Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

sandensea

(21,635 posts)
Wed Dec 30, 2020, 03:13 AM Dec 2020

Argentina Legalizes Abortion, a Milestone in a Conservative Region

Source: New York Times

Argentina on Wednesday became the largest nation in Latin America to legalize abortion, a landmark vote in a conservative region and a victory for a grass-roots movement that turned years of rallies into political power.

The high-stakes vote in the Senate gripped the nation into the early morning, and the measure’s approval — by a wider-than-expected margin of 38 to 29, with one abstention — came after hours of often dramatic debate, exposing the tensions between the long-dominant Roman Catholic Church, whose influence is waning, and a growing feminist movement.

Argentina’s president, Alberto Fernández, has promised to sign the bill into law, making it legal for women to end pregnancies for any reason up to 14 weeks. After that, there will be exceptions allowed for rape and the health of the mother.

Read more: https://www.nytimes.com/2020/12/30/world/americas/argentina-legalizes-abortion.html





Argentine Vice President Cristina Kirchner presides today's Senate vote legalizing abortion on demand up to the 14th week.

The bill, the ninth public effort to legalize abortion in Argentina since 1984, is supported by President Alberto Fernández - the country's first openly pro-choice president.

"Abortion is a public health problem," Fernández noted. "The rest is hypocrisy."
22 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Argentina Legalizes Abortion, a Milestone in a Conservative Region (Original Post) sandensea Dec 2020 OP
I'm glad to hear there is some progress in this benighted world Hekate Dec 2020 #1
Celebrate because the victories are few, as they say. sandensea Dec 2020 #9
Great news! Argentina has distinguished itself as a progressive, civilized country. Hooray! 🎆🎇❤️️ Judi Lynn Dec 2020 #2
You bet, Judi. Fernandez took a big chance - as abortion rights aren't exactly popular there sandensea Dec 2020 #6
It took having a pro-military dictatorship ultra-conservative President for one term to reveal them, Judi Lynn Dec 2020 #16
Well, he certainly failed sandensea Dec 2020 #18
What a great post! You've given us an event to anticipate. A C-Span party, DU-wide! "Must See TV." Judi Lynn Dec 2020 #21
Welp, Karma13612 Dec 2020 #3
And as a pro-choice senator noted: 'if men could get pregnant, this would have been law decades ago' sandensea Dec 2020 #5
Good one! Lindsey has thrown himself at the feet of John McCain and Trump already. Judi Lynn Dec 2020 #8
Lindsey's like a cross between Roy Cohn and J. Edgar Hoover sandensea Dec 2020 #10
Oh, wow! What creepy characters they've been, all this time! Judi Lynn Dec 2020 #12
Mafiosi through and through sandensea Dec 2020 #13
Agreed 1000% !!!!! Nt Karma13612 Dec 2020 #17
Some countries going forward, some going backward. IsItJustMe Dec 2020 #4
True. To think we're one bad day at the Extreme Court from losing what's left of these rights here. sandensea Dec 2020 #7
I am old enough to remember the days of coat hangers. It is truly disparaging. IsItJustMe Dec 2020 #15
Well said. sandensea Dec 2020 #19
Thank you. You too. IsItJustMe Dec 2020 #20
The homeland of a certain Pope, too. NM Grins Dec 2020 #11
Francis wasn't too happy about it - but he largely stayed in the sidelines sandensea Dec 2020 #14
k&r Demovictory9 Dec 2020 #22

sandensea

(21,635 posts)
9. Celebrate because the victories are few, as they say.
Wed Dec 30, 2020, 02:24 PM
Dec 2020

To think we're one bad day at the Extreme Court from losing what's left of abortion rights here.

It would be back to the 19th century: comfy house calls for wealthy women; back rooms for all other women.

Judi Lynn

(160,530 posts)
2. Great news! Argentina has distinguished itself as a progressive, civilized country. Hooray! 🎆🎇❤️️
Wed Dec 30, 2020, 09:09 AM
Dec 2020

Let's hope the leftover fascists in Argentina will not be strong enough to create any serious threat, as they do here.

Congratulations to an admirable administration with President Alberto Fernández, and a healthy, civilized, progressive citizenry.

