no place here. We're all for Clinton now. FailureToCommunicate Sep 2016 #13
I'm not digging at the Bernie supporters who support Hillary LynneSin Sep 2016 #14
Yeah, I still see a few Bernie-or-else comments in here sometimes. That's true. ColemanMaskell Sep 2016 #17
Thank you LynneSin Sep 2016 #24
Oh but you are. The "Stein supporters" However, "they" are so few, and small, they'd fit in a petri dish FailureToCommunicate Sep 2016 #19
You really are doing this just to pick a fight. Please stop LynneSin Sep 2016 #23
I've actually met a few in real life ... karynnj Sep 2016 #30
I think many of those people are too young to remember 2000. Odin2005 Sep 2016 #29
That's my thoughts too. We barely survived 8 years with Bush LynneSin Sep 2016 #31
Trump is "a magnet for crime and extortion.” Good quote Jill Stein, trump won't like to read that. Sunlei Sep 2016 #9
Tough call on what is most disqualifying, being a criminal or memory loss. Coyotl Sep 2016 #10
Yeah. So many other people have memories that Trump's bullshit doesn't fly. n/t Orsino Sep 2016 #11
I'm kicking this because it's the first Trump criticism I've ever seen from her Blue_Tires Sep 2016 #12
Okay. murielm99 Sep 2016 #15
Okay? ColemanMaskell Sep 2016 #18
So may you, Jill JHB Sep 2016 #20
But she still thinks Trump is a better choice mcar Sep 2016 #22
Maybe he had a vaccination, Jill. spiderpig Sep 2016 #26
memory problems my ass. he's a liar. nt Lil Missy Sep 2016 #27

Hortensis

(58,785 posts)
16. Agree. He has a well-recognized personality disorder.
Mon Sep 19, 2016, 06:44 PM
Sep 2016

One prominent expert said he is a textbook case. It does affect cognition, but whether he is malignant enough to qualify as a psychopath (newer term) I haven't read. The search terms are "cluster B" personality traits. And narcissism.

My half sister, who is a psychologist, says she and her colleagues at work have been watching the race in horrified fascination, but they are also clearly enjoying tagging all the obvious signs of his disorder. I once asked if they thought he would meet criteria for psychopathy, but she didn't answer. Doesn't mean he does, though.

The whole thing's a touchy subject and she's not all that forthcoming. She's very conservative, soaked in all the lies about Hillary long ago; but now that the race is tightening she's afraid she may be forced to vote for her against Trump to make sure he doesn't get in office. A choice between a lesser and great evil. Not happy, but imo she deserves it, not that I actually say that to her.

Hortensis

(58,785 posts)
25. She will, Nitram. She's a mental health professional
Tue Sep 20, 2016, 08:09 PM
Sep 2016

for whom clinical personality disorders are extremely real. Political openmindedness isn't her strongest point, but voting for him is completely out of the question.

She mostly specializes in depression and anxiety, which she likes because she really can help. Some with personality disorders are deeply depressed because they keep getting fired and destroying relationships, but mostly she doesn't like dealing with them because their underlying disorders have apparently been effectively untreatable, sounds like mostly counseling family on understanding and dealing with their manipulations, setting boundaries, etc.

LynneSin

(95,337 posts)
8. Only 'memory problems' I see are Bernie supporters who are supporting Jill Stein
Mon Sep 19, 2016, 11:42 AM
Sep 2016

Because clearly they forgot that Bernie is endorsing Hillary and knows how important it is to keep Trump out of the White House.

FailureToCommunicate

(14,013 posts)
13. Your dig has no place here. We're all for Clinton now.
Mon Sep 19, 2016, 05:55 PM
Sep 2016

The only Bernie supporters backing that quack loser from Lexington ("Doctor" Stein) are in the inebriated fantasies of media types.

LynneSin

(95,337 posts)
14. I'm not digging at the Bernie supporters who support Hillary
Mon Sep 19, 2016, 05:58 PM
Sep 2016

It's those that are supporting Stein now saying they see no difference between Trump and Clinton AND ignore what Bernie wants his supporters to do.