Thank you, sandensea!

sandensea

(21,635 posts)
6. You bet, Judi. Fernandez took a big chance - as abortion rights aren't exactly popular there
Wed Dec 30, 2020, 02:17 PM
Dec 2020

Polls usually show a 25-50-25 split in Argentina:

Around 25% in favor of abortion being legal on demand (this bill grants that, up to the 14th week)

Around 50%, in "certain circumstances" (this varies greatly from voter to voter)

And around 25%, illegal in all cases.

It was all the more courageous, given the litany of other challenges (Covid, the 'Macrisis', 44% poverty, etc.) - and coming just 10 months before key mid-term elections.

Macri, as you might expect, was busy making phone calls to try to persuade fence-sitters to vote against this.

The most work he's no doubt done in years.

Thanks as always for your insights, Judi. And if I don't see you until then, Happy New Year!!

Judi Lynn

(160,530 posts)
16. It took having a pro-military dictatorship ultra-conservative President for one term to reveal them,
Wed Dec 30, 2020, 10:07 PM
Dec 2020

but Macri did bring the classist, racist, misogynist segment out from behind the trees and under the rocks there, just as it happened when Trump stole the Presidency for his own one term.

Those people wield a lot more power than they should. I think they do intimidate the normals while they drive the economies right back into the ditch after progressive Presidents restore balance. Looks as if there is a clear pattern which has announced itself in unmistakable terms, both in Argentina, and in the U.S.

To learn Macri is trying to do some arm-twisting from off-stage is really depressing. What a shame. He probably does still maintain power, as he worked hard, and deviously to amass it, with so many dedicated, destructive saboteurs as President. No doubt he is still coercing some powerful ones he bent to his will in the recent past.
t
That would make it even better for this progressive achievement, knowing what they had going against them beyond the conventional public views.

Oh, yeah, I just remembered hearing Macri is also in with those Catholic extremists like some of the worst ones in the US, like Justice Scalia! Right! Opus Dei. They are some brutal, hard-nosed, remorseless a-holes.

I could be since Macri still feels he needs to help direct the government from behind the scenes, he intends to take another shot at it, just like Trump.

True tyrants really intend to control, don't they?

Well, this victory for women is that much valuable, as it has been so hard to win, against angry, violent, misogyistic zealots. Good for all of them, and they must be allowed to keep it without goblins trying to steal it again, as they are doing here.

It's always a great step forward hearing your informed perceptions, deeper background on politics inside and outside this country. Very special, always.

Very best wishes for your New Year's celebration. So glad we can slam the door shut on 2020 tomorrow night. Can't wait!

It's OK if Trump goes away mad, we just want to see his backside waddling off for the last time.



Happy New Year's, sandensea! 🍻 🍸 🍹 🍷

sandensea

(21,635 posts)
18. Well, he certainly failed
Wed Dec 30, 2020, 11:56 PM
Dec 2020

Macri failed to persuade even one undecided/persuadable senator to vote against this.

My guess is that his 'Change' coalition just wishes he'd go off and retire in Miami or Sardinia.

Much as most GOP lawmakers wish Cheeto would do the same (though none will admit it!).

Which reminds me: it should be fun to see GOP congresscritters make fools of themselves on Jan. 6 trying to "overturn" Biden's election.

All that grandstanding and showboating, of course, can only mean one thing: what we'll actually be witnessing are the first round of auditions for the 2024 Republican nomination.

It'll be a real race to the right - and to the bottom.

Enjoy the show - and above all, Happiest of New Years! Best to you and yours, Judi.

Judi Lynn

(160,530 posts)
21. What a great post! You've given us an event to anticipate. A C-Span party, DU-wide! "Must See TV."
Thu Dec 31, 2020, 04:38 AM
Dec 2020

Maybe even set up drinking games for clearly memorable, mockable Trumpican behaviors.

Love your "real race" observation. Flawless.

January 6. Proud Bois will probably be crowding the visitors' gallery, their sweaty snouts proudly gleaming, unencumbered by masks.

They will probably wear their best kilts.



Happiest of all to you, sandensea!



Karma13612

(4,552 posts)
3. Welp,
Wed Dec 30, 2020, 09:44 AM
Dec 2020

When some of our stubborn backward state legislatures are successful in banning abortion at the moment of the heartbeat, then we know the women can go to Argentina for a nice holiday and a safe, legal abortion.

Good on Argentina! And good on Fernandez on his statement that Abortion is a public health problem. And “The rest is hypocrisy” is genius.


Nice to get a bit of sane news for once.

sandensea

(21,635 posts)
5. And as a pro-choice senator noted: 'if men could get pregnant, this would have been law decades ago'
Wed Dec 30, 2020, 02:09 PM
Dec 2020

If men could get pregnant, Lindsey Graham would have an abortionist on call!

He, and who knows how many other ultra-conservative Southern Repugs.

Judi Lynn

(160,530 posts)
8. Good one! Lindsey has thrown himself at the feet of John McCain and Trump already.
Wed Dec 30, 2020, 02:23 PM
Dec 2020

No one noticed him before that.

Didn't take him long to repudiate the faith and esteem McCain had for him. Guess he was only pretending!











Them was the days.



Buddies. Forever.

Judi Lynn

(160,530 posts)
12. Oh, wow! What creepy characters they've been, all this time!
Wed Dec 30, 2020, 04:22 PM
Dec 2020

Hoover looked like a cicada.



Roy Cohn as Igor in Dr. Frankenstein.



Can you imagine anyone wanting to be associated with any of those characters, then or now?

sandensea

(21,635 posts)
13. Mafiosi through and through
Wed Dec 30, 2020, 04:47 PM
Dec 2020

Cheeto - like his mentor Cohn, and his mentor J.E. Hoover - thinks the only way to get anything done is by way of blackmail, threats, or bribery.

All three, of course, were extremely blackmailable themselves - as Putin can attest (I suspect the "pee" tapes are actually incest tapes, pardon my French).

Macri was a lot like that as well - though at a lower level (but not for lack of trying). His extortion drove his own sister Sandra to her grave, on account of his digging up dirt against her ex-husband.

sandensea

(21,635 posts)
7. True. To think we're one bad day at the Extreme Court from losing what's left of these rights here.
Wed Dec 30, 2020, 02:21 PM
Dec 2020

In most Red States, as you know, abortion is virtually illegal already.

"Abortion numbers are coming down!" some bleach-blond congresscritter exulted not too long ago (might have been Marsha Blackburn).

Sure. Because more and more are being performed in back alleys.

IsItJustMe

(7,012 posts)
15. I am old enough to remember the days of coat hangers. It is truly disparaging.
Wed Dec 30, 2020, 09:21 PM
Dec 2020

I would think lots of woman are having to travel a long way now to other states. Of course Republicans are straight up hypocrites as is our SC. They are for state rights until they are against it. The two rulings that the SC have already overrode state's rights in NY and Colorado to allow religious super spreader events.

We will see what happens, but it don't look good. Strange days indeed.

sandensea

(21,635 posts)
19. Well said.
Thu Dec 31, 2020, 12:05 AM
Dec 2020

If Pubic Hair Thomas wanted to redeem himself in the least, he'd have a massive stroke sometime next year.

So many good people do after all - and most never did anything to anyone.

On a lighter note, Happy New Year! All the Best to you and yours for 2021.

IsItJustMe

(7,012 posts)
20. Thank you. You too.
Thu Dec 31, 2020, 12:17 AM
Dec 2020

I keep telling all I know, it's got to be better than the last one. And on the bright side, you never know when the universe will hand an unexpected gift.

sandensea

(21,635 posts)
14. Francis wasn't too happy about it - but he largely stayed in the sidelines
Wed Dec 30, 2020, 04:59 PM
Dec 2020

Why? Because he's very supportive of the current, center-left Alberto Fernández administration.

Francis knew that this was very important to Fernández - the first major-party Argentine presidential candidate to have included abortion rights as a campaign promise.

He was therefore reluctant to contribute to what would've been a significant legislative defeat, had this bill been voted down.

But not so Argentina's right-wingers!

They used all the same bad-faith talking points we hear from Repugs non-stop when it comes to abortion: it's murder; you're "killing a future Beethoven"; it's a Soros/Agenda 21 plot; they sell the fetuses; etc.

38 to 29 was pretty decisive though (after a 131/117 passage in the House). A good day for women's rights.

Latest Discussions»Latest Breaking News»Argentina Legalizes Abort...