ColemanMaskell

(783 posts)
17. Yeah, I still see a few Bernie-or-else comments in here sometimes. That's true.
Mon Sep 19, 2016, 07:41 PM
Sep 2016

Someone the other day was whining about Obama trying to get the TPP through in lame duck, after Hillary has already abandoned the pro-TPP stance specifically as part of an understanding with Bernie.

The person whining had "Women for Bernie" in large colorful text in her tag line.

It OUGHT to be true that we're all behind Hillary now, but the fact is that there are some stragglers on that.

LynneSin

(95,337 posts)
24. Thank you
Tue Sep 20, 2016, 09:45 AM
Sep 2016

They exist and to put our heads in the sand and say they don't is just foolish. Obviously someone else would like to ignore the problem. (read the other reply to my post).

And welcome to DU

FailureToCommunicate

(14,013 posts)
19. Oh but you are. The "Stein supporters" However, "they" are so few, and small, they'd fit in a petri dish
Mon Sep 19, 2016, 08:04 PM
Sep 2016

Only the media seems to find 'em...with a microscope.

LynneSin

(95,337 posts)
23. You really are doing this just to pick a fight. Please stop
Tue Sep 20, 2016, 09:44 AM
Sep 2016

There are former 'Bernie' supporters out there that are gung-ho for Stein. Trust me I've stop following about a dozen of them on facebook. This whole article is about one. They exist. And my point is valid. Anyone who listens to what Bernie has said countless times owner couldn't be a supporter of Jill Stein unless they weren't really a Bernie fan either.

If you choose to ignore this issue then you are the fool. It could mean the difference between a Hillary White House and a Trump one.

karynnj

(59,503 posts)
30. I've actually met a few in real life ...
Wed Sep 21, 2016, 08:57 AM
Sep 2016

One of them has for years spoken of primarying Bernie (or Leahy) from the left. He is 100% sincere as a supporter of Stein eagerly and excitedly speaking of trying to get groups to watch the small number of tv appearances she has had. He seemed surprised and sad that no one was interested in the left leaning discussion group we were in.

Odin2005

(53,521 posts)
29. I think many of those people are too young to remember 2000.
Wed Sep 21, 2016, 08:38 AM
Sep 2016

A college kid, today, would have been a preschooler, or at most a kindergartner, in 2000.

 

Coyotl

(15,262 posts)
10. Tough call on what is most disqualifying, being a criminal or memory loss.
Mon Sep 19, 2016, 12:09 PM
Sep 2016
But, I have to go with being a criminal on this one.

We need a list of Trump's known crimes.

murielm99

(30,736 posts)
15. Okay.
Mon Sep 19, 2016, 06:25 PM
Sep 2016

I forgot where I parked my car today. I was looking for a store, too, that I had only visited once. It took me a while to find it.

I am impaired. Oh, woe.

ColemanMaskell

(783 posts)
18. Okay?
Mon Sep 19, 2016, 07:59 PM
Sep 2016

Murielm99, as with all these types of things, there's a question of magnitude. Sure we all forget things sometimes. But there are medical disorders that cause extreme forgetfulness -- such as Alzheimer's, which is hereditary and which afflicted Trump's daddy Fred.
Whether Trump is "crazy like a fox" or outright nuts or just sick I have no way of knowing. But there has been a lot of speculation on the web about the possibility of Trump having Alzheimer's. Google it if you're curious.

To me it sounds plausible partly because Alzheimer's is hereditary but largely because Trump was so hot to fabricate doubts about Hillary's health. Often when people level accusations at others, they are projecting. Cheating spouses suspect and accuse their faithful mates of cheating. Liars accuse others of lying. Elevator farters are the first to accuse someone else of the offense. The fact that Trump picked imaginary ill health out of the large basket of possible attacks he could make on Hillary indicates that ill health was something that was on his mind. So that lends credence to the hypothesis that something is wrong with Trump's health. Could be Alzheimer's (Some people are saying Alzheimer's; I don't know; You tell me; etc.)

JHB

(37,159 posts)
20. So may you, Jill
Mon Sep 19, 2016, 08:16 PM
Sep 2016

Dubya's occupation of the Oval Office was the Green's big chance to forge a lefty coalition, what with Bush going whole-hog reactionary. What did you do?

Bupkis.

Latest Discussions»Latest Breaking News»Jill Stein: Trump may hav...